Same sex marriage

  • Article by: ERIC BLACK and D.J. TICE , Star Tribune
  • Updated: June 6, 2006 - 11:30 AM

Questions and answers about the same-sex marriage issue

Q: What's the issue?

A: The Minnesota Legislature has for years been debating whether to put a proposed state constitutional amendment on the ballot for voters to approve or reject. It would ban same-sex marriage and other legal recognition for same-sex couples.

Q: Is it legal for same-sex couples to marry anywhere in America now?

A: Neither Congress nor any state legislature has authorized same-sex marriage. In the past decade, courts in Hawaii, Alaska, Vermont and Massachusetts have ruled that their state constitutions require equal treatment of same-sex and opposite sex couples on the marriage question.

In Hawaii and Alaska, the state constitutions were quickly amended to restore the same-sex marriage ban. Vermont and Connecticut have found a middle ground, establishing "civil unions" through which gay and lesbian couples can get all the state legal and financial benefits of married couples but reserving marriage for the union of a man and a woman.

Other states have moved in that direction, sometimes using terminology such as "domestic partners."

The big development driving the action in recent years was the November 2003 ruling by the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court striking down the state's ban on same-sex marriage. That court specifically ruled out the "civil unions" approach.

In the past few years, voters in 15 states have approved state constitutional amendments banning same sex marriage, bringing the total with such constitutional provisions to 19. At least seven more states have such votes scheduled this year and others, including Minnesota, are considering them.

Q: What's the status in Minnesota of same-sex marriage and civil unions?

A: Minnesota is one of 39 states that have adopted Defense of Marriage Acts (DOMAs), laws that specify that marriage can only be between one man and one woman. Minnesota did it in 1997. Congress in 1996 also passed a federal version of DOMA, which specified that federal benefits - for example, the right of a survivor to collect Social Security benefits based on the earnings of a deceased spouse, the right of a married couple to file joint income-tax returns, and more than 1,000 other benefits - would not be afforded to gay and lesbian couples.

Although much of the political action now is on a state level, the biggest stakes, in dollar terms at least, involve federal tax and benefit issues, which are unlikely to be affected by state constitutional amendments, court decisions or laws.

Minnesota does not recognize civil unions. In 2002, Gov. Jesse Ventura, sympathetic to gay rights, agreed to a contract with state employees that would have extended benefits such as family health insurance coverage to gay and lesbian partners of state employees. But the Legislature refused to ratify the contract, and it was renegotiated without the benefits.

Minneapolis has a domestic partnership registry through which some benefits and protections are afforded unmarried couples, including hospital visitation privileges, anti-discrimination rules, and benefits from many large city contractors.

Q: What would the proposed amendment to the Minnesota constitution do?

It would add this provision to the state constitution:

"Only the union of one man and one woman shall be valid or recognized as a marriage in Minnesota. Any other relationship shall not be recognized as a marriage or its legal equivalent."

The "legal equivalent" language would preclude future legislatures from adopting a civil unions-type law and prevent couples from enforcing civil unions here from other states. Amendment opponents fear that it also could be used to take away rights and benefits same sex couples already have, including benefits through private employers. Courts likely would have to interpret its meaning.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters