Deer guards cut damage to Dakota County squad cars

The push bumper grill guards not only reduce the chance that a deputy will be hurt in a collision with a deer, but they also reduce the time a car is out of commission for repairs. At $300 each, they "paid for themselves immediately."

By JOY POWELL, Star Tribune

December 20, 2009 at 2:49PM
Deer guards are paying off for the Dakota County Sheriff's Office, which often paid thousands of dollars per cruiser each time one collided with a deer. The guards cost about $300, and protect the deputy's safety, as well as dramatically reduce repairs costs. The department has been using them for about three years.
Deer guards are paying off for the Dakota County Sheriff's Office, which often paid thousands of dollars per cruiser each time one collided with a deer. The guards cost about $300, and protect the deputy's safety, as well as dramatically reduce repairs costs. The department has been using them for about three years. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

With a flash of gray fur in the headlights, a deer bounded in front of the cruiser that Dakota County Sheriff's Deputy Sharon Drews was driving in rural Hampton Township recently.

The impact damaged the front end of her squad car; Drews was not hurt.

And the damage to the car was significantly reduced by push bumper grill guards that the department has installed on all marked patrol cars.

At a cost of about $300 apiece, the decision to buy them for the fleet came easy for the Sheriff's Office as it reviewed costs for such accidents, said Chief Deputy Dave Bellows. That was three years ago.

"We talked with our fleet folks, too, and they were telling us that prior to using these things, damage to a squad hitting a deer could be $6,000 to $8,000," he said. "These guards, when we've had a deer accident, have been reducing the damage to more in the $1,000 to $2,000 range. So clearly, these things paid for themselves immediately."

"It's unfortunate, but the areas that we drive are especially dangerous and plentiful with deer, and so it's not unusual in a given year that our deputies hit a couple, three deer," Bellows said.

The savings with the push bumpers and grills are not only significant monetarily, but also for cutting down the time when squad cars are out of commission for repairs, he said.

In southern Dakota County, 2009 appears to be one of the busiest in years for deer-vehicle collisions. So far, at least 68 such accidents have taken place in southern Dakota County. In 2004, for instance, there were just 33, Bellows said. The tally for all of last year was 50.

The development of suburbs and exurbs brings more roads, and so there are more deer on the roads causing accidents, Bellows said. Part of the problem is that the metro area has no natural predators or hunting in most areas that could help keep the deer population down, he said.

"The deer herd has been moderating or decreasing in most areas of Minnesota, except the metro area or southeast Minnesota," said Pat Hahn, information officer for the Minnesota Department of Public Safety.

While many deer-vehicle crashes go unreported, in the past three years, 9,820 deer-vehicle crashes were reported. Those included 18 deaths, and all but two involved motorcyclists who were killed.

Experts say motorcyclists should try to swerve around deer, but those driving bigger vehicles should not veer.

"If you encounter deer, brake and come to a controlled stop," said Nathan Bowie, spokesman for the Department of Public Safety. "It's safer to do that than it is to swerve, or veer, into oncoming traffic, or off the road."

Joy Powell • 952-882-9017

about the writer

about the writer

JOY POWELL, Star Tribune