The theme of John Surma’s speech this week to the Economic Club of Minnesota was that the company he serves as CEO, US Steel Corp., has operated taconite mines a long time in the state and remains a major contributor to the economic vitality of northeastern Minnesota
It was a hardly controversial message, delivered by a genial CEO to a friendly audience.
There was an agenda, of course, if you listened for it. It turns out US Steel is frustrated with regulators.
“There just seems to be a lot more people involved,” Surma said after the speech, when asked about what’s changed in how his industry is regulated in Minnesota. “There seems to be a lot more discussion, and a lot more people who seem to want to be in a position to say no.”
There is a “lack of clarity” in the process as a result.
What also changed for US Steel is the presence of companies like PolyMet Mining Corp., which is seeking permits to begin production of copper, nickel and precious metals at its mine and processing facility at the eastern end the Mesabi Iron Range.
Behind PolyMet are other copper-nickel mining projects not as far along.
Mining for taconite is hardly a clean industry, but it’s had nothing close to the kind of problems that have cropped up with copper and nickel mining in other parts of the world. PolyMet has been grinding away on its permitting process for years.
Has greater environmental review of mining as a result of copper and nickel projects changed the dynamic for US Steel? Surma responded that copper and nickel mining was a different business and he wished those firms well.
US Steel, no matter how aggravated it becomes, obviously can’t move its mines. Short of a dramatic - and unlikely - contraction in North American steel demand, Surma said, there is not much that would cause US Steel to significantly reduce its level of investment in the state. About a quarter of the company’s $800 million capital budget this year will go to Minnesota.
On the other hand, there are choices that will come up someday, on where to build plants with newer technology or otherwise invest the company’s capital.
It was very subtle, but that message was delivered.
More from Star Tribune
More from Lee Schafer
There continues to be development after development in home delivery options for Twin Cities consumers.
The idea that Naming Rights deals mean that the Vikings principal owners are particularly gifted negotiators is just plain silly.
John Taylor, Stanford economist, came to Minneapolis to argue for a more stable and predictable monetary policy, including shrinking the size of the Fed's bloated balance sheet.
The Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis President went to Korea to talk about the benefits of higher government debt.
A recent report by the national firm CBRE highlighted 11 attractive Midwestern real estate markets, topped by Minneapolis. The thing is, Minneapolis rents are relatively low, which suggests rents could only be going up.
Recommended For You
Here's a quick look at the Vikings’ quarterback situation, under the assumption — and it is only an assumption — that Bridgewater is out of action for a while.
The quarterback was taken from Winter Park by ambulance. Asked if Bridgewater would play again this season, coach Mike Zimmer said, "It doesn't look good right now."
Hector Santiago's strong start was wasted as his teammates couldn't score as the Twins moved closer to a team-record losing streak.
National anthem protest brings out the worst in social media.
About 25 minutes into practice, Bridgewater dropped back in the pocket but crumpled to the turf, seemingly without being touched. Coach Mike Zimmer ended practice.
Recommended For You
Gov. Mark Dayton has pulled the plug on Essar Steel Minnesota's lucrative mineral leases on the Iron Range and turned to Cliff Natural Resources as a possible developer of the Nashwauk site.
Twin Metals eyes land near Boundary Waters.
There's a perception that the metro area doesn't understand.
Magnetation's Bovey plant is its second to go idle since April.
Iron Range elected officials, union representatives and miners told legislators Thursday about the struggles of the beleaguered region, which has seen 2,000 layoffs since last spring.