MLB Insider: On a collision course with Rule 7.13

  • Updated: August 30, 2014 - 8:31 PM

Protecting catchers has been achieved, but many are protesting the vagueness around the plate.

hide

Kurt Suzuki struck a now-familiar pose, reaching to his left to tag Cleveland’s Chris Dickerson during a July game. A new rule requires catchers to leave a sliding lane for runners.

Photo: JIM MONE • Associated Press,

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

When a runner rounds third and an outfielder throws the baseball home, Ron Gardenhire’s reaction is different than it used to be. No longer is he focused on the ball, or calculating how long it will take the baserunner to reach the plate. No, he’s watching the catcher’s feet.

“You have to really stare at every one,” Gardenhire said. “The biggest thing for me to remember is, ‘Where did the catcher set up?’ ”

That’s an adjustment caused by MLB Rule 7.13, a new policy intended to eliminate collisions at home plate. The new rule has worked in the most basic way — there have been no major collisions at the plate this season — but it has had additional consequences that make managers and players uncomfortable.

The rule has two parts: prohibiting a runner from going out of his way to knock over a catcher, a guideline that has been generally accepted; and prohibiting a catcher from blocking the plate before he receives the ball, a stipulation that has created huge controversy, some notable replay reversals and plenty of uncertainty.

“It’s just tough to know what they’re going to call from play to play,” said Twins catcher Kurt Suzuki. “Sometimes you see a play that’s called one way, and the next time it goes the other way. It’s weird that we don’t really know.”

That’s the part that bothers managers and players around the game. A survey of managers of playoff-contending teams by USA Today this week found at least four who want the rule scrapped before the postseason, just to avoid a game-changing decision. “It would be a travesty if it decides the seventh game of the World Series,” Tigers manager Brad Ausmus told the newspaper. Added Tampa Bay’s Joe Maddon: “It’s so unclear, you can’t ask it to be umpired consistently. It’s impossible. So I would go back to the old rule, ASAP.”

Some umpires even told USA Today that they intend not to enforce the rule during the playoffs, and let replay officials in New York sort it out, case by case.

Gardenhire’s suggestion is one that the NFL adopted several years ago: Just make a review on a scoring play automatic. “You need to go look at it every time. The catcher is supposed to be in fair territory — sometimes the play happens so quick, he never clears home plate,” Gardenhire said. “You almost should check it every time.”

In fact, that’s become his policy in the Minnesota dugout. Several outs that weren’t even close have been overturned by replay review umpires because catchers weren’t giving a “sliding lane” before they had the ball, and Gardenhire believes he missed chances to have similar plays nullified because he wasn’t focused on the catcher’s feet.

“I tell Steiny [bench coach Terry Steinbach, the dugout liaison with video coordinator Sean Harlin] every time now — get on the phone and see where [the catcher] is at,” Gardenhire said. “Now, you just don’t know.”

And not knowing is a big problem.

Statistically speaking

The Twins’ four-year run of losing seasons has coincided with the four worst seasons of hitting with runners in scoring position during manager Ron Gardenhire’s tenure. The trend bottomed out last year, but 2014 is the second-worst such season; still, the Twins have raised their average by 11 points in August. Here are the Twins’ batting averages with runners in scoring position and their team leaders (minimum of 100 plate appearances) in that category since 2002:

Year Team BA Twins leader Leader’s BA

2014 .242 Kurt Suzuki .326

2013 .225 Brian Dozier .307

2012 .252 Joe Mauer .372

2011 .248 Jason Kubel .324

  • related content

  • Statistically speaking

    Sunday August 31, 2014

    The Twins’ four-year run of losing seasons has coincided with the four worst seasons of hitting with runners in scoring...

  • Central Intelligence

    Saturday August 30, 2014

    As August turns to September, the pressure on AL Central teams grows. Here’s how each team dealt with the atmosphere...

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

ADVERTISEMENT

New England 2/1/15 5:30 PM
Seattle
Toronto 95 4th Qtr 5:07
Indiana 81
Cleveland 75 3rd Qtr 0:32
Detroit 62
Milwaukee 62 3rd Qtr 6:02
Miami 67
Memphis 24 2nd Qtr 12:00
Dallas 24
Chicago 9:30 PM
Golden State
Washington 9:30 PM
LA Lakers
NY Rangers 0 3rd Prd 13:58
NY Islanders 2
Arizona 3 3rd Prd 14:50
Philadelphia 3
Winnipeg 3 3rd Prd 10:43
Pittsburgh 4
Washington 2 3rd Prd 11:04
Columbus 4
Tampa Bay 2 2nd Prd 1:14
Carolina 3
Dallas 2 2nd Prd 4:19
Montreal 3
Detroit 5 2nd Prd 2:23
Florida 3
Colorado 1 2nd Prd 16:49
Nashville 0
Buffalo 0 1st Prd 19:20
Calgary 0
Minnesota 8:30 PM
Edmonton
Anaheim 9:00 PM
Vancouver
Ball State 47 FINAL
Akron 59
Northern Ill 46 FINAL
Bowling Green 56
Western Mich 71 FINAL
Buffalo 77
Ohio 40 FINAL
Eastern Mich 76
Xavier 64 2nd Half 0:28
Georgetown 53
Vanderbilt 62 FINAL
Georgia 70
West Virginia 55 2nd Half 2:09
Kansas State 49
Central Mich 53 2nd Half 0:12
Kent State 63
Saint Josephs 48 FINAL
La Salle 53
Nebraska 44 FINAL
Michigan 58
Miami-Ohio 65 FINAL
Toledo 70
Tulsa 62 FINAL
Tulane 55
George Washington 48 FINAL
VA Commonwealth 72
Pittsburgh 64 1st OT 2:57
Virginia Tech 65
Indiana State 36 2nd Half
Evansville 40
Tabor College 30 2nd Half 16:20
Oral Roberts 51
Florida 6 1st Half 17:15
Alabama 2
Tennessee 0 1st Half 18:16
Arkansas 4
Texas A&M 3 1st Half 17:52
Auburn 0
Baylor 2 1st Half 17:22
Oklahoma State 4
DePaul 0 Postponed
Providence 0
Michigan State 0 Postponed
Rutgers 0
Wyoming 2 1st Half 17:51
Utah State 2
Fresno State 2 1st Half 17:35
San Diego St 3
UNLV 9:00 PM
Nevada
SD Christian 9:00 PM
CS-Bakersfield
Colorado State 10:00 PM
Boise State
Temple 71 FINAL
UCF 54
Campbell 42 FINAL
Presbyterian 51
Coastal Carolina 65 FINAL
High Point 73
Gardner-Webb 49 FINAL
Radford 59
UNC-Asheville 58 FINAL
Liberty 62
Winthrop 63 FINAL
Longwood 62
Columbia International 33 FINAL
Charleston Southern 74
Tulane 26 2nd Half
Houston 18
(3) Baylor 56 2nd Half 16:00
TCU 42
Navy 32 2nd Half 16:17
American Univ 40
Valparaiso 21 2nd Half 17:10
Illinois-Chicago 26
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: How optimistic are you about the 2015 Twins?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close