Facebook Twitter Mobile alerts

Home | Sports | Access Vikings

Is Allen that "one player away from a title" signing? No

Even though the Vikings gave up a lot to get him, it is unrealistic to consider Jared Allen one player who can lift them to a championship. That job description will always fall on the quarterback's shoulders -- in this case, on Tarvaris Jackson's.

Last update: April 23, 2008 - 1:20 PM

For the past week, the Vikings have been making a bold proclamation: We are one player away.

The original announcement came by way of Air Wilf, the private jet that transported one of the NFL's top players to the Twin Cities last Thursday. Upon arrival, the Vikings spent 48 hours showcasing the franchise to the player and his girlfriend.

Tuesday night, the Vikings finalized an agreement to acquire that player, doling out the largest contract in team history along with three high draft choices.

Generally speaking, such a commitment is reserved for a team that otherwise considers itself ready to challenge for a championship.

It is also the kind of value normally placed on a quarterback, the single most critical position in professional sports.

Jared Allen, of course, is no quarterback. True, he plays the critical defensive end position. And yes, finding a star defensive end might be more difficult than getting an elite quarterback.

But even though the Vikings gave up a first-round draft pick and two third-round selections to the Kansas City Chiefs -- while also agreeing to give Allen a $74 million contract that includes more than $31 million guaranteed -- it is unfair and unrealistic to consider him that one player who can lift them to a championship. That job description will always fall on the quarterback's shoulders -- in this case, on Tarvaris Jackson's.

So in reality, here is what the Vikings were thinking Tuesday night: Tarvaris Jackson will be good enough in 2008 that we feel comfortable making an enormous investment toward winning the Super Bowl right now.

This thought is not exactly groundbreaking. Two credible NFL observers expressed similar hesitation earlier Tuesday, before the trade was finalized.

"That division is up for grabs," said former San Francisco and Detroit coach Steve Mariucci, now an NFL Network analyst. "Without [Brett] Favre in Green Bay, anyone can win the division. The Vikings are putting a pretty darn good football team together. They need their quarterback to play well. If he's better than last year, which he should be, they have a chance to win that division. Jared would be another piece of the puzzle."

Meanwhile, during an ESPN conference call, "Monday Night Football" analyst Ron Jaworski acknowledged Allen would be a "huge boost" for the Vikings defense and said they "are definitely going in the right direction."

Later, reporter Chris Mortensen asked Jaworski if he thought Jackson was ready to take the Vikings to the championship -- or if they should pass on the Allen trade and select a quarterback in the first round of the draft.

"[Jackson] is not there yet," Jaworski said. "He has a ways to go. But I think if you take a step back and go with a young quarterback, now you're looking at a further development at the quarterback position."

This is neither a diminution of Allen's expected impact nor a gratuitous shot at Jackson. It's a simply a reality check, a reminder that there is only one transcendent position in football. And it's not defensive end.

To be sure, the Vikings undoubtedly have built a strong team around Jackson. Allen's arrival gives the Vikings a potentially elite defense, one that we know can stop the run and now should be significantly more effective against the pass.

On offense, the Vikings have given Jackson an accomplished receiver in Bernard Berrian to stretch the field. Versatile fullback Thomas Tapeh will block for the NFL's most explosive running back in Adrian Peterson, and the offensive line returns all five starters for the first time since 2004.

Jackson has been hard at work all offseason, working on his decision-making and learning to avoid turnovers. After his second-half improvement last season (82.9 rating, accounting for nine touchdowns over the final seven games), it's reasonable to count on additional progress in 2008.

Will it be enough to put his team on a short list of Super Bowl contenders? The Vikings think so. Otherwise, they wouldn't have mortgaged their future, and their bank account, on their most expensive player acquisition since the Herschel Walker trade in 1989.

Allen is the type of player who can help turn a good team into a great one. But make no mistake: If the Vikings win the Super Bowl any time soon, that one player must be Jackson.

Staff Writer Judd Zulgad contributed to this report. Kevin Seifert • kseifert@startribune.com.

Recent Access Vikings stories

AP IMPACT: Nearly a fifth of 160 NFL players asked said they hid effects of concussions - April 23, 2008
AP IMPACT: Nearly a fifth of 160 NFL players asked said they hid effects of concussions - Washington Redskins kick returner Rock Cartwright remembers his brain "shaking like a bell" when he was walloped in a game against the New York Giants a few years ago. More

Comments are temporarily unavailable

Our reader comments feature is currently undergoing maintenance. Please check back to comment on this story and join the discussion. We apologize for any inconvenience.
Subscribe

Win tickets and gear: This week’s prize is a $100 gift card to Vikings Locker Room team store.Enter now!

Play Upick’em: Join our weekly contest. It’s fun and free, and you can win prizes. Play now!

Meet Grand Prize winner Kay and her friends! Plus view all entries from our Fanatical Football Fan contest! Go now!

see all StarTribune.com contests >>


Date/Opponent Time W L Score
Sep 13 - at Cleveland 12:00 PM1034-20
Sep 20 - at Detroit 12:00 PM2027-13
Sep 27 - vs. San Francisco 12:00 PM3027-24
Oct 5 - vs. Green Bay 7:30 PM4030-23
Oct 11 - at St. Louis 12:00 PM5038-10
Oct 18 - vs. Baltimore 12:00 PM6033-31
Oct 25 - at Pittsburgh 12:00 PM6117-27
Nov 1 - at Green Bay 3:15 PM7138-26
Open     
Nov 15 - vs. Detroit 12:00 PM8127-10
Nov 22 - vs. Seattle 12:00 PM9135-9
Nov 29 - vs. Chicago 3:15 PM   
Dec 6 - at Arizona 3:15 PM   
Dec 13 - vs. Cincinnati 12:00 PM   
Dec 20 - at Carolina 7:20 PM   
Dec 28 - at Chicago 7:30 PM   
Jan 3 - vs. NY Giants 12:00 PM   

© 2009 Star Tribune. All rights reserved.

Contact UsAbout UsTerms of Service
Privacy PolicyMember CenterAdvertise

Powered by Clickability