New draft rules work well for Twins

  • Article by: PHIL MILLER , Star Tribune
  • Updated: June 3, 2013 - 11:58 AM

Baseball’s year-old “slotting’’ rules mesh with the team’s approach — even in a case like Joe Mauer’s.

hide

Twins General Manager Terry Ryan

Photo: David Brewster, Star Tribune file

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

 

Fortunately for the Twins and their three-time batting champion, the question is only a hypothetical. But it’s interesting nevertheless: If the 2001 draft were held under 2013 rules, would Joe Mauer be a Twin today?

Yes, insists Terry Ryan, the general manager who authorized the $5.15 million bonus it took to sign the St. Paul catcher; Mauer was the player the Twins preferred all along, he said. But the industry consensus at the time was that Southern California righthander Mark Prior was one of the best pitching prospects in baseball history, and Georgia Tech third baseman Mark Teixeira was a better hitter than Mauer. Trouble was, both were represented by super agent Scott Boras, both wanted huge contracts and were willing to hold out to get them, and Prior had made it clear he wouldn’t sign with the Twins, who owned the No. 1 pick.

But today? The players would have far less leverage, negotiations would last only about six weeks, no prospect could sign a major league contract (as Prior and Teixeira did), and the money they received — $10.5 million in Prior’s case, counting guaranteed major league money, a record that stood until Steven Strasburg entered the draft in 2009 — would be severely restricted. “The early returns on the system we have now show that the quote-unquote superstar players are affected the most by the [2012] changes,” said John Manuel, editor of Baseball America magazine, which closely covers the draft and all levels of pro and amateur baseball. “Basically, it’s no longer realistically possible for a superstar to get outrageous money.”

Which is fine with the Twins. When Major League Baseball’s amateur draft convenes on Thursday, teams will operate for a second season under strict limits on bonus money, rules that changed strategies, shuffled draft boards and sped up the draft-and-sign process last year. But from the Twins’ point of view, the new “slotting” guidelines simply made their competitors play under the same rules the Twins had followed all along.

“In our humble opinion, we were getting killed by teams who were taking advantage of a bad system,” said Mike Radcliff, the Twins vice president for player personnel, who oversees, along with scouting director Deron Johnson, the team’s draft preparations. “We were getting killed because we tried to follow rules that others ignored. Now it’s more about who does the best job of scouting. It’s more of a level playing field.”

Well, not for the franchise-altering players at the top of the draft, who can no longer expect to stretch the size of the bonus record. Strasburg received a guaranteed $15.1 million from the Nationals when the righthander was selected No. 1 in 2009, and outfielder Bryce Harper signed a $9.9 million contract the following year, but "if another Strasburg comes along, he's not going to get anywhere near $15 million, and if a Harper is drafted now, he'd get a lot less than $10 million," Manuel said. "You can't tie up all your bonus money in one guy, even if he's a franchise guy."

That’s because of the bonus pool and “slotting.” Each draft pick is assigned a recommended bonus, from $7.79 million for the overall No. 1 this year, to $135,300 for the last player taken in the 10th round. A team can spread its money around any way it likes, but if it spends more than its recommended 10-round total — $8.3 million for the Twins this year, for instance — it must pay a penalty, first in a “luxury tax” on the overage. It a team exceeds its slot amount by more than 5 percent, it forfeits its first-round pick in the following year’s draft, a penalty few teams are expected to risk. Go over by 10 percent, and lose two first-round picks.

"Teams did a good job of identifying who would sign and for how much, and who would be a signability problem," Manuel said. "Signability is more important now than ever," because there is no advantage to not signing a draftee; teams forfeit the allowance for any unsigned player.

 

The rules also set a mid-July deadline to sign players (except college seniors), speeding up negotiations, and grants compensation a year later for unsigned picks. Only Stanford righthander Mark Appel, disappointed to fall to eighth due to signability concerns, went unsigned last year, by the Pirates. Appel, a Boras client, is one of the top two or three prospects again this year.

The office of Commissioner Bud Selig had issued draft-bonus recommendations for several years, and the Twins “mostly” followed them, Radcliff said. But there were no real repercussions for teams that ignored them, and some teams spent with impunity to convince some players to forego college or another sport in order to play baseball. That changed last year.

“For us, it really hasn’t had much of an impact. Here’s what we’re allowed to spend, now let’s find the best way to use it,” Radcliff said. “The system really worked the way it was designed. Everybody knows what the numbers are. So it went pretty smoothly.”

Not without a few surprises, however. The Astros had the No. 1 pick (as they do again Thursday), but rather than take one of the highest rated players, they chose Puerto Rican shortstop Carlos Correa. The reason: Correa agreed to sign for $4.8 million, not the $7.2 million that Houston was allowed to offer. The Astros then used the extra cash to convince two later choices not to enroll in college.

  • related content

  • Chart: Baseball's slotting system

    Monday June 3, 2013

    Slotting systemBaseball’s slotting system, which went into effect last year, makes recommendations on what each draftee can be signed for,...

