Joint efforts: Today's knee injuries aren't the career-enders of old

  • Article by: CHIP SCOGGINS , Star Tribune
  • Updated: July 17, 2012 - 2:19 PM

Medical advances mean today's knee injuries aren't the career-enders of old.


The Wolves suffered through plenty of injuries in the compressed NBA season, including a knee injury to starting point guard Ricky Rubio.

Photo: Marlin Levison, Star Tribune file

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

The play called for a reverse punt return, an odd decision since the Chicago Bears already held a comfortable lead on the New England Patriots in the 1985 Super Bowl. Bears returner Keith Ortego signaled a fair catch before deciding to hand the ball to Leslie Frazier, whose left foot got stuck in the Louisiana Superdome's turf.

Frazier's career was over.

He suffered extensive damage in his knee, the most severe being a torn anterior cruciate ligament, which required reconstructive surgery. He spent the following season on injured reserve for the Bears and then failed a physical in training camp in 1987. He accepted a tryout with the Philadelphia Eagles, but he wasn't the same player and retired.

"I just couldn't get my range of motion," Frazier said. "I couldn't sprint."

The Vikings coach reflected on his experience with ACL surgery an hour after witnessing All-Pro running back Adrian Peterson sprint up a steep hill abutting the team's practice field at the five-month mark of his ACL rehabilitation.

Frazier smiled and shook his head.

"It's a totally different procedure than when I had mine," he said. "It's no comparison. The cut on my knee looks a lot different than the cut on Adrian's knee."

Advances in technology and rehab protocol in ACL reconstruction the past two decades have improved the long-term prognosis for athletes and enabled them to return to competition significantly faster. A normal timeline for return from ACL surgery now is six to nine months, which is encouraging news for Twin Cities sports fans tracking the progress of three high-profile athletes in the midst of ACL rehab -- Peterson, Timberwolves point guard Ricky Rubio and Gophers forward Trevor Mbakwe.

Doctors note that ACL surgery and rehab vary by patient, but the injury has become so common that nearly 100,000 reconstructions are performed in the United States each year, according to medical literature. Athletes still view ACL surgery as a significant career setback that promises a long, arduous recovery process. Many also acknowledge that they didn't feel completely normal until their second full season after surgery. But medical improvements and overall awareness of the injury provide a much brighter outlook nowadays.

"You put the best technology with the most motivated person, you get some spectacular results," said Randy Twito, a HealthPartners Medical Group physician who practices at Regions Hospital.

Twito, a veteran surgeon, has witnessed the procedure's transformation over the years. One example: Previously, patients had their knee immobilized in a cast after surgery so that it would stiffen. Now, many patients awake from surgery with their knee in a machine that stimulates range of motion in order to avoid stiffness.

"It's such a perfect science now so they're efficient," Vikings head athletic trainer Eric Sugarman said.

Surgery advances

Dr. David Fischer, the Timberwolves' orthopedic surgeon since their inception, began performing ACL surgery in his practice in the late 1970s when, he notes, "we really didn't know much about this injury at all."

Surgery was performed on an open knee because arthroscopic technology was still developing. Surgeons experimented with different tissue grafts to replace the torn ligament, including synthetic material, allografts (donor tissue from a cadaver) and xenografts (animal tissue). Eventually, doctors found the most successful grafts come from the patient's own patellar tendon or hamstring tendon.

Advancements in science, technology and surgical techniques over the years made surgery less invasive. Doctors also gained a better understanding of the ideal placement of the graft inside the knee. Those improvements led to better results and more confidence that the knee could withstand physical punishment at the same force as preinjury.

Early postoperative protocol required the knee to be cast for at least a month to make sure it healed and stabilized. That, however, caused stiffness and atrophy and severely diminished range of motion, which never completely returned for many athletes.

"I was in that boat," said Frazier, who was in a cast for six weeks after surgery. "I got real stiff."

That side effect added months to the rehab timetable.

"You take [someone] out of a cast six weeks later and his leg looks like a toothpick," Sugarman said. "You take Adrian six weeks after his surgery, his quad is almost back to normal. They were at such a disadvantage that way."

Fischer credits Indianapolis-based Dr. Donald Shelbourne for revolutionizing ACL surgery and rehab protocol in the early 1990s. Shelbourne determined that an aggressive approach could accelerate the rehab timetable without jeopardizing the graft, according to Fischer.

"That was an observation that grew into what we have now," Fischer said.

Learning to wait

Now, rehab begins immediately after surgery. The goal is to improve range of motion and build strength in the knee while healing takes place. Doctors now also allow some lag time between injury and surgery -- typically a week to two weeks -- to let swelling subside and the knee to "calm down," said Moira Novak, the Gophers' director of athletic medicine who is overseeing Mbakwe's rehab.

"It used to be that a kid would tear an ACL on Saturday and we'd have him in Monday morning doing surgery," Novak said. "What we're finding is, even though you may have done surgery two weeks earlier than the next guy, the post-op response is a better response if you wait it out. At the moment it's injured, it's a very angry knee. It does not want to be assaulted again with surgery."

Rehab protocol is more layered and aggressive now, but athletic trainers caution that every individual is different, their timetables largely dependent on the scope of damage. For example, Peterson also tore his medial collateral ligament in addition to his ACL. Rubio suffered a torn ACL and lateral collateral ligament.

Mbakwe tore his ACL, MCL and suffered some articular cartilage damage that required a microfracture procedure.

"In terms of what we're doing with [Mbakwe] at the five-month mark versus what I would be doing with a person at five months with an uncomplicated ACL tear, it's different for sure," Novak said. "The earlier phase of his rehab was much slower."

Sugarman said athletic trainers "press the envelope" in their rehab approach, but they also realize there's a limit to the physical demands on the knee. The graft actually weakens around three to four months and becomes susceptible to reinjury if pushed too hard too soon.

"As an athletic trainer that's the scariest time because you know you're at your biggest risk," Sugarman said. "In my opinion, I don't think it's safe to put a guy out there before six months. It's too much stress. The body has to heal."

Time to heal

An occasional outlier patient will trim that timetable, but it's not recommended, even for elite athletes. Doctors have improved their understanding of biomechanics and the importance of proprioception (balance), but they haven't discovered a way to make the body heal faster.

"We hold our breath if somebody is going back out there in less than six months because of the biologic maturation process necessary," said noted surgeon Dr. Neal ElAttrache, who performed Tom Brady's reconstructive surgery. "So far, we've been able to really improve the technique, the actual anatomic placement of the graft to mimic the normal ACL. And we've been very good at regaining range of motion, strength and endurance."

Those advancements have prolonged careers and allowed athletes to return to action sooner. Of course, it's also beneficial, doctors note, if a patient possesses a genetic makeup in the highest percentile.

"We're operating on superior creatures physically," ElAttrache said. "It certainly helps a surgeon when you're operating on that kind of a canvas."

