Scoggins: NHL stalemate might be deal-breaker, even for diehard fans

  • Article by: CHIP SCOGGINS , Star Tribune
  • Updated: December 7, 2012 - 9:01 PM

Lockout is splintering a fan base the NHL can't afford to chase away.

  • share

    email

Josh Petzel coaches Pee Wee hockey in the suburbs, plays in four adult leagues, spends a boatload of money on hockey sticks and other equipment every year and has shared Wild season tickets the past five seasons.

The guy is a hockey nut. He's also fed up with the ongoing NHL lockout, so much so that he called his buddies and told them that he's no longer interested in splitting Wild tickets with them.

Instead, Petzel is using that money to remodel his kitchen and get new appliances.

"[The lockout] basically just emotionally depleted me on this situation," said Petzel, managing partner of Cara Irish Pubs.

He's not alone. Mendota Heights resident Tom Graves purchased Wild season tickets the first day they went on sale after the organization came into existence. Graves and his wife have talked about canceling them because they're frustrated by the labor stalemate and they've found other things to do. They go to movies, enjoy eating out and attend Gophers hockey games now.

"We're definitely finding things to fill our time," Graves said. "Honestly, it's kind of nice to have some money to use for other things, too."

Both Petzel and Graves admittedly are hockey diehards, which should scare the NHL and players union into resolving their differences pronto. If the diehards are moving on, imagine the indifference among fringe or casual fans who don't require much push to turn elsewhere. The NHL can't afford that.

Friday marked the lockout's 83rd day, and the two sides were forced to regroup after an amateurish display that elevated the anger level tenfold and revealed a maddening disconnect between the participants. It's both incomprehensible and comical that players union chief Donald Fehr would call a news conference Thursday night to declare an end to the lockout was near, only to return moments later and announce the league had pulled its proposal off the table by voice mail.

Neither side is free of blame. That's never the case in these labor situations, and this dispute has dissolved into a stare-down between two egomaniacs, Fehr and NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman, who is now overseeing his third lockout.

However they achieve compromise, the two sides are foolish if they think their sport is popular enough that fans will return in flocks, even in this self-described state of hockey. Hockey fans, by nature, are loyal and passionate. They shell out big bucks to buy replica jerseys and attend games on Tuesday night in the dead of winter. Though frustrated and angry now, those diehards likely will return once the puck drops again.

But unlike the NFL's recent lockout, the NHL is not embraced by the masses to the degree that it can expect to avoid substantial losses at the ticket office. They don't have a massive TV deal. Hockey doesn't lead "SportsCenter." Outside of Canada, the sport's popularity doesn't rank high on the pecking order.

It's almost as if the lockout has created an out-of-sight-out-of-mind attitude toward hockey. Anger eventually goes away. Indifference is harder to change.

"There's going to be people that will stay away because they're just turned off," Graves said. "There will be other people who will want to come back, too. For me, I'll probably come back, but I know it's not going to be with open arms and with as much excitement as I had."

Some NHL teams already have difficulty selling tickets and attracting fans under normal circumstances. Good luck doing so now. Even the Wild has struggled to fill Xcel Energy Center on a regular basis the past two seasons. And any momentum the Wild created among casual fans with the summer signings of Zach Parise and Ryan Suter has vanished. Remember those July 4 fireworks? Poof, gone.

Maybe that excitement will return if the season is salvaged. But maybe not. The league undoubtedly will go to great lengths to thank fans for their patience and loyalty. Those self-serving gestures will probably fall on deaf ears.

"I'm going to watch the games on TV and I'm going to continue to read everything I can," Petzel said. "But the conscious decision I'm going to make is, I'm not going to put one dollar towards it."

Shawn Larson held Wild season tickets since the team's second season but canceled them two weeks ago. He doesn't blame the Wild necessarily, but "it's the whole process that's disheartening. This is the second [lockout] we've been through as season ticket holders."

Larson loves hockey though, and he admits he'll eventually return.

"I don't want to totally say no because that will probably make me a hypocrite," he said. "But I can't tell you how long it will take."

Chip Scoggins ascoggins@startribune.com

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions
  • share

    email

ADVERTISEMENT

Cincinnati 3:30 PM
Houston
Minnesota 7:00 PM
Green Bay
Indianapolis 1/6/13 12:00 PM
Baltimore
Seattle 1/6/13 3:30 PM
Washington
Cleveland 106 FINAL
Charlotte 104
Brooklyn 115 FINAL
Washington 113
Sacramento 105 FINAL
Toronto 96
Atlanta 84 FINAL
Detroit 85
Chicago 96 FINAL
Miami 89
Indiana 75 FINAL
Boston 94
Philadelphia 85 FINAL
Oklahoma City 109
Portland 86 FINAL
Memphis 84
Houston 115 FINAL
Milwaukee 101
Utah 87 FINAL
Phoenix 80
LA Lakers 102 FINAL
LA Clippers 107
TX A&M-CC 57 FINAL
Sam Houston St 61
Yale 61 FINAL
Holy Cross 54
Manhattan 55 FINAL
Saint Peters 53
Iona 66 FINAL
Siena 62
George Washington 41 FINAL
Georgia 52
Brown 47 FINAL
Rhode Island 59
Cleveland State 50 FINAL
Valparaiso 74
Rider 65 FINAL
Loyola-Maryland 71
Wofford 48 FINAL
Tulane 62
Savannah State 59 FINAL
Saint Louis 67
Memphis 85 FINAL
Tennessee 80
Texas Southern 57 FINAL
Alcorn State 48
Grambling St 56 FINAL
Alabama State 69
Jackson State 87 FINAL
Alabama A&M 88
Prairie View 45 FINAL
Southern U 50
Fordham 68 FINAL
Ole Miss 95
(5) Oregon 35 FINAL
(7) Kansas State 17
(10) Texas A&M 41 FINAL
(12) Oklahoma 13
Pittsburgh 12:00 PM
Ole Miss
(25) Kent State 1/6/13 8:00 PM
Arkansas State
(2) Alabama 1/7/13 7:30 PM
(1) Notre Dame
Siena 62 FINAL
Canisius 65
Fordham 71 FINAL
American Univ 50
TX A&M-CC 46 FINAL
Sam Houston St 65
Jackson State 48 FINAL
Alabama A&M 66
Grambling 60 FINAL
Alabama State 68
Texas Southern 61 FINAL
Alcorn State 45
Prairie View 55 FINAL
Southern U 60
Navy 59 FINAL
Richmond 65
Youngstown St 58 FINAL
VA Commonwealth 45
Temple 58 FINAL
Howard 61
Loyola-Maryland 54 FINAL
Fairfield 64
Iona 76 FINAL
Niagara 65
UCF 59 FINAL
Bowling Green 56
Marist 62 FINAL
Rider 47
Bradley 54 FINAL
Indiana State 55
Northern Iowa 41 FINAL
Illinois State 72
(7) California 55 FINAL
Utah 50
SD Mines & Tech 53 FINAL
Colorado State 97
USC 56 FINAL
Oregon State 55
(16) UCLA 89 FINAL
Oregon 80
Arizona 71 FINAL
Washington St 65
Arizona State 74 FINAL
Washington 77
(4) Stanford 57 FINAL
(20) Colorado 40

Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Who did the best coaching job in Minnesota sports in 2012?

Weekly Question
 
Close