Matt Vensel is in his first year at the Star Tribune after covering the Ravens for the Baltimore Sun for six years. He is a Pittsburgh native and a Penn State grad. Follow him at @mattvensel.
Mark Craig has covered the NFL for 23 years, and the Vikings since 2003 for the Star Tribune. He is one of 44 Pro Football Hall of Fame selectors. Follow him at @markcraignfl.
Master Tesfatsion is the Star Tribune’s digital Vikings writer. He is a 2013 graduate of Arizona State and worked for mlb.com before arriving in Minneapolis. Follow him at @masterstrib.
Josh Freeman’s debut as Vikings quarterback was an utter failure.
Freeman was under pressure most of the night, but was missing receivers all night, and threw a crucial interception as the Vikings lost to the Giants 23-7 on Monday in the Meadowlands.
Freeman was 20-for-53 for 190 yards and no touchdowns and a 40.6 passer rating as the Vikings fell to 1-5.
Adrian Peterson had the sixth-lowest rushing total of his NFL career with only 28 yards on 13 carries.
Eli Manning passed for 200 yards and a touchdown for the Giants.
Key player: Marcus Sherels
The Vikings return man and backup cornerback scored the second touchdown of his career on an 86-yard punt return in the first half.
But in the third quarter, Sherels missed an interception chance and, on the following play, fumbled the ball away on a punt return although he was untouched, setting up a Giants touchdown.
Sherels’ punt return was the third longest in team history, behind a 98-yarder by Charlie West in 1968 and a 91-yarder by Nate Burleson in 2004. It gave the Vikings a 7-3 lead. Sherels has two career punt return TDs, tying the team record held by David Palmer and Mewelde Moore.
But Sherels’ fumble was costly. The Giants led 10-7 in the third quarter, and Sherels fielded Steve Weatherford’s kick at his own 10. He stumbled ahead to the 13, but lost the ball when he hit the ground, untouched, and the Giants eventually recovered the bouncing ball at the 3. Peyton Hillis scored two plays later on a 1-yard run.
The Giants have a 10-7 halftime lead over the Vikings thanks to a 24-yard touchdown pass from Eli Manning to Rueben Randle midway through the second quarter.
The Good: Marcus Sherels’ 86-yard punt return for a touchdown gave the Vikings a 7-3 lead late in the first quarter. It was the 13th punt return touchdown in Vikings history. Sherels tied David Palmer and Mewelde Moore in the team record books for most career punt return TDs, with his second. The 86-yarder was the third longest in team history. Charlie West had a 98-yarder in 1968 and Nate Burleson had a 91-yarder in 2004. It was the third punt return for a TD against the Giants this season.
The bad: Vikings rookie cornerback Xavier Rhodes had a rough first half. The Giants should have scored a touchdown on their first possession, but Manning overthrew Hakeem Nicks in the end zone from the 28-yard line. Rhodes got a late break on the play, and was clearly beaten. The Giants settled for a field goal and a 3-0 lead. The nine-minute, 36-second drive was the longest drive by time in the NFL this season.
Rhodes was called for pass interference on a third-down play to keep a Giants drive alive in the second quarter. Randle scored on the next play, beating Chris Cook.
The ugly: Vikings running back Adrian Peterson has 9 yards on eight carries, and quarterback Josh Freeman is 7 of 16 for 74 yards.
Former Giants defensive end and New Jersey native Justin Trattou returns to MetLife Stadium tonight to do something he never expected to be doing two weeks ago: Helping extend the Giants’ winless start to the 2013 season.
“Definitely a strange turn of events,” said Trattou, who signed with the Vikings on Oct. 9.
Trattou joined the Giants as a undrafted rookie out of Florida in 2011. He played six games with one tackle in 2011, spent 2012 on injured reserve and played five games with three more tackles before being released two weeks ago.
Trattou was on the Vikings roster for last week’s loss to Carolina, but was inactive. His game-day contribution against the Giants wasn’t expected to match what he was able to do while helping the Vikings’ defensive coaches prepare the game plan.
“Yeah, I won’t answer that one,” Trattou said with a smile when asked how he was able to help the coaches prepare for the Giants.
Asked what was wrong with Giants two-time Super Bowl MVP Eli Manning, who has 17 of the team’s NFL-high 23 turnovers, Trattou said, “I have no idea what goes on over on the offensive side of the ball, but obviously turnovers has been a major problem for them. But Eli is a good player. We’ve all seen that. But you can’t fight through turnovers, at least not the number of turnovers they’ve had this year.”
Perhaps Trattou will bring the Vikings some good luck. The 6-foot-4, 255-pounder won a New Jersey state title with Don Bosco Preparatory High School, a BCS national championship alongside Percy Harvin and the rest of the Gators in 2009 and a Super Bowl title as a rookie with the Giants in 2011.
The Vikings signed defensive end Brian Robison to a four-year contract extension Wednesday for reportedly $13 million in guaranteed money.
Robison, who is in his seventh season with the team, is in the final year of a three-year deal he signed in 2011. He elected to sign during the season and forego free agency.
"I think in any player’s mind, anytime you have an opportunity to hit free agency, it creates a little bit of excitement," Robison said. "But after me and my family sat down and talked about things, we realize there’s not a whole lot of guys in the league that get to start their career in one place and end their career in one place. This is an opportunity for me to do that"
The team gave Robison an opportunity to start in 2011 by signing him to a $14.1 million deal, which included a $6.5 million signing bonus.
