Souhan: Kirby vs. Joe? This argument sounds familiar

  • Article by: JIM SOUHAN , Star Tribune
  • Updated: March 29, 2014 - 9:48 PM

It’s style (Kirby Puckett) vs. substance (Joe Mauer).


John Croft /startribune file photo Oct 25, 1987

Photo: John Croft, DML -

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

Player A might be the most popular athlete in Minnesota history.

He shot through the Twins’ farm system and became a big part of winning teams. After his agent, Ron Shapiro, battled the Twins in contract negotiations, he became, briefly, the highest-paid player in baseball by signing a deal to keep him in Minnesota at least through his prime.

In his first 10 seasons in the majors, he produced an OPS (on-base-plus-slugging percentage) of .827 and a WAR (overall player rating, called wins above replacement player) of 44.0. He made the All-Star team eight times, won six Gold Gloves and five Silver Sluggers and ranked in the top 10 in MVP votes seven times.

He was not a classic power hitter, instead spraying line drives all over the ballpark. He was beloved.

Player B is not the most popular athlete in Minnesota history, even though he grew up in the state.

He shot through the Twins’ farm system and became a big part of winning teams. After his agent, Ron Shapiro, battled the Twins in contract negotiations, he signed the most lucrative contract in franchise history, a deal expected to keep him in Minnesota at least through his prime.

In his first 10 seasons in the majors, he produced an OPS of .873 and a WAR of 44.3. He made the All-Star team six times, won one MVP Award, finished in the top 10 of MVP voting four times, won three Gold Gloves and five Silver Sluggers, all despite having two of his first 10 seasons wiped out by injuries.

He was not a classic power hitter, instead spraying line drives all over the ballpark. He was not beloved, at least not among the chattering classes that use social media.

Player A was Kirby Puckett. Player B is Joe Mauer. Through the first 10 years of their careers, they proved to be remarkably similar. They are perceived to be altogether different.


Mauer might have been slightly more valuable than Puckett over his first 10 big-league seasons, because he played a more difficult defensive position — catcher instead of center and right field — and because he reached base more often. In fact, while Puckett was perceived to have more power, and did hit more home runs on average, Puckett’s slugging percentage his first 10 years was .469. Mauer’s is .468.

As public figures, Puckett still benefits from three factors:

1) Puckett played more.

He was incredibly durable. Puckett prided himself on playing every day. He never visited the disabled list, while Mauer has had two seasons ruined by injury and was rested regularly even when healthy, as are most modern-day catchers.

2) Puckett was charismatic.

He played with great joy and more obvious effort, while Mauer showed off smooth mechanics. As a center fielder, Puckett could make the spectacular play, running into or leaping above a wall, while Mauer toiled in a crouch.

3. Puckett won championships, and shined while doing so.

Puckett made the playoffs only twice, but both trips turned into World Series titles, with his Game 6 performance in the 1991 World Series branding him as a clutch performer, a winner for the ages. Mauer’s teams made the playoffs four times — five if you count Game 163 in 2008 — but he never has played in a winning playoff game (the Twins won a game in 2004 when Mauer was injured), much less a series. If Game 6 of 1991 stands as Puckett’s postseason symbol, Mauer’s is the potentially game-changing double he hit in 2009 that was incorrectly ruled foul in Yankee Stadium.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions
Bottom 8th123456789RHE
Detroit00000000 050
Minnesota0001010 270
Preview | Matchup | Lineup | Log | Wrap | Box
HR: DET- None MIN- K.Vargas (8)


