Replacement refs: Officials of a different stripe

  • Article by: KENT YOUNGBLOOD , Star Tribune
  • Updated: August 7, 2012 - 7:01 AM

Former NFL official Bernie Kukar fears the use of replacement officials for NFL games could prove damaging to the game.

hide

Replacement officials worked Sunday’s Hall of Fame exhibition game between the Arizona Cardinals and New Orleans in Canton, Ohio, with few problems. However, former NFL official Bernie Kukar said he believes the speed of the game will lead to mistakes being made if replacements are used when the regular season begins.

Photo: Gene J. Puskar, Associated Press

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

Bernie Kukar expects problems if replacement officials continue to call NFL games.

This shouldn't come as a surprise on a divisive issue. And how you feel about the current state of officiating in the most popular league in North America depends on what side of the issue you're on.

Kukar, a Minnesota native, was an NFL official for 22 seasons, starting in 1984. He worked hundreds of games, including two Super Bowls. And when he looks at the folks the league has assembled to call games during the lockout of officials? He sees trouble.

"They've never seen an NFL game up-close, on the field," Kukar said. "The difference will be significant. That much is guaranteed. I hope this gets resolved, because I think there will be some big problems."

The lockout began when talks between the league and the NFL Referees Association on a new contract hit a stalemate. It is the first such lockout since 2001, when two preseason weeks and the opening weekend were called by replacement officials.

The lockout of 121 officials began June 3. Major issues appear to be their pensions, which were first frozen, then eliminated; and salaries, which officials would like to be on par with other major sports. The NFL has proposed a seven-year deal, and says a fifth-year official who earned $115,000 last season would earn $183,000 in the final year of the proposed contract. Commissioner Roger Goodell said negotiations were "ongoing."

Because a number of collegiate conference supervisors -- including the Big Ten's -- are former NFL officials, most Division I officials are not allowed to be a part of a replacement crew. That means teams have been assembled primarily from officials from the Arena League, or from lower college divisions.

To Kukar, it's too big a leap to expect from the officials.

"The speed of the game will be a big difference for these guys," he said. "It's just a huge difference.''

Safety issues raised

Not surprisingly, the NFLRA agrees. In a conference call with reporters weeks ago, union president Scott Green said he thought using replacement officials would pose a health risk for the league at a time when the NFL has been beset by player safety issues.

"If calls aren't being made there will probably be additional things going on out on the field and that potentially could lead to a lot of player-safety issues," Green said.

The Los Angeles Times reported that nine well-known former officials had refused to help train the new officials.

The league is downplaying safety and competency issues. While visiting Green Bay Packers training camp last week, Goodell said the new officials would be prepared and that player safety was a key part of their training.

In an official statement, the NFL said, "We have made substantial investments in training despite the efforts of the NFLRA to denigrate the replacements and disrupt the training process."

In Sunday's Hall of Fame game, there were a few mistakes, but no huge issues. The opening coin toss was incorrectly announced. Referee Craig Ochoa announced a play was under review when it wasn't. There was a problem spotting the ball after a punt and a penalty.

On Thursday night Shannon Eastin will become the first female to officiate an NFL game. She will be a line judge in Green Bay's preseason game at San Diego.

Minnesotan Josh Thurow, a teacher and coach at Minnehaha Academy and an official for MIAC games, has been placed on a crew. Replacement officials are not allowed to talk with the media.

Players weigh in

It appears one group not riled up about the situation is the players, who are more concerned with preparing for the season.

"I must say, I hope we have the best guys, the best guys you can possibly have," center John Sullivan said. "We've had incredible officials. They've done a great job. But we also understand circumstances. And the NFL is a business. So I'm sure the NFL will do everything they can to put the best guys out there with us. As a player? We're not really focused on that."

Former player Ben Leber, who will be part of the broadcast team for the Vikings preseason games, said he thought the replacement officials would go out of their way to protect the players, particularly quarterbacks.

"I think quarterbacks will truly be off-limits," he said. "I think any ticky-tack [hit] will be called. So it could affect the outcome of the games.''

Will the new officials be able to handle the speed of the game? Will they struggle to control the battles along the line of scrimmage? Leber suggested fans watch the play there, anticipating players will look to take advantage of the situation.

"It could be an opportunity for guys to work on some things, like defensive linemen holding up offensive linemen," Leber said. "Using two-hand hold techniques, letting linebackers skate by without being touched. Things like that, tricks of the trade pros are great at."

And player safety?

"That's a tough question," Kukar said. "Because, as you know, the league is running scared right now with that concussion business. ... You can't help but feel it could lead to problems on the field. These guys won't be used to the speed these players will have."

Kukar said that speed could make it difficult to know which hits are legal and which are not.

"Let's put it this way," Kukar said. "If I was a player, I'd be a little concerned."