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


New England 2/1/15 5:30 PM
Milwaukee 59 3rd Qtr
Orlando 44
New York 49 3rd Qtr
Indiana 54
Denver 11 1st Qtr 4:24
Memphis 19
Chicago 9:30 PM
LA Lakers
Montreal 0 2nd Prd 18:08
NY Rangers 0
Winnipeg 2 2nd Prd 15:23
Philadelphia 3
Boston 2 2nd Prd 12:04
NY Islanders 0
Arizona 0 1st Prd :59
Toronto 1
Dallas 3 1st Prd 2:32
Ottawa 1
Detroit 1 1st Prd 1:30
Tampa Bay 1
Columbus 0 2nd Prd
Florida 0
Nashville 0 1st Prd 18:12
St. Louis 0
Minnesota 8:00 PM
Buffalo 8:30 PM
Anaheim 9:00 PM
San Jose
DePaul 72 FINAL
Providence 83
Michigan State 71 FINAL
Rutgers 51
Boston Univ 37 2nd Half
Army 32
Fla Atlantic 29 2nd Half 17:57
Charlotte 41
Youngstown St 26 2nd Half 17:55
Detroit 40
East Tenn St 36 2nd Half 13:42
Furman 37
Saint Louis 29 2nd Half 17:58
George Mason 34
USC Upstate 44 2nd Half
Jacksonville 34
High Point 33 2nd Half
Liberty 26
Central Conn St 38 2nd Half 10:41
Long Island 52
Western Ky 26 2nd Half 15:56
Louisiana Tech 41
Dayton 45 2nd Half 13:42
Massachusetts 48
Chattanooga 35 2nd Half 13:59
Mercer 44
Wofford 39 2nd Half 14:28
UNC Greensboro 31
Maryland 32 2nd Half 17:26
Ohio State 41
FIU 31 2nd Half 15:41
Old Dominion 41
Fair-Dickinson 34 2nd Half 16:30
Robert Morris 41
Mount St Marys 38 2nd Half 14:15
St Francis-NY 37
Bryant 39 2nd Half 15:32
St Francis-PA 47
Northern Ky 27 2nd Half
Stetson 37
Coll of Charleston 25 2nd Half 15:39
Towson 37
Western Carolina 45 2nd Half 18:42
Va Military 41
Sacred Heart 33 2nd Half
Wagner 30
Lipscomb 32 2nd Half 16:29
Fla Gulf Coast 44
Kennesaw St 32 2nd Half 15:40
North Florida 59
Appalachian St 16 1st Half 1:35
Ga Southern 31
Holy Cross 18 1st Half 2:00
Loyola-Maryland 19
Eastern Ill 22 1st Half 1:15
UT Martin 41
Jacksonville St 6 1st Half 15:13
Belmont 12
Connecticut 4 1st Half 14:38
Cincinnati 7
Rider 6 1st Half 16:25
Saint Peters 3
SIU Edwardsville 8 1st Half 12:56
SE Missouri St 7
Marshall 11 1st Half 14:42
Southern Miss 4
Tenn Tech 9 1st Half 12:37
Tennessee St 11
Middle Tennessee 5 1st Half 17:21
TX-San Antonio 7
Ill-Chicago 4 1st Half 15:16
Milwaukee 4
Weber State 4 1st Half 15:20
North Dakota 8
Denver 9 1st Half 15:56
North Dakota St 3
IUPU-Ft Wayne 8 1st Half 13:49
South Dakota 11
Louisiana 3 1st Half 16:47
South Alabama 4
Georgia State 7:15 PM
Ark-Little Rock 7:30 PM
Arkansas State
ULM 7:30 PM
Portland 8:00 PM
Kentucky 8:00 PM
Eastern Ky 8:00 PM
Murray State
UAB 8:00 PM
Texas-El Paso
Idaho State 8:00 PM
Northern Colorado
UMKC 8:00 PM
Grand Canyon
Chicago State 8:05 PM
Utah Valley U
Colorado 8:30 PM
Cal Poly 9:00 PM
UC Irvine
Hawaii 9:00 PM
Pepperdine 9:00 PM
Santa Clara 9:00 PM
San Diego
Utah 9:00 PM
UC Santa Barbara 9:00 PM
UC Davis
Montana 9:05 PM
Portland State
Montana State 9:05 PM
Sacramento St
Long Beach State 9:30 PM
Cal State Fullerton
Loyola Marymount 9:30 PM
St Marys-CA
San Francisco 10:00 PM
California 10:00 PM
Washington St
Louisiana 47 FINAL
South Alabama 57
Saint Josephs 51 FINAL
Saint Louis 52
Appalachian St 77 FINAL
Georgia Southern 74
Niagara 58 FINAL
Saint Peters 65
Old Dominion 80 FINAL
FIU 67
Southern Miss 65 FINAL
Marshall 67
Georgia State 45 FINAL
TX-Arlington 57
Ark-Little Rock 69 FINAL
Arkansas State 70
Troy 90
Pittsburgh 43 2nd Half 1:33
(17) Duke 61
(6) Tennessee 31 2nd Half 16:58
(10) Kentucky 34
(24) Oklahoma 38 2nd Half 16:50
(14) Texas 32
Nebraska Omaha 36 2nd Half 11:38
IUPU-Ft Wayne 45
UC-Riverside 39 2nd Half 18:51
CS-Northridge 32
Army 44 2nd Half 13:48
Boston U 21
New Orleans 26 2nd Half 11:46
Nicholls 43
Charlotte 32 2nd Half 18:51
Florida Atlantic 39
Towson 29 2nd Half 11:56
Delaware 46
Hofstra 35 2nd Half 20:00
Northeastern 25
New Hampshire 39 2nd Half 11:11
Maine 65
Albany 49 2nd Half 15:52
Vermont 32
Hartford 39 2nd Half 12:52
Stony Brook 43
UNC-Wilmington 54 2nd Half 10:16
William & Mary 40
Clemson 34 2nd Half 18:08
Wake Forest 34
Alabama 30 2nd Half 15:34
(1) South Carolina 48
(23) Syracuse 0 2nd Half 16:51
(8) Louisville 42
Missouri 37 2nd Half 18:23
Florida 31
Iona 45 2nd Half 11:32
Fairfield 56
Manhattan 17 2nd Half 15:54
Marist 48
NC State 51 2nd Half 11:03
Virginia 44
(4) Notre Dame 51 2nd Half 15:04
Virginia Tech 24
(22) Rutgers 30 2nd Half 15:56
Purdue 30
(5) Maryland 61 2nd Half 14:04
Michigan 48
Milwaukee 31 2nd Half 15:19
Cleveland State 37
Wright State 64 2nd Half 16:43
Oakland 51
Jacksonville 29 2nd Half 17:10
USC Upstate 34
North Florida 30 2nd Half 12:18
Kennesaw St 29
Stetson 25 2nd Half 15:21
Northern Ky 48
Loyola-Maryland 31 2nd Half 12:36
Holy Cross 30
Lamar 41 1st Half 3:41
Sam Houston St 30
Fla Gulf Coast 31 1st Half 1:37
Lipscomb 17
Incarnate Word 7:00 PM
McNeese State 7:00 PM
SE Louisiana
Vanderbilt 4 1st Half 15:9
(18) Miss State 4
IUPUI 7 1st Half 15:47
Western Ill 9
Abilene Christian 10 1st Half 14:51
Houston Baptist 6
Oral Roberts 2 1st Half 18:26
South Dakota St 4
Louisiana Tech 4 1st Half 15:58
Western Ky 10
TX-San Antonio 8 1st Half 14:20
Middle Tennessee 13
Texas-El Paso 5 1st Half 14:54
Auburn 0 1st Half 20:00
Arkansas 0
Grand Canyon 0 1st Half 20:00
Illinois 4 1st Half 18:00
(15) Nebraska 1
(20) Iowa 20 1st Half 13:09
Northwestern 15
Utah Valley U 0 1st Half 19:49
Chicago State 1
Green Bay 11 1st Half 13:33
Valparaiso 5
Ole Miss 8:00 PM
Portland State 8:00 PM
Sacramento St 8:00 PM
Montana State
North Dakota 8:00 PM
Weber State
Ohio State 8:00 PM
Northern Colorado 8:00 PM
Idaho State
BYU 9:00 PM
San Francisco
St Marys-CA 9:00 PM
Loyola Marymount
Pacific 9:00 PM
Cal-Irvine 9:00 PM
UC Santa Barbara
San Diego 9:00 PM
Santa Clara
UC Davis 9:00 PM
Cal Poly
Long Beach St 10:59 PM
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters



