CC Sabathia walked into Yankee Stadium's interview room with his left arm in a sling Friday, 16 hours after shuffling off the mound in pain following the 58,692nd and final pitch of his major league career.
That powerful left shoulder — which earned six All-Star appearances, the 2007 AL Cy Young Award and possibly a spot in the Hall of Fame — finally had given out.
"I think it's just kind of fitting," he said. "I threw until I couldn't anymore."
His burly body — 6-6 and at least 300 pounds — had echoed the decision he announced last winter.
No second thoughts about retirement following 19 major league seasons. No temptation for more, the 39-year-old explained to his wife.
"I told Amber last night that this was the best way for it to end for me because of the way I've been feeling, loving the bullpen, jogging out, feeling pretty good, I feel like about July of next year I'll be like, 'I think I can pitch,' " he said.
He dislocated a joint in his pitching shoulder during the eighth inning of New York's Game 4 loss to Houston on his 17th pitch, then pushed his arm through three more before the torment became too great. He was dropped from the Yankees' AL Championship Series roster Friday before Game 5 and replaced by righthander Ben Heller.
Sabathia said he will have a magnetic resonance imaging exam to determine whether he needs surgery.