Phil Miller's Sunday Insider: Challenge system turns managers into umps

  • Updated: August 17, 2013 - 9:33 PM

With the challenge system next year, managers will have to be umpires, too.

hide

Bud Selig, the commissioner of Major League Baseball, wanted his sport to get calls correct.

Photo: MIKE GROLL • Associated Press,

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

Ron Gardenhire got a pay raise this week.

Well, not an actual increase in pay, exactly, but he will be keeping more of the money he earns. That’s because one side effect of baseball’s decision to review umpire’s calls via replay should be a reduction in on-field arguments, ejections and the nearly automatic fines that go with them. Gardenhire has been ejected 64 times as a manager, and fined thousands of dollars as a result.

Of course, maybe he deserves to keep a little more of his paycheck now, because baseball is adding a new job to his responsibilities: Starting next year, he will have to umpire, too.

That’s one of the most glaring weaknesses of Major League Baseball’s decision to adopt a challenge system to the game, starting next Opening Day — it shifts the burden of umpiring from umpires to managers, who are standing perhaps hundreds of feet away from the play. Without the benefit of seeing a replay — TVs and other electronics are banned from dugouts; managers don’t even have headsets that allow NFL coaches to confer with staff members watching from above — it will be Gardenhire’s responsibility to determine whether a call was missed and whether he should exercise one of his limited challenges.

Yes, baseball should be applauded for finally dragging itself into the 21st century, for finally acknowledging that it makes no sense for games to be decided by calls that everyone in the stadium, except those making the decision, can see clearly and definitively were wrong.

But here’s the craziest thing about the system that baseball has settled upon: On a day when player after player, manager after manager, kept saying that the most important thing is getting calls right, baseball proposed a system that it acknowledges right up front won’t do that.

They’ll get the calls right … as long as the manager can tell it was missed. They’ll get the calls right … as long as the manager hasn’t used all his challenges. They’ll get the calls right … as long as the manager calculates that it’s worth risking a challenge, rather than saving it for later.

How does that make sense? A close play at first with two out in the first inning, when the manager couldn’t tell for sure, might be deemed not worthy of double-checking, since teams get only one challenge for the first six innings. But if a player is called safe when he wasn’t, and his next two teammates walk and the next hits a grand slam, why is it fair that the game was potentially decided by an easily confirmed missed call?

Baseball is adding complexity where it’s not necessary, and tacitly allowing blown calls to stand rather than be corrected.

“I’ve said all along that they should have a guy up in the booth, he has a replay right in front of him, and he signals yes or no. I’ve always thought that’s the quickest way to do it,” Gardenhire said. “That would be fine. Leave me in the dugout, that’d be great. I wouldn’t ever have to go out on the field.”

No system is going to be controversy-free. It’s not difficult to imagine scenarios where blown calls affect how a play unfolds — a player whose sinking liner is caught but ruled a trap then gets into a rundown, allowing runners to score ahead of him; where do you put the runners when the original call is overruled? The system is surely the death of the “neighborhood play,” too, since replays will detect whether a player has the ball as he touches second. And balls and strikes, the most heatedly debated calls in the game, won’t be affected.

But Gardenhire is right. The “solution” to baseball’s tech-fueled discovery that umpires make more mistakes than we once realized shouldn’t create a new set of problems.

  • related content

  • Sunday Insider: Statistically Speaking

    Saturday August 17, 2013

    Walk-offs for and againstChris Herrmann delivered a single in the ninth inning Thursday, driving home the winning run in a...

  • Sunday Insider: Central Intelligence

    Saturday August 17, 2013

    Central intelligenceThe White Sox opened the season with a $119 million payroll, ninth highest in the majors, but by shedding...

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

ADVERTISEMENT

Buffalo 12/28/14 12:00 PM
New England
Cleveland 12/28/14 12:00 PM
Baltimore
Dallas 12/28/14 12:00 PM
Washington
Indianapolis 12/28/14 12:00 PM
Tennessee
Jacksonville 12/28/14 12:00 PM
Houston
San Diego 12/28/14 12:00 PM
Kansas City
NY Jets 12/28/14 12:00 PM
Miami
Chicago 12/28/14 12:00 PM
Minnesota
Philadelphia 12/28/14 12:00 PM
NY Giants
New Orleans 12/28/14 12:00 PM
Tampa Bay
Carolina 12/28/14 3:25 PM
Atlanta
Detroit 12/28/14 3:25 PM
Green Bay
Oakland 12/28/14 3:25 PM
Denver
Arizona 12/28/14 3:25 PM
San Francisco
St. Louis 12/28/14 3:25 PM
Seattle
Cincinnati 12/28/14 7:30 PM
Pittsburgh
Marshall 52 FINAL
Northern Ill 23
Navy 17 FINAL
San Diego St 16
Central Mich 48 FINAL
Western Ky 49
Fresno State 6 FINAL
Rice 30
Illinois 12/26/14 12:00 PM
Louisiana Tech
Rutgers 12/26/14 3:30 PM
North Carolina
NC State 12/26/14 7:00 PM
UCF
Cincinnati 12/27/14 12:00 PM
Virginia Tech
Duke 12/27/14 1:10 PM
(15) Arizona State
Miami-Florida 12/27/14 2:30 PM
So Carolina
Boston College 12/27/14 3:30 PM
Penn State
(25) Nebraska 12/27/14 7:00 PM
(24) USC
Texas A&M 12/29/14 1:00 PM
West Virginia
Oklahoma 12/29/14 4:30 PM
(18) Clemson
Arkansas 12/29/14 8:00 PM
Texas
Notre Dame 12/30/14 2:00 PM
(22) LSU
(13) Georgia 12/30/14 5:45 PM
(20) Louisville
Maryland 12/30/14 9:00 PM
Stanford
(9) Ole Miss 12/31/14 11:30 AM
(6) TCU
(21) Boise State 12/31/14 3:00 PM
(12) Arizona
(8) Miss State 12/31/14 7:00 PM
(10) Georgia Tech
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Do you like the Twins' offseason moves so far?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close