  • MSU Mankato pitcher Hoppe aiming for more

    Monday June 3, 2013

    The standout Mavericks pitcher hopes to hear his name called in the upcoming draft.

  • Twins prospect Byron Buxton is the next big thing

    Sunday June 2, 2013

    Until they drafted Buxton and signed power-hitting third baseman Miguel Sano, who is playing at Class A Fort Myers, the Twins hadn’t raved about prospects with such enthusiasm since they...

  • Upcoming stories: Previewing the draft

    Monday June 3, 2013

    coming up this week on the draftThe Star Tribune began a five-part series Sunday previewing baseball’s draft, which starts Thursday....

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

ADVERTISEMENT

Atlanta 6 FINAL
Detroit 4
Philadelphia 3 FINAL
Houston 6
St. Louis 4 FINAL
Miami 1
Baltimore 3 FINAL
Tampa Bay 2
NY Yankees 2 FINAL
Pittsburgh 1
Chicago Cubs 6 FINAL
San Francisco 8
Los Angeles 6 FINAL
Chicago WSox 1
San Diego 4 FINAL
Seattle 9
Cleveland 9 FINAL
Cincinnati 3
Milwaukee 2 FINAL
LA Angels 3
Oakland 2 FINAL
Chicago Cubs 2
Texas 4 FINAL
Kansas City 5
Colorado 3 FINAL
Arizona 4
NY Mets 4 FINAL
Washington 5
Boston 8 FINAL
Minnesota 9
Toronto 0 FINAL
Baltimore 5
Oklahoma City 103 4th Qtr 1:07
Chicago 99
Dallas 9:30 PM
Portland
Calgary 4 FINAL(SO)
Boston 3
St. Louis 1 FINAL
Philadelphia 3
Minnesota 2 FINAL
Washington 1
Toronto 2 FINAL
Tampa Bay 4
Dallas 4 FINAL(SO)
Florida 3
NY Islanders 4 3rd Prd 1:51
Nashville 3
Vancouver 0 2nd Prd 4:57
Arizona 1
Montreal 9:30 PM
Los Angeles
Morgan State 76 FINAL
MD-Eastern Shore 89
Niagara 54 FINAL
Siena 71
Holy Cross 83 FINAL
Bucknell 90
Western Ky 88 FINAL
Charlotte 84
Navy 62 FINAL
Colgate 72
Temple 70 FINAL
East Carolina 56
UAB 59 FINAL
Fla Atlantic 62
Boston Univ 64 FINAL
Lafayette 89
American Univ 68 FINAL
Lehigh 62
Wisconsin 76 FINAL
Minnesota 63
Fairfield 33 FINAL
Saint Peters 63
Arkansas 78 FINAL
South Carolina 74
Morehead State 76 FINAL
UT Martin 65
USC Upstate 63 FINAL
Fla Gulf Coast 62
Lipscomb 57 FINAL
North Florida 71
Southern Ill 55 FINAL
Missouri State 48
Texas State 64 FINAL
Appalachian St 67
SC State 62 FINAL
Bethune-Cookman 72
Delaware State 104 FINAL
Coppin State 92
Middle Tennessee 54 FINAL
FIU 59
Texas-Arlington 64 FINAL
Ga Southern 76
Norfolk State 80 FINAL
Hampton 69
NC A&T 58 FINAL
NC Central 69
Savannah State 57 FINAL
Florida A&M 64
Southern Miss 61 FINAL
Louisiana Tech 72
Marshall 50 FINAL
Old Dominion 67
Rice 76 FINAL
TX-San Antonio 74
South Alabama 73 2nd Half 3:35
Arkansas State 71
Alabama State 56 2nd Half 10:00
Grambling St 35
Alabama A&M 44 2nd Half 5:20
Jackson State 60
Sam Houston St 45 2nd Half 9:00
Lamar 46
Georgia State 58 FINAL
ULM 50
Central Arkansas 70 2nd Half 0:11
Nicholls 75
Portland State 51 FINAL
Northern Ariz 58
Southern U 42 2nd Half 12:38
Prairie View 52
Alcorn State 55 2nd Half 10:00
Texas Southern 61
Houston Baptist 60 2nd Half 3:49
TX A&M-CC 76
Ark-Little Rock 59 2nd Half 3:23
Louisiana 63
SE Louisiana 50 2nd Half 12:07
New Orleans 73
California 33 2nd Half 15:48
Arizona 58
Memphis 35 2nd Half 13:29
Connecticut 37
VA Commonwealth 29 2nd Half 14:15
Davidson 48
Ark-Pine Bluff 0 Postponed
Miss Valley St 0
Sacramento St 57 2nd Half 8:00
Southern Utah 56
Northwestern St 46 2nd Half 13:00
Stephen F Austin 65
North Texas 43 2nd Half 8:42
Texas-El Paso 63
Colorado 54 2nd Half 7:38
Washington 42
Idaho 41 2nd Half 10:14
Weber State 60
Abilene Christian 27 2nd Half 15:50
