I'm not in the habit of mourning the loss of a series that lasted only 20 months and averaged about a half-million viewers. Truth be told, I came pretty close to not giving two hoots about Comedy Central's decision to ax "The Nightly Show With Larry Wilmore."
For most of the low-budget talker's run, I tuned in for only the first four minutes before switching to "Jimmy Kimmel Live," "The Late Show With Stephen Colbert" and, on days when I needed an unhealthy burst of optimism, "The Tonight Show With Jimmy Fallon."
Then came the political conventions. For two weeks, Wilmore challenged both parties (well, mostly the Republicans) with scathing commentary, unhinged field reports and panel discussions more penetrating than the overly rehearsed remarks spewing out of talking heads on cable news.
During the Democratic National Convention, he launched a hilarious "over-celebration" of Michelle Obama's speech and imagined how an ambitious Sen. Cory Booker, who had also addressed the Philadelphia crowd, might have secretly fumed. "She didn't just steal his thunder," Wilmore said. "She pulled up in a van and straight up jacked his thunder."
Wilmore's age — 54 — was considered a detriment when he got the assignment to replace Colbert in January 2015, but it turned out to be his secret weapon.
A few miles on the treadmill and a solid backup career as a show runner (he could have been running ABC's Emmy-nominated "Black-ish") meant Wilmore didn't treat the job like a make-or-break situation. He seemed less interested than his younger competitors in how the public would react, which may explain why he continued to press the Bill Cosby assault allegations long after the mainstream had moved on, and why he pulled out the "N" word at the White House Correspondents' Dinner, a bit he resurrected to kick off his final week on the air.
Fallon has party games. Kimmel has "Mean Tweets." Wilmore's signature piece? "The Unblackening," an unvarnished, nearly nightly examination of just how little progress we've made in race relations since putting an African-American in the White House.
The approach probably cost him. While "The Daily Show With Trevor Noah" has taken some critical hits — many of them unjust — it has seen an uptick in the ratings. Not so with "The Nightly Show." It never gained traction after taking over the 10:35 p.m. time slot from Colbert, who averaged 1.12 million viewers during his nine-year run. Wilmore drew 400,000 to 650,000.