NFL needs more than a quick fix for labor woes

  • Article by: MARK CRAIG , Star Tribune
  • Updated: April 5, 2011 - 11:10 PM

Fans are the losers in the legal sparring match between owners and players, but a winning outcome is possible.

Picking a side to root for is, frankly, impossible. Neither the NFL's owners, nor its players, are sympathetic billionaires and millionaires. So let's turn our attention to what's best for you -- the fan that both sides say they truly love but totally take for granted because they know you'll never close your wallet on them.

The league's legal fisticuffs continue Wednesday in St. Paul when U.S. District Judge Susan Richard Nelson hears the players' request for a preliminary injunction to end the owners' lockout while the Brady et al. vs. National Football League et al. antitrust lawsuit continues. If the players win, the lockout ends. If the owners win, the lockout continues.

Nelson isn't expected to rule from the bench, but her decision could come in a matter of days. The losing side likely will appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, where the fun would shift temporarily to St. Louis.

"I think if you're an NFL fan, you want the court to deny the injunction," said Matthew Cantor, a partner in the New York law firm Constantine Cannon and an antitrust law expert.

Fans starving for the lockout to end so free agency can begin might disagree. But Cantor said fans should ultimately want the owners and players to head back to the negotiating table and hammer out a new Collective Bargaining Agreement so there's labor peace heading into the 2011 season. Ending the lockout would embolden the players' resolve to avoid the negotiating table.

"I am so confident that there will be a 2011 season either way that as a fan, you want the lockout to continue because you'll see the players come back to the bargaining table," Cantor said. "With billions of dollars at stake, nobody is going to forgo a whole season."

In 2003, Cantor was on the lead counsel for the plaintiffs in a class-action antitrust lawsuit that led to several U.S. merchants and consumers winning a settlement of about $28 billion against Visa and MasterCard. The U.S. District Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit called it the largest antitrust settlement in history. So Cantor knows antitrust law the way Mel Kiper Jr. knows the draft.

Cantor believes Nelson has no legal basis to grant the players' request for a preliminary injunction. He said the players can't prove they're being irreparably harmed by the lockout.

"That's the first thing you have to prove in a preliminary injunction motion," Cantor said. "It means the plaintiffs can't be compensated by money damages later. Here, you have [players] who have contracts for stipulated amounts of money. For instance, Tom Brady, I think, is making $7.5 million a year. If he's locked out and the players are ultimately right when this gets to the jury, then Tom Brady will get treble damages, or three times $7.5 million per year for however many seasons he lost because of a lockout. That's a lot of money."

If the lockout is lifted, the labor struggle still could loom over the sport via the courtroom for years to come.

"A case like this, I think the fastest you'd get to a trial is about four years," Cantor said. He also said the legal bills would be at least $50 million and would approach "nine figures."

Let's go out on a limb and suggest that tab would ultimately be passed on to you, the fan, in the form of higher prices for tickets, parking, concessions, Personal Seat Licenses, etc. Who knows, considering the NFL's current leverage advantage over the fans, maybe teams can start charging restroom fees on game day.

There also should be concern about what Brady et al. could do to the NFL if the players prevail. The lawsuit challenges the most basic rules that ensure the competitive balance that is at the root of the league's unmatched popularity and profitability. The draft, franchise tags and the salary cap are among the rules that could be altered or eliminated.

A well-balanced sports fan would spend Wednesday enjoying coverage of the Masters' Par 3 contest and not worrying about the NFL. But if your NFL-obsessed mind is on Judge Nelson's courtroom, remember what's in your best interest long-term. An end to the lockout is a quick football fix. A continuation of the lockout provides the urgency for both sides to sit down and settle this thing once and for all.

