Four is perfect number for College Football Playoff

There are two reasonable choices: Kill the bowl system and go to a full playoff; or, stick with drama of three elite match-ups to decide title.

January 18, 2015 at 6:53AM

More is less on many occasions in competitive sports. That will be case when the College Football Playoff decision-makers give in to pressure from the whiners and double the size of the field to eight, sooner rather than later.

This was the first year for the playoff, and it was a spectacular success with two semifinals on New Year's Day, followed by the title game played an exactly-right 11 days later.

The lone flaw in the whole thing was the completely phony ratings that the 12-person selection committee released on a weekly basis through the second half of the FBS schedule.

Now that we know those ratings were being manipulated to produce maximum attention for ESPN, we can get less worked up when a TCU randomly jumps an unbeaten Florida State some week next fall.

The "Power Five'' conferences, not the NCAA, call the shots for big-time football. This year, 49 of the 65 teams in those conferences played in bowl games. As long as the administrators and coaches remain committed to that system, then it's folly to expand the playoff field.

If you go to eight teams, there will be conference title games in early December, followed by the quarterfinals in mid-December, followed by semifinals on or around New Year's Day in two of the six involved bowls: Rose, Orange, Sugar, Cotton, Peach and Fiesta.

Which means, two out of every three years, you're telling the Rose Bowl promoters:

"We can't send you teams that finished in the top eight this year, but we have Boise State and the third-place team in the Big Ten for you. That will take care of the needs for the Grand Daddy of Them All, right?''

ADVERTISEMENT

And, oh, Pasadena: "We had our college football orgy with the four quarterfinals a couple of weeks ago, and the public won't be watching No. 11 vs. No. 16, even with your big parade beforehand.''

There are two choices: Kill the bowls and go to a full playoff system; or, continue to choose four teams with superb credentials and reap the reward of the nation's NFL-loving football fans actually being fascinated by three college matchups in a 1 ½-week period.

PLUS THREE FROM PATRICK

Reasons retiring commissioner Bud Selig should be forgiven here for baseball's contraction drama:

*Selig's push for increased revenue sharing made the Twins more viable financially and thus relevant in the 2000s.

*That revenue sharing and some spending rules ended the Yankees' dominance (four titles from 1996-2000) and led to reasonable competitive balance.

*Selig was persuasive behind-the-scenes in getting approval for Target Field, a ballpark for generations.

about the writer

about the writer

Patrick Reusse

Columnist

Patrick Reusse is a sports columnist who writes three columns per week.

See Moreicon

More from Gophers

See More
Minnesota running back Ky Thomas (8) runs away from West Virginia safety Alonzo Addae and safety Sean Mahone (29) during the first half of the Guaranteed Rate Bowl NCAA college football game Tuesday, Dec. 28, 2021, in Phoenix. (AP Photo/Rick Scuteri)
Rick Scuteri/The Associated Press

The game at Chase Field will be the first meeting between the Gophers and the Lobos.

card image
card image