Best ever from Minnesota: Joe Mauer or Lindsay Whalen? The voting continues

November 15, 2018 at 1:32PM
(Howard Sinker/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

After Twins star Joe Mauer announced his retirement, Star Tribune columnist Sid Hartman wrote "there is an argument to be made that the combination of Mauer's performance for the Twins and his performance as a prep athlete at Cretin-Derham Hall makes him the most successful athlete in state history."

That caused a stir on Twitter and some people pointed out that Hartman failed to mention Lindsay Whalen, the former Hutchinson High, Gophers and Lynx star who is currently coaching the U's women's basketball team.

Not wanting to spoil a good fight, we've posted a poll asking people to choose between Mauer and Whalen for that honor.

Early returns favored Mauer by about 60/40. By 6 a.m. Thursday, however, Whalen had taken a 55 percent to 45 percent lead with more than 1,700 votes cast overall. Was that an influx of votes from Hutchinson? Or basketball bots from Russia, where Whalen played for a couple of WNBA off-seasons?

We'll keep the poll open for another day so you can vote.

One thing, though: No recounts or lawsuits, please.

about the writer

about the writer

More from Sports

See More
Lakeville is moving its Area Learning Center, designed to help students who struggle academically or socially in high school, to a space within each high school in 2017 in an effort to save money and provide a variety of classes for students. Above: Lakeville South High School.
The Minnesota Star Tribune

With an investigation ongoing and the girls team's season over, Kurt Weber steps in to try to lead the boys team back to the state tournament.

card image
card image