"That deal, to me, was an opportunity to be a starter and an opportunity to prove myself in this league," Robison said. "I was able to do that. I’m not going to sit here and toot my horn. I’m just very thankful to the Vikings for giving me that opportunity."
The Vikings rank last in the NFL in pass defense, allowing 326 yards per game. They are tied for first in touchdown passes allowed with 10.
In Sunday's 34-27 victory against Pittsburgh in London, the Vikings two best corners were rookie Xavier Rhodes and Marcus Sherels, who made the team primarily as a punt returner.
Chris Cook did not play because of a groin injury, Josh Robinson continued to struggle and A.J. Jefferson got zero snaps on defense, playing strictly on special teams.
Their cornerback situation is a mess right now and you wonder if Leslie Frazier and his staff won't use the bye to consider personnel changes.
Many fans would welcome the return of Antoin Winfield. Short of that, one logical move would be to replace Robinson with Rhodes as the starter at left cornerback, and possibly slide Sherels into that slot/nickel role.
Rhodes has been the team's best corner through four games. But in Cook's absence, Frazier's staff has resisted moving Rhodes to the right side. Instead, they started Sherels at right cornerback against Pittsburgh with Robinson starting on the left side.
Even if Cook returns next week against Carolina, you wonder how long the coacing staff will stick with Robinson. Until this point, Frazier has said he prefers to keep Rhodes as the outside corner in the nickel package, noting that Rhodes gets plenty of snaps because the Vikings use their nickel so often.
Rhodes has played in 71 percent of the team's snaps this season. But Robinson looks lost right now. According to Pro Football Focus, he has allowed 91.9 percent of passes thrown his direction to be completed for 377 yards.
Robinson also was called for a 48-yard pass interference penalty on Pittsburgh's opening drive of the second half that gave the Steelers the ball at the 1-yard line.
"He’s had some struggles, in particular inside playing the nickel position," Frazier said. "That’s been a challenge for him with all the things we ask that position to do. He’s had some good moments and he’s had some moments I’m sure he looks back at the end of the four weeks and said, ‘Man, I can do that better,’ and we think he will. We knew going in this offseason and even in training camp that there were going to be some moments that we would have to work through and we’re experiencing some of that, but he’s doing some good things as well."
Frazier was asked if the staff will consider moving Rhodes into the starting lineup because of Robinson's struggles.
"Xavier is doing some good things," Frazier said. "He is playing a lot in our nickel package which almost equates to being a starter with the number of snaps you get. We’ll see how he continues to progress. Josh has had some ups and downs, but we think he’s going to get better. We’ll evaluate that coming out of the bye as well."
Rhodes made a mistake on Pittsburgh's final drive. He went for an interception on a pass to Jerricho Cotchery and missed, which led to a 36-yard catch and run.
"If he makes that play the game is over," Frazier said. "I like the aggressiveness. We worked on that play, he anticipated, he was there and came up a little bit short. You like to believe if we’re in that situation again, as he gains more experience, he’s going to make that play. You don’t want to stifle that aggressiveness at the corner. The fact that he had enough gumption to go try it, that’s a good thing. But if you don’t make the interception, you have to make the tackle. You can’t do both. But he’ll learn from it and fortunately we survived it. That’s part of some youth in the secondary."
|Vikings (3945)||People (1)|
|AFC (93)||Bears (487)|
|Ex-Vikings (50)||Football on TV (53)|
|Lions (377)||NFC (1405)|
|NFL draft (293)||NFL post-season (28)|
|Packers (533)||Super Bowl (285)|
|Vikings coaches (83)||Vikings defense (261)|
|Vikings fans (119)||Vikings injury report (293)|
|Vikings management (32)||Vikings off the field (283)|
|Vikings offense (371)||Vikings quarterbacks (262)|
|Vikings road games (77)||Vikings rookies (38)|
|Vikings roster moves (41)||Vikings special teams (40)|
|Vikings training camp (143)||Injury report (351)|
|Off the field (148)||On the road (88)|
|Quarterbacks (372)||Rookies (94)|
|Roster moves (19)||Vikings draft (275)|
|Vikings trade talk (2)||Vikings players (815)|
|Adrian Peterson (1005)||Anthony Herrera (161)|
|Antoine Winfield (412)||Ben Leber (97)|
|Bernard Berrian (213)||Bobby Wade (16)|
|Brad Childress (643)||Brett Favre (812)|
|Brian Robison (180)||Bryant McKinnie (107)|
|Cedric Griffin (194)||Chad Greenway (226)|
|Chester Taylor (79)||Chris Kluwe (127)|
|Darrell Bevell (120)||E.J. Henderson (184)|
|Heath Farwell (50)||Jared Allen (427)|
|John Sullivan (215)||Kevin Williams (243)|
|Leslie Frazier (940)||Madieu Williams (78)|
|Pat Williams (156)||Percy Harvin (684)|
|Phil Loadholt (169)||Ray Edwards (173)|
|Ryan Longwell (145)||Sage Rosenfels (102)|
|Sidney Rice (273)||Steve Hutchinson (192)|
|Tarvaris Jackson (173)||Tyrell Johnson (152)|
|Visanthe Shiancoe (216)||Brad Childress (647)|
|Darrell Bevell (121)||Leslie Frazier (949)|