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

ADVERTISEMENT

Philadelphia 12/20/14 3:30 PM
Washington
San Diego 12/20/14 7:25 PM
San Francisco
Minnesota 12/21/14 12:00 PM
Miami
Baltimore 12/21/14 12:00 PM
Houston
Detroit 12/21/14 12:00 PM
Chicago
Cleveland 12/21/14 12:00 PM
Carolina
Atlanta 12/21/14 12:00 PM
New Orleans
Green Bay 12/21/14 12:00 PM
Tampa Bay
Kansas City 12/21/14 12:00 PM
Pittsburgh
New England 12/21/14 12:00 PM
NY Jets
NY Giants 12/21/14 3:05 PM
St. Louis
Buffalo 12/21/14 3:25 PM
Oakland
Indianapolis 12/21/14 3:25 PM
Dallas
Seattle 12/21/14 7:30 PM
Arizona
Denver 12/22/14 7:30 PM
Cincinnati
Utah 70 3rd Qtr 3:11
Orlando 57
Charlotte 74 3rd Qtr 7:30
Philadelphia 53
Brooklyn 45 2nd Qtr 2:39
Cleveland 45
Washington 52 2nd Qtr 2:06
Miami 51
Minnesota 48 3rd Qtr
Boston 53
Toronto 52 3rd Qtr
Detroit 52
Chicago 20 2nd Qtr 12:00
Memphis 22
Portland 17 2nd Qtr
San Antonio 20
LA Clippers 8:00 PM
Denver
Oklahoma City 9:30 PM
LA Lakers
Tampa Bay 1 2nd Prd 3:40
New Jersey 2
Anaheim 0 2nd Prd 19:19
Ottawa 2
NY Islanders 1 2nd Prd 17:35
Detroit 1
Boston 0 1st Prd 5:34
Winnipeg 1
Dallas 8:00 PM
Calgary
Wilberforce 71 FINAL
Youngstown St 92
Jackson State 49 FINAL
Tulane 56
Siena 66 FINAL
Radford 76
Stillman 29 2nd Half 12:26
Alabama 47
Case Western Reserve 59 2nd Half 5:05
Bucknell 76
Niagara 34 2nd Half 13:23
Buffalo 54
SD Christian 46 FINAL
UC Santa Barbara 69
Concordia (MI) 52 2nd Half 8:43
Central Mich 79
Northern Ill 36 2nd Half 7:11
Dartmouth 42
North Florida 62 2nd Half 7:28
Florida A&M 43
Hiwassee 58 2nd Half 5:04
Gardner-Webb 84
Tennessee St 43 2nd Half 9:23
Hampton 49
NC A&T 38 2nd Half 10:55
Kent State 46
Central Penn College 55 2nd Half 7:52
Liberty 74
Eastern Ky 43 2nd Half 10:29
Miami-Florida 29
Northern Ky 64 2nd Half 5:57
Morehead State 48
Northern Ariz 43 2nd Half 6:30
Norfolk State 61
MD-Eastern Shore 35 2nd Half 5:52
Old Dominion 46
St Marys-CA 39 2nd Half 11:44
St Johns 33
Clemson 37 2nd Half 8:25
South Carolina 54
Tenn Tech 48 2nd Half 5:24
Tennessee 50
Washington-MD 39 2nd Half 4:19
William & Mary 77
Bethune-Cookman 24 2nd Half
Mercer 33
Furman 34 2nd Half
Fla Gulf Coast 38
South Dakota St 30 2nd Half 16:34
CS-Bakersfield 30
Milligan 19 1st Half 4:31
Lamar 31
LSU-Alexandria 19 1st Half 6:28
ULM 22
Southern Utah 9 1st Half 7:36
Loyola-Chicago 22
Chattanooga 14 1st Half 7:55
Middle Tennessee 16
Seattle 15 1st Half 10:09
Minnesota 22
Lipscomb 25 1st Half 0:51
Princeton 40
Winthrop 28 1st Half 6:01
SE Louisiana 29
Dickinson State 7 1st Half 8:13
North Dakota 15
New Orleans 16 1st Half 7:08
Southern Ill 17
TX-Pan American 8:00 PM
Creighton
Colorado State 8:00 PM
Denver
Alabama A&M 8:00 PM
Marquette
Ark-Pine Bluff 8:00 PM
Texas Tech
Eastern Wash 9:00 PM
California
Idaho State 9:05 PM
Utah State
Arizona 10:00 PM
Texas-El Paso
Hawaii 10:59 PM
Chaminade
Nevada 12/20/14 10:00 AM
Louisiana
Utah State 12/20/14 1:20 PM
Texas-El Paso
(23) Utah 12/20/14 2:30 PM
Colorado State
Western Mich 12/20/14 4:45 PM
Air Force
South Alabama 12/20/14 8:15 PM
Bowling Green
BYU 12/22/14 1:00 PM
Memphis
Marshall 12/23/14 5:00 PM
Northern Ill
Navy 12/23/14 8:30 PM
San Diego St
