Rand: The LeBron vs. Durant debate is already a classic one

  • Updated: January 29, 2014 - 7:46 PM
hide

Comparing LeBron James, left, and Kevin Durant is problematic because of differing ages, accomplishments and styles.

Photo: Sue Ogrocki • Associated Press file photo,

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

The Heat and Thunder played Wednesday night, and judging by the buildup, one might have thought this had never happened before (let alone happened in the NBA Finals a couple of years back).

It has suddenly become fashionable to pose this question: Who is better, LeBron James or Kevin Durant? Basically, it’s a challenge to the previous notion that James is the unquestioned best player in the NBA right now (and possibly the best player of all time).

It’s also one of those classic bar stool debates that ultimately proves to be unfair to both players and impossible to answer. Here is why:

• The players will never be in the same stage of their careers at the same time. Want to feel old? LeBron turns 30 in December. Durant, on the other hand, is four years younger. He is about at the point in his career where LeBron was during his final year with the Cavaliers. While it is certainly fun to watch them square off, they have different objectives.

• Because of that, it’s not only hard to measure them head-to-head, but also hard to define their accomplishments. Durant has reached the NBA Finals once, while James has made it four times (three with the Heat, once with the Cavs) and won two titles. But when James was 25, he had also made only one Finals appearance. If Durant doesn’t match James’ titles eventually while staying in Oklahoma City, does that make him inferior? Hardly, since James only got his rings when he hand-picked his team and supporting cast.

• They are completely different types of players. Durant is a deadly scorer who is nearly impossible to guard because of his height, range and quick release. While he is also a solid rebounder and is averaging a career-high 5.2 assists this season, he is primarily a scorer. James is a hybrid who can quite literally play all five positions. He, too, has worked to improve areas of his game, and he is nearly impossible to guard because of his power, vision and range of skills.

Trying to compare Durant and James might be fun, but any answer is elusive at best. Instead, let’s just enjoy two of the greatest players of all time and hope they have many more NBA duels to come.

Michael Rand

  • related content

  • FILE - In this Feb. 14, 2013, file phot, Oklahoma City Thunder forward Kevin Durant (35) shoots in front of Miami Heat forward LeBron James (6) during NBA basketball game in Oklahoma City, It's a matchup of perhaps the best two players in the NBA, when James and Durant square off on Wednesday night, Jan. 29, in Miami.(AP Photo/Sue Ogrocki, File)

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

ADVERTISEMENT

New England 7 2nd Qtr 9:47
Seattle 0
Miami 83 FINAL
Boston 75
LA Lakers 80 FINAL
New York 92
Arizona 3 FINAL
Montreal 2
St. Louis 4 FINAL
Washington 3
Nashville 4 FINAL
Pittsburgh 0
Minnesota 4 FINAL
Vancouver 2
Miami-Florida 54 FINAL
Florida State 55
Oakland 96 FINAL
Youngstown St 80
Cincinnati 46 FINAL
East Carolina 50
Michigan 66 FINAL
Michigan State 76
Marist 75 FINAL
Canisius 67
Fordham 77 FINAL
Dayton 101
Manhattan 87 FINAL
Monmouth 76
Quinnipiac 100 FINAL
Niagara 105
Utah 67 FINAL
USC 39
Connecticut 68 FINAL
Houston 70
California 90 FINAL
Washington 88
North Dakota St 64 FINAL
Western Ill 62
Penn State 65 FINAL
(22) Rutgers 76
(14) Texas 59 FINAL
TCU 64
Coll of Charleston 49 FINAL
Towson 71
Cornell 53 FINAL
Yale 60
Xavier 68 FINAL
Providence 57
Drexel 61 FINAL
UNC-Wilmington 44
Stony Brook 60 FINAL
New Hampshire 52
Maine 52 FINAL
Albany 44
Miami-Florida 66 FINAL
Pittsburgh 81
(21) Georgia 72 FINAL
(10) Kentucky 80
Arizona 69 FINAL
Colorado 81
Wake Forest 63 FINAL
(4) Notre Dame 92
Loyola-Chicago 56 FINAL
Illinois State 72
(24) Oklahoma 69 FINAL
West Virginia 78
St Johns 73 FINAL
Seton Hall 78
Delaware 73 FINAL
Hofstra 62
Binghamton 49 FINAL
UMass Lowell 66
Vermont 49 FINAL
Hartford 60
William & Mary 72 FINAL
Northeastern 66
Boston College 60 FINAL
(16) North Carolina 72
Virginia 77 FINAL
Clemson 72
(2) Connecticut 83 FINAL
Temple 49
Arkansas 53 FINAL
Alabama 42
Virginia Tech 71 FINAL
Georgia Tech 79
Kansas 58 FINAL
(3) Baylor 66
Canisius 51 FINAL
Rider 52
Monmouth 52 FINAL
Fairfield 54
Quinnipiac 81 FINAL
Saint Peters 50
Butler 55 FINAL
Creighton 62
Wichita State 61 FINAL
Drake 64
Evansville 52 FINAL
Indiana State 67
(18) Miss State 67 FINAL
(6) Tennessee 79
Villanova 47 FINAL
DePaul 49
Georgetown 73 FINAL
Marquette 80
North Texas 55 FINAL
Rice 58
Auburn 45 FINAL
(12) Texas A&M 78
(11) Arizona State 58 FINAL
Utah 48
Missouri State 56 FINAL
Northern Iowa 64
Michigan 60 FINAL
(15) Nebraska 75
Minnesota 49 FINAL
Northwestern 70
Wisconsin 73 FINAL
Illinois 62
Bradley 59 FINAL
Southern Ill 76
Florida 67 FINAL
Vanderbilt 58
(20) Iowa 88 FINAL
(5) Maryland 93
(1) South Carolina 77 FINAL
Ole Miss 59
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: How should Timberwolves fans greet Kevin Love on Saturday?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close