Fed could do nothing to save Lehman, Bernanke says

He said he knew the investment bank's failure would be disastrous, but it was already too far gone to save.

September 3, 2010 at 1:12AM

WASHINGTON - Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke on Thursday strongly rejected as "myth" suggestions that he could have saved investment bank Lehman Brothers and prevented the near-collapse of the global financial system.

Former Lehman CEO Richard Fuld suggested Wednesday that the Fed could have given him a lifeline in September 2008 and spared the world the subsequent chaos. That view is wrong, Bernanke, a former Princeton economist, told the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission.

"Before I came to the Fed chairmanship, I was an academic, and I studied for many years the Great Depression, financial crises, and this is my bread and butter. And I believed deeply that if Lehman was allowed to fail or did fail that the consequences for the U.S. financial system and the U.S. economy would be catastrophic," Bernanke said. "And I never at any time wavered in my view that we should do absolutely everything possible to prevent the failure of Lehman."

The problem, he said, was that Lehman lacked the sufficient collateral to provide to the Fed for any loans it would have received. Lehman was under the modern equivalent of a bank run, where investment firms on the other end of deals with it simply refused to lend it any more money, pulled out of existing deals and demanded immediate repayment from it.

Bernanke's testimony provided the most detailed public accounting yet of how the Fed reached the decisions it made in a pivotal point in American financial history. Almost two years later, another Great Depression has been averted, but the damage to the structure of the nation's financial sector led to a deep and seemingly intractable downturn.

On the fateful weekend of Sept. 13-14, 2008, regulators concluded that Lehman was dead. It would be either be purchased at the last minute by the British bank Barclays or shuttered. Any government rescue effort amounted to a "Hail Mary" pass.

"The view was that failure was essentially certain in either case," the Fed chief testified.

Nearly two years after Lehman's bankruptcy on Sept. 15, 2008 -- the largest in U.S. history -- there are some who question why the Fed and other regulators rescued insurance giant American International Group days later, and them helped broker the sales of retail bank Wachovia to Wells Fargo, investment bank Merrill Lynch to Bank of America, and thrift Washington Mutual to J.P. Morgan Chase.

Bernanke apologized Thursday for not stating more clearly in congressional testimony days after Lehman's collapse that it was a dead man walking.

"This is my own fault, in a sense," Bernanke said.

Emphasizing Lehman's weakness so soon after the bank's failure "might have even reduced confidence further and led to a further pressure" in a stressed financial system, he said.

He added, "I regret not being more straightforward there, because clearly that ... has supported the mistaken impression that, in fact, we could have done something. We could not have done anything."

about the writer

about the writer

KEVIN G. HALL, McClatchy News Service

More from Business

See More
card image
Leila Navidi/The Minnesota Star Tribune

Following concerns that Medtronic was overspending on the high-tech system and not developing it fast enough, FDA clearance is a major victory for the Minnesota-run medtech company.

Hormel headquarters in Austin, MN. ] GLEN STUBBE * gstubbe@startribune.com Friday September 11, 2015 Despite woes throughout the food industry, partly due to consumers turning away some from processed foods, Hormel has managed to continue prospering -- even though a good part of its business -- Spam, chili -- is about as processed as you can get. But the company's turkey and pork offerings are riding a hot protein trend. And over the past two years, it's made some of the biggest acquisitions in
card image