Central Mich 12/24/14 11:00 AM
Western Ky
Fresno State 12/24/14 7:00 PM
Rice
Illinois 12/26/14 12:00 PM
Louisiana Tech
Rutgers 12/26/14 3:30 PM
North Carolina
NC State 12/26/14 7:00 PM
UCF
Ohio Valley 33 FINAL
Youngstown St 84
East Tenn St 48 FINAL
UNC-Wilmington 61
Cal-Irvine 44 FINAL
Purdue 69
Campbell 63 FINAL
Stetson 76
Jacksonville St 70 FINAL
Charleston Southern 43
Louisiana 64 FINAL
Alcorn State 57
Denver 63 FINAL
Wright State 72
Blue Mountain 30 FINAL
Central Arkansas 71
Texas State 51 FINAL
Bethune-Cookman 40
Albany 62 FINAL
Pepperdine 36
TX-San Antonio 53 FINAL
Houston 56
Yale 66 FINAL
Bucknell 73
Northern Colorado 56 FINAL
Fla Gulf Coast 69
Belmont 86 FINAL
Mercer 83
Massachusetts 66 FINAL
Georgia State 71
George Mason 69 FINAL
Winthrop 57
Portland State 33 FINAL
Princeton 104
UCLA 71 FINAL
Samford 52
Mobile 30 FINAL
Alabama State 66
Nicholls 49 FINAL
Texas Tech 76
Toledo 65 FINAL
Nevada 56
UMass Lowell 48 FINAL
(13) Duke 95
St Marys-CA 30 2nd Half 9:00
Virginia 43
McNeese State 36 2nd Half 11:37
Rice 31
McMurry 43 2nd Half 4:35
Houston Baptist 57
NJIT 50 2nd Half 5:26
Seton Hall 69
(6) North Carolina 46 2nd Half 10:00
Maine 29
Lafayette 53 2nd Half 7:45
Stony Brook 49
Siena 58 2nd Half 2:53
Binghamton 47
Longwood 34 2nd Half 10:59
Clemson 51
Savannah State 33 2nd Half 9:23
Florida State 67
(19) Syracuse 62 2nd Half 6:02
(9) Baylor 60
Buffalo 43 2nd Half 11:15
Manhattan 29
Canisius 40 2nd Half 3:05
Michigan 77
Davidson 50 2nd Half 6:09
NC State 64
Northern Ky 50 2nd Half 7:34
Delaware 47
Saint Louis 32 2nd Half
Austin Peay 39
(25) DePaul 33 2nd Half
(2) Connecticut 53
Ohio U 32 2nd Half 20:00
La Salle 40
Florida Atlantic 19 1st Half 7:47
Long Beach St 24
Miami-Florida 4 1st Half 16:00
Tulane 8
Miss Valley St 14 1st Half 6:13
Memphis 20
Ark-Pine Bluff 17 1st Half 5:00
UAB 29
Bowling Green 23 1st Half 8:39
Illinois State 10
Arkansas State 24 1st Half 7:03
Missouri State 21
ULM 10 1st Half 6:58
Wichita State 25
(16) Oregon State 8:00 PM
Southern Ill
Utah Valley U 8:30 PM
Montana
Pacific 9:00 PM
New Mexico St
No Dakota State 9:00 PM
Cal State Fullerton
Utah State 9:00 PM
Sacramento St
Bethesda (CA) 9:00 PM
Fresno State
LSU 9:30 PM
UC Santa Barbara
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Date/Opponent Time W L Score
2014 preseason     
Aug 8 - vs. Oakland 7 pmX10-6
Aug 16 - vs. Arizona 7:30 pmX30-28
Aug 23 - at Kansas City 7 pmX30-12
Aug 28 - at Tennessee 7 pmX19-3
2014 regular season     
Sep 7 - at St. Louis NoonX34-6
Sep 14 - vs. New England NoonX30-7
Sep 21 - at New Orleans NoonX20-9
Sep 28 - vs. Atlanta 3:25 pmX41-28
Oct 2 - at Green Bay 7:25 pmX42-10
Oct 12 - vs. Detroit NoonX17-3
Oct 19 - at. Buffalo NoonX17-16
Oct 26 - at Tampa Bay NoonX19-13 ot
Nov 2 - vs. Washington NoonX29-26
Nov 9 - Bye
Nov 16 - at Chicago NoonX21-13
Nov. 23 - vs. Green Bay NoonX24-21
Nov. 30 - vs. Carolina NoonX31-13
Dec 7 - vs. NY Jets NoonX30-24 ot
Dec 14 - at Detroit 3:25 pmX16-14
Dec 21 - at Miami Noon
Dec 28 - vs. Chicago Noon

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Will Christian Ponder ever be a full-time starter in the NFL?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close