Brady or Manning? It all depends on who you ask

February 22, 2010 at 4:57PM
New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady (12) throws a pass wide receiver Sam Aiken as running back Laurence Maroney (39) and Patriots offensive lineman Sebastian Vollmer (76) block during the third quarter of their NFL football game against the Tennessee Titans in Foxborough, Mass., Sunday afternoon, Oct. 18, 2009. Brady was 29 of 34 for 380 yards and six touchdowns in less than three quarters of play as the Patriots defeated the Titans 59-0.
Tom Brady and the Patriots face their old rivals, the Colts, on Sunday. (Associated Press/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

The NBC "Sunday Night Football" studio analysts were split during a conference call this week on which future Hall of Fame quarterback they prefer among the two who will compete in what should be another classic Colts-Patriots game on Sunday night.

Naturally, former Patriots safety Rodney Harrison took New England's Tom Brady, who is 7-3 against the Colts, including 2-1 in the postseason.

"[Colts quarterback] Peyton Manning is the best pure quarterback in the National Football League, but Tom Brady is my quarterback with a minute left and we're down four points and we need a touchdown," Harrison said. "Three Super Bowl rings, Super Bowl MVP, a guy whose preparation goes above and beyond anyone in that facility. It's not very often that you find Tom Brady not prepared or ready to go."

Supporting Manning, naturally, was Tony Dungy, the former Colts coach. Manning has won four of the past five meetings against the Patriots. He also has led the Colts (8-0) to 17 consecutive regular-season victories and needs to beat the Patriots (6-2) to tie the 2003-04 Patriots for the second-longest regular-season winning streak in NFL history.

"There is no other quarterback that I would want," Dungy said. "I've been with Peyton Manning for seven years. I've seen him prepare and I've seen what he does and how he's led our team. ... I can't imagine anybody running the offense and doing as much as Peyton does for the Colts."

Why the fumbles, Adrian? Vikings running back Adrian Peterson has fumbled 15 times and lost nine in 38 regular-season games. One third of the fumbles (five) and lost fumbles (three) have come in his past three meetings with a Lions team that was working on a 19-game losing streak.

With the Lions visiting the Metrodome on Sunday, I asked Peterson why the best back in the league gets the dropsies against the worst team in the league.

"I don't know," he said. "I really didn't think about it. Thanks."

Just a coincidence, then?

"I really don't feel like it's what those guys do, it's what I do," he said. "When I go back and look at my fumbles, it's more so when I'm reaching for yards or I got guys wrapping me up and I'm just scratching. It's my mentality. It's all on me to be more careful with the ball."

Tomlin 7-0 at home vs. AFC North The best division game of the week is in Pittsburgh, where the Steelers and Bengals match 6-2 records. A Steelers victory would give Mike Tomlin an 8-0 home record against his fellow AFC North teams.

It also would move him into a tie with Chan Gailey (Cowboys) and Chuck Knox (Los Angeles Rams) for the second-best start at home against division foes. The record is 9-0 by Raymond Berry (Patriots) and Steve Mariucci (49ers).

about the writer

about the writer

Mark Craig

Sports reporter

Mark Craig has covered the NFL nearly every year since Brett Favre was a rookie back in 1991. A sports writer since 1987, he is covering his 30th NFL season out of 37 years with the Canton (Ohio) Repository (1987-99) and the Star Tribune (1999-present).

See Moreicon

More from Minnesota Star Tribune

See More
card image
Provided/Sahan Journal

Family members and a lawyer say they have been blocked from access to the bedside of Bonfilia Sanchez Dominguez, while her husband was detained and shipped to Texas within 24 hours.

card image