$400 million Downtown East deal is left hanging amid a legal challenge

  • Article by: ERIC ROPER , Star Tribune
  • Updated: December 13, 2013 - 5:47 AM

Judge weighs suit over projects adjacent to new Vikings stadium.


Downtown East

What: The Yard, a new park in the heart of the emerging Downtown East area, would link the new Vikings States stadium and the downtown core.

Where: The two blocks between Park and 5th Avenues S. and 4th and 5th Streets S.

The plan: City officials hope to build a million square feet of office space, more than 300 housing units and retail space on two blocks. The city would be responsible for, among other things, borrowing $65 million to help build the parking ramp and park. (Source: Star Tribune)

Photo: Rayn Companies,

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

The fate of one of the largest development deals in Minneapolis history — a $400 million plan to transform land next to the new Vikings stadium — is in the hands of a Hennepin County judge who heard a last-minute legal challenge Thursday.

The lawsuit could prove perilous to the development if Judge Mel Dickstein agrees with plaintiffs when he reaches a decision, expected next week. The City Council is on track to give the project final approval Friday morning.

Ryan Cos. has proposed building more than 1 million square feet of office space for presumed occupant Wells Fargo, as well as apartments and retail, on land currently owned by the Star Tribune. The city has agreed to borrow up to $65 million to build an adjacent parking ramp and nearly two-block public park.

The suit, which seeks an injunction, claims that the city is violating spending limits of the Vikings stadium legislation by paying extra for the parking and parkland, both of which were required in that bill. The stadium legislation limited the city’s stadium contribution to $150 million, in addition to an estimated $189 million to operate the stadium over 30 years.

The city attorney’s office stressed Thursday that the deal could crumble. Ryan’s agreement to buy the Star Tribune land expires Dec. 27, which is also Wells Fargo’s deadline for Ryan to finalize the project.

“The whole thing can and may well fall apart because of delay,” City Attorney Susan Segal told the court.

Representatives of the city, Ryan Cos. and the Star Tribune gathered in a downtown courtroom Thursday, less than 24 hours after the lawsuit was announced. They were joined by the three plaintiffs: former City Council President Paul Ostrow, software executive and city Audit Committee member Stephanie Woodruff and Planning Commission member Dan Cohen — a City Council president in the 1960s. Cohen and Woodruff ran for mayor earlier this year, and Ostrow was Woodruff’s campaign manager.

Ostrow, who is also an Anoka County prosecutor, noted that the stadium bill explicitly includes parking in the definition of stadium costs. The bill requires 2,000 stalls of parking near the stadium, most of which will be satisfied by the new ramp.

“This is critical because the cap on the state and city contributions was a very significant and integral part of this legislation,” Ostrow said.

Deputy City Attorney Peter Ginder argued that the parking ramp and park were spurred by the Ryan development, rather than the stadium. He said they are unrelated to the stadium legislation.

“This is not a stadium deal. This is not a stadium parking lot, per se,” Ginder said. He added: “I suggest the court does not need to look at the stadium legislation at all.”

But the Minnesota Sports Facilities Authority, which is overseeing stadium construction, must sign off on the project because it’s committing $16.3 million for one-third of the parking ramp. The authority is also paying $10.3 million for skyways. Both come from a budget made up of city, state and Vikings funds intended for stadium-related construction.

Ostrow argued that the team should be covering costs beyond the public dollars the Legislature authorized for the stadium. “The obligation to build this ramp is clearly and unambiguously the responsibility of the Minnesota Vikings,” he said.

The mayor’s office has pointed to another section of the stadium legislation, which says the “city may make expenditures or grants for other costs incidental and necessary to further the purposes of” the legislation. Ostrow countered that this language was not intended to override the $150 million cap for stadium-related costs.

Ostrow and plaintiffs also challenged whether the city has the ability to develop a park under its charter and whether city officials were appropriately invoking Port Authority powers to execute the deal. City finance officials have said the Port Authority power merely adds financial flexibility, but it also reduces the number of votes necessary for passage and bypasses the city’s semi-independent Board of Estimate and Taxation.

“There are rights that are lost, procedures that are bypassed by using the Port Authority,” Ostrow said.

Unlike the polarizing Vikings stadium vote, the City Council has remained largely unanimous in support of the Ryan project. Its final vote on the deal is expected at the council’s last meeting of the year on Friday, which is also when the Sports Authority’s vote is expected.

Key components still hang in the balance, such as presumed tenant Wells Fargo’s commitment to buy the office towers. Ryan Vice President Rick Collins said Dec. 27 is their final contingency date in the agreement with Wells Fargo, after which the company “may have to move on.”

  • related content

  • Vikings stadium section: The game plan

    Friday May 10, 2013

    The latest news on the construction of the new Vikings stadium in downtown Minneapolis. It's set to open in the fall of 2016.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


Cleveland - LP: T. House 1 FINAL
Detroit - WP: A. Simon 4
Chicago Cubs 0 Postponed
Cincinnati 0
Kansas City 0 Postponed
Chicago WSox 0
Houston - WP: S. Feldman 9 FINAL
Oakland - LP: K. Graveman 3
NY Mets - WP: M. Harvey 8 FINAL
NY Yankees - LP: C. Sabathia 2
Washington - LP: S. Strasburg 0 FINAL
Miami - WP: T. Koehler 8
Toronto - LP: B. Cecil 2 FINAL
Tampa Bay - WP: E. Frieri 4
Atlanta - WP: S. Miller 5 FINAL
Philadelphia - LP: D. Buchanan 2
Boston 3 Top 10th Inning
Baltimore 3
St. Louis 5 Bottom 8th Inning
Milwaukee 0
Pittsburgh 1 Top 6th Inning
Arizona 1
San Francisco 2 Bottom 5th Inning
Colorado 2
Los Angeles 6 Bottom 3rd Inning
San Diego 3
Texas 0 Bottom 2nd Inning
LA Angels 0
Minnesota 1 Top 2nd Inning
Seattle 2
Atlanta 83 FINAL
Brooklyn 91
Chicago 90 FINAL
Milwaukee 92
Golden State 80 3rd Qtr 5:14
New Orleans 62
Memphis 9:30 PM
Washington 1 FINAL
NY Islanders 3
Detroit 4 FINAL
Tampa Bay 0
Nashville 3 2nd Prd 9:41
Chicago 3
Vancouver 3 1st Prd 1:47
Calgary 1
Philadelphia 1 FINAL
Columbus 4
Real Salt Lake 0 FINAL
New England 4
Sporting Kansas City 1 2nd Half
Houston 2
D.C. 9:30 PM
Vancouver FC
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters






question of the day

Poll: Where will Adrian Peterson be playing in 2015?

Weekly Question