Advertisement

Friday (Olympic beer and cigar controversy) edition: Wha' Happened?

Here's a tricky one.

February 26, 2010 at 2:42PM
(The Minnesota Star Tribune)
Advertisement
(The Minnesota Star Tribune)

The exuberance of youth, carrying beer and cigars, met the stuffiness of Olympic figureheads, wearing scowls and shaking their fingers at the alleged impropriety of it all.

Yes, that was the scene yesterday in Vancouver after Team Canada defeated Team USA 2-0 in the gold medal women's hockey game. The AP describes it thusly:

More than half an hour after they beat the United States 2-0 on Thursday, the players came back from the locker room and staged a party on ice — swigging from bottles of champagne, guzzling beer and smoking cigars.

In a sport that Canada invented, there was never an option besides gold, and with it finally in hand, the home team let loose.

Meghan Agosta and Marie-Philip Poulin posed wearing goofy grins. Rebecca Johnston actually tried to drive the ice-resurfacing machine. Haley Irwin poured champagne into the mouth of Tessa Bonhomme, gold medals swinging from both their necks.

The celebration raised eyebrows at the IOC, which said it would look into the matter. Informed of the antics by The Associated Press, Gilbert Felli, the IOC's executive director of the Olympic Games, said it was "not what we want to see."

"I don't think it's a good promotion of sport values," he said. "If they celebrate in the changing room, that's one thing, but not in public. We will investigate what happened."

Poulin, who scored both goals, doesn't turn 19 — legal drinking age in British Columbia — until next month. The drinking age in Alberta, where the Canadian team trains, is 18. Photos showed Poulin on the ice with a beer in her hand.

ADVERTISEMENT

OK, so the part about Poulin might be technically unsettling, seeing as how she could probably get into some sort of trouble for underage drinking. But the rest of it? C'mon. Organizations like the IOC (and NFL ... and NBA ...) have to learn that, in most cases, fans like to see players acting naturally instead of in some sort of pre-packaged, sterile way. You can't expect them to devote years of their lives to train for a sport and then react exactly how you want them to react once they experience the greatest moment of their playing careers.

The quote from the IOC director is overly administrative and galling in two ways. Keep in the locker room, he says. It's not a promotion of the sport's values. Huh? More like "don't shatter the facade that Olympic athletes are as innocent as a falling snowflake," which probably plays well with a large viewing demographic but is total garbage. Part of us wonders if there would even be a controversy if it was the men's hockey team instead of the women's team. Seriously, we don't usually like to hint at playing the sexism card, but we wonder in this case.

The second part of the quote makes us mad in any situation like this. Investigate? What is there to investigate? Everyone can see what happened. Everyone knows what happened, but now you are still trying to placate whoever incorrectly has their undies in a bunch by saying words that have no meaning. There will be no conclusion that, upon further review, these hockey players were coerced into their behavior by laser-wielding aliens. They partied on the ice because THEY WON THE GOLD [REDACTED] MEDAL. End of story, and good for them.

about the writer

about the writer

Michael Rand

Columnist / Reporter

Michael Rand is the Minnesota Star Tribune's Digital Sports Senior Writer and host/creator of the Daily Delivery podcast. In 25 years covering Minnesota sports at the Minnesota Star Tribune, he has seen just about everything (except, of course, a Vikings Super Bowl).

See Moreicon

More from Sports

See More
card image
Alex Kormann/The Minnesota Star Tribune

Centennial/Spring Lake Park and Hill-Murray will square off for the Class 2A title after winning their semifinals Friday at Grand Casino Arena.

card image
card image
Advertisement