A leaking relief valve at the water heater: why it's leaking and what to do about it

Water heaters come equipped with a temperature and pressure relief valve, also known as a TPRV. This valve allows water or steam to escape from the water heater if the temperature or pressure gets too high. This prevents a water heater from exploding or turning into a missile.

When a TPRV at a water heater leaks, it's usually a simple fix; just replace the valve. These valves cost less than $15 and replacing the valve is a basic job. There are plenty of videos on YouTube showing how to do this, and the whole project probably won't take more than fifteen minutes.

Unless it starts leaking again.

If you replace a TPRV and it starts leaking again, it probably means the valve is doing its job; it's relieving excess pressure. When this happens, the fix gets a little bit more involved, and some troubleshooting is in order.

The TPRV on a water heater is set to discharge at 150 PSI or 210° Fahrenheit. These numbers will be printed right on the valve, or on a tag attached to the valve. See below.

If a pressure relief valve for a boiler is accidentally installed on a water heater, it will leak like crazy from the start. These valves may look identical, but they're set to go off at 30 psi, not 150 psi.

If a new TPRV is properly installed and it still leaks, you probably have a pressure problem.

The easiest way to do this is to get a gauge with a garden hose thread, connect it to an outside garden hose faucet, and open up the faucet. If that's not an option, you can also use the hot or cold spigot for a washing machine. You should expect the pressure to be somewhere in the 40 – 80 PSI range with no other water running. If the pressure is over 80 PSI, it should be corrected. That's too high for your system. The solution is to have a pressure regulator installed. Get a plumber to do that, as they'll need to install an expansion tank at the same time. I'll come back to those in a minute.

If the pressure is within the acceptable range, you probably have an intermittent problem with excessive pressure that can be easily re-created. Go run a bunch of hot water at your plumbing fixtures until you've exhausted the hot water supply on your water heater, and keep running the water for another few minutes. If you have several fixtures open, this should only take about ten to fifteen minutes. Now stop running water at all of your fixtures and wait.

You've just replaced the hot water in your water heater with cold water, which will cause your water heater to run for a while. This will cause the water to expand significantly until the water heater thermostat is satisfied. That might take about an hour or two. In most situations, this water will expand back out through the cold water inlet, all the way back to the water supply coming into the house. The municipal water supply for the house acts as a gigantic expansion tank... and nobody notices. This is illustrated in the diagram below.

Your pressure gauge shouldn't change a bit while this happens. If the pressure increases with this test, however, you've made an important discovery. You have a closed system!

A closed system exists when water can't leave your house. One way for this to happen is to have a check valve installed on the water supply coming into the home. I don't see a lot of these in Minnesota, but I do see them periodically.

When a closed system exists on the water distribution piping in a home, an expansion tank needs to be installed somewhere on the plumbing system. This is a simple and straightforward fix; an expansion tank will give the water somewhere to go when it expands, and the TPRV on the water heater will stop causing problems.

Expansion tanks are required when a closed system exists, both by water heater manufacturers and by plumbing codes. The Minnesota State Plumbing Code requires an expansion tank when a pressure regulator is installed (608.2):

An approved expansion tank shall be installed in the cold water distribution piping downstream of each such regulator to prevent excessive pressure from developing due to thermal expansion and to maintain the pressure setting of the regulator.

Additionally, Section 608.3 requires an expansion tank when a check valve or backflow preventer is installed on the water supply line:

If an expansion tank is already installed and there is still a problem with excessive pressure, you have a problem with the expansion tank. I'll talk about expansion tanks in next week's blog post.