Date/Opponent Time W L Score
2014 preseason     
Aug 8 - vs. Oakland 7 pmX10-6
Aug 16 - vs. Arizona 7:30 pmX30-28
Aug 23 - at Kansas City 7 pmX30-12
Aug 28 - at Tennessee 7 pmX19-3
2014 regular season     
Sep 7 - at St. Louis NoonX34-6
Sep 14 - vs. New England NoonX30-7
Sep 21 - at New Orleans NoonX20-9
Sep 28 - vs. Atlanta 3:25 pmX41-28
Oct 2 - at Green Bay 7:25 pmX42-10
Oct 12 - vs. Detroit NoonX17-3
Oct 19 - at. Buffalo NoonX17-16
Oct 26 - at Tampa Bay NoonX19-13 ot
Nov 2 - vs. Washington NoonX29-26
Nov 9 - Bye
Nov 16 - at Chicago NoonX21-13
Nov. 23 - vs. Green Bay NoonX24-21
Nov. 30 - vs. Carolina NoonX31-13
Dec 7 - vs. NY Jets NoonX30-24 ot
Dec 14 - at Detroit 3:25 pmX16-14
Dec 21 - at Miami NoonX37-35
Dec 28 - vs. Chicago NoonX13-9




question of the day

Poll: Who will win the Super Bowl?

Weekly Question