Boston 0 Top 9th Inning
Pittsburgh 4
Toronto 2 Top 9th Inning
Baltimore 8
Washington - WP: T. Roark 3 FINAL
Atlanta - LP: A. Harang 0
Miami - LP: N. Eovaldi 1 FINAL
NY Mets - WP: B. Colon 9
NY Yankees 1 Bottom 7th Inning
Tampa Bay 4
Cincinnati 0 Bottom 7th Inning
Chicago Cubs 6
Chicago WSox 4 Top 5th Inning
Kansas City 3
Cleveland 2 Top 6th Inning
Houston 1
Detroit 0 Top 8th Inning
Minnesota 2
Milwaukee 1 Top 7th Inning
St. Louis 2
Los Angeles 0 Top 6th Inning
Colorado 5
San Francisco 0 Top 3rd Inning
Arizona 0
Seattle 0 Top 1st Inning
LA Angels 0
Texas 0 Top 1st Inning
Oakland 0
Philadelphia - A. Burnett 9:10 PM
San Diego - I. Kennedy
Tampa Bay 9/18/14 7:25 PM
San Diego 9/21/14 12:00 PM
Dallas 9/21/14 12:00 PM
St. Louis
Washington 9/21/14 12:00 PM
Houston 9/21/14 12:00 PM
NY Giants
Minnesota 9/21/14 12:00 PM
New Orleans
Tennessee 9/21/14 12:00 PM
Baltimore 9/21/14 12:00 PM
Green Bay 9/21/14 12:00 PM
Indianapolis 9/21/14 12:00 PM
Oakland 9/21/14 12:00 PM
New England
San Francisco 9/21/14 3:05 PM
Denver 9/21/14 3:25 PM
Kansas City 9/21/14 3:25 PM
Pittsburgh 9/21/14 7:30 PM
Chicago 9/22/14 7:30 PM
NY Jets
(5) Auburn 9/18/14 6:30 PM
(20) Kansas State
Connecticut 9/19/14 7:00 PM
So Florida
Old Dominion 9/20/14 11:00 AM
Troy 9/20/14 11:00 AM
(13) Georgia
Georgia Tech 9/20/14 11:00 AM
Virginia Tech
Eastern Mich 9/20/14 11:00 AM
(11) Michigan State
Iowa 9/20/14 11:00 AM
Bowling Green 9/20/14 11:00 AM
(19) Wisconsin
Maryland 9/20/14 11:30 AM
Tulane 9/20/14 11:30 AM
Hawaii 9/20/14 1:00 PM
Marshall 9/20/14 1:00 PM
North Carolina 9/20/14 2:30 PM
East Carolina
Army 9/20/14 2:30 PM
Wake Forest
Virginia 9/20/14 2:30 PM
(21) BYU
(6) Texas A&M 9/20/14 2:30 PM
Rutgers 9/20/14 2:30 PM
Central Mich 9/20/14 2:30 PM
Utah 9/20/14 2:30 PM
Florida 9/20/14 2:30 PM
(3) Alabama
Louisville 9/20/14 2:30 PM
Fla Atlantic 9/20/14 3:00 PM
Indiana 9/20/14 3:00 PM
(18) Missouri
San Jose St 9/20/14 3:00 PM
Texas State 9/20/14 3:00 PM
Massachusetts 9/20/14 3:00 PM
Penn State
Georgia State 9/20/14 5:00 PM
Appalachian St 9/20/14 6:00 PM
Southern Miss
Miss State 9/20/14 6:00 PM
(8) LSU
Northern Ill 9/20/14 6:00 PM
Middle Tennessee 9/20/14 6:00 PM
Utah State 9/20/14 6:00 PM
Arkansas State
Miami-Ohio 9/20/14 6:00 PM
Idaho 9/20/14 6:00 PM
Ohio U
Ball State 9/20/14 6:00 PM
(14) So Carolina 9/20/14 6:30 PM
(4) Oklahoma 9/20/14 6:30 PM
West Virginia
Ga Southern 9/20/14 6:30 PM
South Alabama
UNLV 9/20/14 7:00 PM
(22) Clemson 9/20/14 7:00 PM
(1) Florida State
Miami-Florida 9/20/14 7:00 PM
(24) Nebraska
New Mexico 9/20/14 7:00 PM
New Mexico St
California 9/20/14 9:00 PM
Louisiana 9/20/14 9:30 PM
Boise State
(2) Oregon 9/20/14 9:30 PM
Washington St
San Diego St 9/20/14 9:30 PM
Oregon State
Toronto 9/19/14 9:00 PM
Brt Columbia
Edmonton 9/20/14 6:00 PM
Calgary 9/21/14 12:00 PM
Ottawa 9/21/14 3:00 PM
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters





question of the day

Poll: How sure are you that the Twins are on the road to improving?

Weekly Question