A.J. Shepherd Logo


A.J. Shepherd

Thrift expert, blogger

Is Walmart Really Cheaper Than Cub?

I'm sure you've heard all the Walmart ads on TV, newspaper and even the radio, boasting about their lower food prices. They are even daring you to "take the test" and compare their prices against Cub Foods (which has the largest marketshare here in the Twin Cities). 

So, I decided to visit a neaby Cub Foods and then a Walmart store to compare the two. While this was not "scientific" study, it did give me a feel for the price differences. Who do you think was cheaper?

This is how I ran the test: I sampled 10 random items at each store that (I'm assuming) end up in a lot of shopper's carts. Of those, one was eliminated because I could not find the exact product at Cub. Also, I just matched - price to price - not including any coupons. I wanted the straight-up price for what I could get each item for - that day.

Here's what I discovered.

 Grocery Item  Walmart Price  Cub Price
 Ragu Chunky Garden Sauce (24 oz) $1.88  $2.29
 Kikkoman Soy Sauce (10 oz) 1.74  1.99 
Kraft Stove Top for Turkey (6 oz)  1.98 2.19 
Kraft Mac and Cheese (7.25 oz) 1.38  1.00 
Pace Picante Chunky Sauce Mild (24 oz)  2.48 3.39 
Betty Crocker Super Moist Lemon Mix (15.25 oz)  1.34 1.99 
Kelloggs Fruit Loops (8.7 oz)  2.50 2.50 
Diet Coke - 24 cans  5.98  5.99 
Ice Mountain Sport (23.7 oz)  4.98  5.00 
Totals $24.26 $26.34

So, according to my loose study - it appears as though Walmart is correct in their boast. I have to admit - I'm partial to Cub Foods - as I've grown up shopping the store and enjoy supporting a local, home-grown company.

While the price difference isn't huge - it could cause a few folks to turn their backs on Cub and shop Walmart from now on. 

Do you think the difference is enough to make the switch? Or do you have other factors (besides price) that factor into your choice of grocers?

Aaron writes at ThreeThriftyGuys.com - a personal finance site devoted to helping folks keep a few more bucks in their pockets (and purses).

Personal Finance Reading: Get More Done, Best Bank Accounts and Start a Budget

There are a lot of good personal finance sites out there right now. So we thought we'd bring you a round-up of some of our favorite posts from the past week.

Five Unique Money Personalities (Which are you?) Budgets Are Sexy
An interesting read about five different ways in which people handle money.

Class Consciousness and Social Mobility Get Rich Slowy
A discussion of class and how it plays a role in our lives.

America's Billion Dollar Baby Scam Frugal Dad
Through an infographic, see the baby industry in a whole new light.

Best Bank Accounts That Save You Money ChristianPF
A list of seven banking accounts that will put money back into your pocket.

Local Deals: Free Showerheads and More Pocket Your Dollars
From free admission to the zoo to low-flow shower heads - PYD has got you covered.

Start Small When Starting a Budget Northern Cheapskate
Creating a budget doesn't have to be overwhelming.

3 Productivity Apps to Help You Get More Done The Jenny Pincher
If you've got a smartphone, these tips will help you maximize your productivity.

Are there any other articles out there you are reading?

Aaron writes for ThreeThriftyGuys.com - a personal finance site devoted to helping you keep a few more bucks in your pocket.