Incarnate Word 28
Eastern Wash 67 2nd Half 8:23
Idaho State 52
Marist 46 2nd Half 15:41
Quinnipiac 32
Eastern Ill 30 2nd Half 15:29
Belmont 54
Bradley 21 2nd Half
Drake 17
Cal State Fullerton 14 1st Half 7:50
UC Irvine 13
CS-Northridge 12 1st Half 10:47
Long Beach State 16
UC Riverside 23 1st Half 9:21
UC Davis 10
Stanford 10:00 PM
Arizona State
Utah 10:00 PM
Washington St
Monmouth 68 FINAL
Canisius 56
Wake Forest 85 FINAL
(22) Syracuse 79
Saint Louis 65 FINAL
VA Commonwealth 58
Saint Peters 62 FINAL
Rider 54
UNC-Asheville 51 FINAL
Liberty 59
UNC Greensboro 44 FINAL
(17) Chattanooga 78
Michigan State 69 FINAL
Michigan 49
Arkansas 72 FINAL
Ole Miss 61
Manhattan 51 FINAL
Niagara 57
Massachusetts 63 FINAL
Richmond 67
Virginia 52 FINAL
Miami-Florida 62
Jacksonville St 45 FINAL
Belmont 55
Morgan State 65 FINAL
MD-Eastern Shore 50
Campbell 65 FINAL
Winthrop 52
Furman 65 FINAL
Samford 54
Oregon 64 FINAL
Washington St 66
Indiana 52 FINAL
(23) Rutgers 63
Pepperdine 67 FINAL
Loyola Marymount 68
Auburn 47 FINAL
(18) Texas A&M 57
Morehead St 66 FINAL
Tennessee St 81
George Mason 43 FINAL
Saint Josephs 71
Western Carolina 53 FINAL
East Tenn St 73
Arizona 62 FINAL
UCLA 80
FIU 30 FINAL
Middle Tennessee 79
Texas State 55 FINAL
Appalachian St 61
TX-Arlington 66 FINAL
Georgia Southern 41
SC State 57 FINAL
Bethune-Cookman 56
Delaware State 51 FINAL
Coppin State 80
Portland 58 FINAL
Santa Clara 66
Norfolk State 49 FINAL
Hampton 64
Florida Atlantic 56 FINAL
UAB 59
NC A&T 67 FINAL
NC Central 46
Savannah State 72 FINAL
Florida A&M 51
Virginia Tech 51 FINAL
Pittsburgh 45
Central Arkansas 43 FINAL
Nicholls 53
Houston Baptist 48 FINAL
TX A&M-CC 73
Gardner-Webb 70 FINAL
Radford 56
Georgia 75 FINAL
Missouri 64
Old Dominion 67 FINAL
Marshall 55
Ark-Little Rock 68 FINAL
Louisiana 66
South Alabama 60 FINAL
Arkansas State 70
Georgia State 66 FINAL
ULM 61
Sam Houston St 73 FINAL
Lamar 92
SE Louisiana 75 FINAL
New Orleans 84
Northwestern St 45 FINAL
Stephen F Austin 56
Alabama A&M 58 FINAL
Jackson State 66
Alabama State 68 FINAL
Grambling 62
Southern U 78 FINAL
Prairie View 50
Alcorn State 55 FINAL
Texas Southern 73
Ark-Pine Bluff 0 Postponed
Miss Valley St 0
Wofford 54 FINAL
Mercer 75
Abilene Christian 72 FINAL
Incarnate Word 62
La Salle 60 FINAL
Rhode Island 65
Illinois 71 FINAL
Nebraska 86
TX-San Antonio 60 FINAL
Rice 49
Valparaiso 55 FINAL
Oakland 70
Missouri State 65 FINAL
Indiana State 56
Georgia Tech 64 FINAL
(15) North Carolina 84
Charlotte 72 FINAL
Western Ky 80
Texas-El Paso 69 FINAL
North Texas 61
Wichita State 77 FINAL
Evansville 63
Loyola-Chicago 64 FINAL
Northern Iowa 69
Bradley 70 FINAL
Drake 86
Presbyterian 62 2nd Half 0:24
High Point 73
Vanderbilt 51 2nd Half 4:13
(12) Kentucky 57
Colorado 49 2nd Half 11:57
USC 42
San Francisco 48 2nd Half 11:40
Pacific 43
Idaho State 43 2nd Half 8:14
Eastern Washington 44
Weber State 24 2nd Half 12:12
Idaho 51
Purdue 32 2nd Half
Minnesota 45
Cal-Irvine 16 1st Half 6:32
Cal State Fullerton 24
Long Beach St 9 1st Half 9:36
CS-Northridge 19
Hawaii 23 1st Half 7:56
UC Santa Barbara 20
UC Davis 12 1st Half 9:26
UC-Riverside 6
Northern Ariz 28 1st Half 6:45
Portland State 19
Southern Utah 4 1st Half 12:15
Sacramento St 22
Utah 10:30 PM
Washington
BYU 10:30 PM
St Marys-CA
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Who is doing the best job coaching a Minnesota pro sports team?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close