The baseball spun out of Brian Dozier’s glove before he could flip it to second base last Wednesday, and the batter and baserunner were both safe. Moments later, Dozier fielded Prince Fielder’s ground ball cleanly, but his throw pulled first baseman Chris Colabello off the bag.
And just like that, Dozier had experienced an incident that’s becoming as rare as hitting for the cycle, as unusual as a triple play: He committed two errors in one inning.
That’s hard to do in the modern major leagues, where the notion of tallying a fielder’s mistakes seems to be as out of date as polyester jerseys. The Twins, with 55 errors going into Friday’s game, are on pace to break the franchise record for fewest errors this season — 74 committed by the 2002 Twins — but it’s not just them. Errors are being recorded with record-breaking infrequency all around the majors.
American League teams are averaging .556 errors per game in 2013, and the Twins, charged with .437 per game, are markedly better than that. In 1999, teams were charged with .703 errors per game, so there’s been a 38 percent reduction from then. The skyrocketing number of strikeouts has something to do with it — there were 5,000 more strikeouts in the majors last year than a decade earlier, greatly cutting the number of batted balls to be fielded — but errors are way down even on balls put in play.
Around the majors, an error is committed on one in every 46.4 balls in play this year, well down from the one-in-38.5 rate of 1999.
There’s little doubt that better fielders playing with better equipment are likely responsible for the reduction in errors. But, face it: What’s the first factor that you think of?
“Everybody says it’s the scorer, no doubt,” said Stew Thornley, the baseball historian who, along with former Pioneer Press sportswriter Gregg Wong, serves as official scorer at Target Field. “I’m sure that’s the perception. We hear it all the time.”
It’s more than perception, however. Thornley is part of a three-scorer advisory committee that is attempting to standardize offical scoring in all ballparks. “Our objective is to make an error called in one park to be an error everywhere, so it’s a level playing field,” he said.
Thornley said baseball’s review process, which last year began allowing players to appeal a scorer’s ruling to Joe Torre, MLB’s executive vice president of baseball operations, has helped establish leaguewide guidelines. “When a call has been reversed, that helps me to understand what standard the league wants,” Thornley said.
Basically, MLB seems to rely on rule 10.05(a), which explains “the official scorer shall always give the batter the benefit of the doubt.” Thornley said his own standards of hit-or-error have changed on short-hop grounders; if the ball stays lows and a fielder bobbles it, it’s an error. “But if it comes up higher than you’d expect, that’s a really tough play to react to,” he said.
“When a ball drops between fielders, or when someone takes a bad route and makes what could have been an easier play much harder — it’s hard for fans to understand why we rule those hits,” Thornley said. “In a lot of cases, there’s no right or wrong call, but we have to acknowledge that the line between hit and error is always going to be fuzzy, not fine. We want to reduce that band of fuzziness.”
Last week, Justin Verlander threw 121 pitches in a 7-6 loss to the Twins, the fifth time he’s eclipsed 120 pitches — just against Minnesota — since the last Twins pitcher to reach that mark against anyone: Nick Blackburn, on May 24, 2011. In fact, an opposing starter has reached 120 pitches against the Twins 16 times since Blackburn’s long outing. But the Twins ask their starters to throw an extended number of pitches less often than most teams. A look at this year’s rankings, through Thursday:
Starts of 110 or more pitches: 1. Tigers 43, 2. White Sox 35, t3. Nationals 27, t3. Rangers 27, t24. Twins 8.
Starts of 115 or more pitches: 1. Tigers 17, 2. White Sox 15, 3. Rangers 13, 4. Red Sox 12, t26. Twins 1.
Most pitches thrown by a Twins starter:
151: Willie Banks, Aug. 14, 1993, no-decision
143: Rich Robertson, June 24, 1996, win
143: Frank Viola, June 13, 1989, no-decision
140: Scott Erickson, Sept. 18, 1993, loss
137: Jack Morris, Aug. 22, 1991, no-decision
136: Roy Smith, Aug. 12, 1989, win
136: Bert Blyleven, Sept. 28, 1988, loss
135: Frankie Rodriguez, June 9, 1996, win
135: Scott Erickson, Sept. 30, 1992, loss
Mike Moustakas (27 career at-bats) and Eric Hosmer (31 at-bats) of the Royals and Ryan Doumit (13 at-bats) of the Twins had never homered off Justin Verlander. Now they all have, in the space of five weeks, and all three shots were the deciding blows in Tigers losses.
It’s a sign that the former Cy Young and MVP winner remains a great pitcher but not the unhittable ace he was before his 30th birthday. Here’s another: Verlander’s 3.68 ERA is the highest of the four Detroit pitchers most likely to start in the postseason.
• • •
Chicago seemed to have the third pick in next June’s amateur draft, behind Houston and Miami, sewn up in mid-August. Then the White Sox went on a six-game winning streak, entering the weekend, and brought eight other teams, including the Twins, into the race.
The Cubs, Brewers, Angels, Phillies, Giants, Blue Jays, Padres, and yes, the Twins, are all within five games of securing that No. 3 pick.
• • •
Cleveland entered the weekend five games behind the Tigers and 2½ games out of a wild-card spot, but the Indians have an advantage they hope makes a big difference in September. In the Indians’ final 23 games, they will face the Mets, Astros, Twins and White Sox 17 times; they are 20-8 against those three AL teams so far, and 9-5 in interleague games.