Mark Craig • mcraig@startribune.com

  • ON THE NFL mark Craig

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

ADVERTISEMENT

New England 2/1/15 5:30 PM
Seattle
Detroit 2 1st Qtr 10:35
Philadelphia 4
Portland 5 1st Qtr 9:03
Cleveland 7
Sacramento 6:30 PM
Toronto
Boston 7:00 PM
Minnesota
Dallas 7:00 PM
Houston
Denver 7:00 PM
New Orleans
Brooklyn 7:00 PM
Atlanta
Oklahoma City 7:00 PM
New York
Charlotte 7:30 PM
San Antonio
LA Clippers 8:00 PM
Utah
Washington 9:30 PM
Phoenix
Toronto 6:30 PM
New Jersey
Pittsburgh 7:00 PM
Washington
Chicago 9:30 PM
Los Angeles
Temple 5 1st Half 15:40
UCF 3
Winthrop 8 1st Half 15:37
Coastal Carolina 9
Lafayette 4 1st Half 16:00
Colgate 7
Northeastern 6 1st Half 15:20
Drexel 5
Wake Forest 5 1st Half 15:48
Florida State 4
Rhode Island 6 1st Half 15:54
Fordham 9
Delaware 7 1st Half 15:18
James Madison 4
South Carolina 11 1st Half 14:40
LSU 13
New Hampshire 4 1st Half 16:35
Maine 0
Seton Hall 14 1st Half 12:45
Marquette 14
Binghamton 9 1st Half 15:58
UMBC 3
American Univ 10 1st Half 16:02
Navy 11
Elon 2 1st Half 15:04
UNC-Wilmington 13
Wright State 8 1st Half 15:00
Oakland 7
Minnesota 12 1st Half 13:41
Penn State 11
Duquesne 0 1st Half 19:20
Richmond 2
SMU 2 1st Half 14:14
South Florida 9
Hartford 6 1st Half 15:11
Stony Brook 4
Albany 3 1st Half 12:45
Vermont 6
Hofstra 5 1st Half 15:40
William & Mary 10
UNC-Asheville 6:00 PM
Longwood
Radford 6:30 PM
Char Southern
Holy Cross 0 Postponed
Loyola-Maryland 0
Duke 6:30 PM
Notre Dame
Texas Tech 6:30 PM
Oklahoma
Oregon State 7:00 PM
Arizona State
Morehead State 7:00 PM
Austin Peay
Drake 7:00 PM
Bradley
Lehigh 7:00 PM
Bucknell
Rice 7:00 PM
Houston
Missouri State 7:00 PM
Illinois State
Loyola-Chicago 7:00 PM
Wichita State
Nebraska Omaha 7:00 PM
South Dakota St
Northern Iowa 7:05 PM
Southern Ill
Louisville 8:00 PM
Boston College
St Johns 8:00 PM
Creighton
East Carolina 8:00 PM
Memphis
Georgia Tech 8:00 PM
Miami-Florida
Miss State 8:00 PM
Ole Miss
Clemson 8:00 PM
NC State
Indiana 8:00 PM
Purdue
Kansas 8:00 PM
TCU
Oregon 9:00 PM
Arizona
Air Force 9:00 PM
San Jose St
Stanford 10:00 PM
Washington
Rider 56 FINAL
Siena 49
Dayton 76 FINAL
Richmond 62
Eastern Kentucky 53 FINAL
Jacksonville St 73
Saint Josephs 0 Postponed
Saint Louis 0
UMBC 8 1st Half 15:31
Binghamton 6
Akron 6 1st Half 14:48
Ohio U 21
Ball State 14 1st Half 11:32
Miami-Ohio 8
Memphis 4 1st Half 15:37
Cincinnati 6
East Carolina 4 1st Half 16:29
(2) Connecticut 12
Murray State 11 1st Half 12:21
Eastern Illinois 16
Kent State 15 1st Half 13:23
Central Michigan 18
UT Martin 17 1st Half 12:28
Tennessee St 12
Eastern Michigan 0 1st Half 20:00
Western Mich 0
Bucknell 4 1st Half 18:40
Lehigh 2
Indiana 10 1st Half 13:35
Michigan State 9
Colgate 8 1st Half 16:29
Lafayette 5
Fordham 10 1st Half 14:19
Davidson 6
Duquesne 11 1st Half 15:05
St Bonaventure 0
George Mason 4 1st Half 17:34
VA Commonwealth 3
Detroit 8 1st Half 13:26
Youngstown St 9
Army 0 Postponed
Boston U 0
Loyola-Maryland 0 Postponed
Holy Cross 0
SMU 7:00 PM
Tulsa
Oklahoma St 7:00 PM
Kansas State
West Virginia 7:00 PM
Texas Tech
Denver 7:00 PM
South Dakota
Northwestern St 7:00 PM
Central Arkansas
Austin Peay 7:00 PM
SIU-Edwardsville
Kansas 7:00 PM
Iowa State
Bowling Green 7:00 PM
Northern Ill
Penn State 7:00 PM
Minnesota
San Jose St 8:00 PM
Air Force
Boise State 8:00 PM
Colorado State
Utah State 8:00 PM
Wyoming
San Diego State 9:00 PM
Fresno State
Nevada 9:00 PM
UNLV
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Date/Opponent Time W L Score
2014 preseason     
Aug 8 - vs. Oakland 7 pmX10-6
Aug 16 - vs. Arizona 7:30 pmX30-28
Aug 23 - at Kansas City 7 pmX30-12
Aug 28 - at Tennessee 7 pmX19-3
2014 regular season     
Sep 7 - at St. Louis NoonX34-6
Sep 14 - vs. New England NoonX30-7
Sep 21 - at New Orleans NoonX20-9
Sep 28 - vs. Atlanta 3:25 pmX41-28
Oct 2 - at Green Bay 7:25 pmX42-10
Oct 12 - vs. Detroit NoonX17-3
Oct 19 - at. Buffalo NoonX17-16
Oct 26 - at Tampa Bay NoonX19-13 ot
Nov 2 - vs. Washington NoonX29-26
Nov 9 - Bye
Nov 16 - at Chicago NoonX21-13
Nov. 23 - vs. Green Bay NoonX24-21
Nov. 30 - vs. Carolina NoonX31-13
Dec 7 - vs. NY Jets NoonX30-24 ot
Dec 14 - at Detroit 3:25 pmX16-14
Dec 21 - at Miami NoonX37-35
Dec 28 - vs. Chicago NoonX13-9

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Who will win the Super Bowl?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close