TwinsCentric was formed by Twins super-bloggers Seth Stohs, Nick Nelson, Parker Hageman and John Bonnes. Together they publish at and have authored books, e-books and magazines that provide independent and in-depth coverage of the Minnesota Twins from a fan's perspective. You can contact them at

Read more about them.

TwinsCentric: On Paradigms and Kevin Correia

Posted by: John Bonnes Updated: December 11, 2012 - 12:06 PM



The easy reaction to the news that the Minnesota Twins and Kevin Correia have agreed to a 2-year/$10 million deal is to overreact. I still plan to. But before I go down that path, I want to remind myself about paradigms.

A paradigm is the story around the story that impacts our perceptions. The classic example (I think from Stephen Covey) is that while riding the subway, he saw the father of several small children watching them passively as they misbehaved quite badly. People were getting angry at the children and even angrier at his indifference. That perception, and the entire car’s reaction, changed when it became clear he and the children were coming from the hospital, where they had said their last goodbyes to his wife, their mom.

A paradigm is the story the conman spins to make us think that doing something stupid is doing something smart. It can also lead to overreaction, as Aaron Gleeman and I discussed on our most recent podcast. We recalled the overwhelmingly negative reaction nationally and locally when the Twins drafted Ben Revere.

Some of that reaction was undoubtedly driven by two paradigms in vogue at the time. First, that the Twins were cheap, and thus overdrafted Revere to save money. And second was that they were enamored with speedy piranhas over power. Ultimately, it isn’t clear that either was true, and it certainly isn’t clear that Revere was a good example of either.

Here’s an interesting thought experiment. What if the paradigms at the time had been different? For instance, what if the Twins had the reputation of the “Moneyball” A’s? Had the A’s signed Revere, it would have been example of them recognizing the value of speed and defense, getting an underrated contributor in those overlooked areas at a bargain price. (And ultimately flipping him for more than he was worth.) It might well have been a love-fest.

That’s the power – and the trap – of a paradigm.

The signing of Correia faces a similar challenge. The current popular paradigms for the Twins are that they love “pitch to contact” starters and that they are cheap. Correia represents the worst of both of those philosophies. So, before I overreact, let me just say that I’m aware of these paradigms. I’m aware of their power. And I’m aware that neither paradigm is really true, with plenty of counter-examples. I’m even aware that Kevin Correia is not Jason Marquis.

So what am I left with? Unfortunately, I think I’m left with Kevin Correia signed for two-years and $10 million.

Correia's ERA over the last two years is 4.49 and that’s pitching in the National League. He wasn’t bad because he was unlucky. Instead, on those off-years where he’s been good, it’s because he has been lucky. And he’s never pitched in the AL.

I guess he’s been fairly durable. However, just because you can make every start doesn’t mean you should, a lesson that the Pirates seemingly learned when they moved him to the bullpen after the trade deadline.

And while there is room for a guy like that on the bottom end of a pitching staff, it isn’t on a multi-year deal. This is not dissimilar to the Twins signing Marquis last year. Except that Marquis wasn’t kicked off of the starting rotation the year before. And he had a better year. And he wasn’t given a multi-year deal.

I get that the starting pitching market is drying up. I get that the Twins need someone to eat some innings. And I get that the most vitriolic critics will wallow in paradigms that aren’t really justified.

But here’s something else that isn’t justified – giving Kevin Correia a two-year deal and 10 million dollars.


Twins Daily has been killing it lately.



Team Irvin 7:15 PM
Team Carter
Miami 94 4th Qtr 0:37
Chicago 84
Oklahoma City 2:30 PM
Dallas 5:00 PM
New Orleans
Indiana 5:00 PM
LA Clippers 5:00 PM
Minnesota 5:00 PM
Detroit 6:00 PM
Milwaukee 6:00 PM
San Antonio
Boston 7:00 PM
Golden State
Washington 7:00 PM
Houston 8:30 PM
LA Lakers
Team Toews 4:00 PM
Team Foligno
South Florida 53 FINAL
Connecticut 66
Boston College 64 FINAL
Georgia Tech 62
Virginia 50 FINAL
Virginia Tech 47
Indiana 60 2nd Half 4:46
Ohio State 70
Stony Brook 36 2nd Half 17:15
Binghamton 30
Cincinnati 33 2nd Half 17:05
UCF 26
Maine 40 2nd Half 14:15
Hartford 35
Monmouth 49 2nd Half 13:19
Manhattan 47
Fairfield 32 2nd Half 15:43
Marist 33
Rowan 31 2nd Half 8:48
Princeton 77
St Bonaventure 31 2nd Half 14:40
Rhode Island 35
Duke 39 2nd Half 19:27
St Johns 45
Saint Peters 53 2nd Half 11:30
Siena 32
Drake 24 2nd Half 15:46
Wichita State 43
Vermont 35 2nd Half 12:30
UMass Lowell 33
Seton Hall 6 1st Half 14:05
Butler 12
NJIT 7 1st Half 12:08
South Alabama 11
Northern Iowa 3:00 PM
Illinois State
Louisville 3:00 PM
UMBC 3:30 PM
Niagara 3:30 PM
Notre Dame 5:30 PM
NC State
Belmont 5:30 PM
Tennessee St
Creighton 6:00 PM
Northwestern 6:30 PM
Washington 7:30 PM
Senior-North 34 FINAL
Senior-South 13
Seton Hall 99 FINAL
Georgetown 85
St Johns 69 FINAL
Villanova 81
Arkansas 58 FINAL
Florida 72
Maine 56 FINAL
Vanderbilt 55 FINAL
Alabama 52
Lafayette 60 FINAL
Lehigh 65
UCF 28 2nd Half
SMU 25
Utah 34 2nd Half 12:22
Washington 45
James Madison 54 2nd Half 10:47
Coll of Charleston 36
Delaware 21 2nd Half
Drexel 32
Hofstra 38 2nd Half 14:09
William & Mary 48
Hartford 42 2nd Half 15:18
Albany 44
Binghamton 35 2nd Half 12:05
Stony Brook 43
Towson 37 2nd Half
UNC-Wilmington 30
Wake Forest 49 2nd Half 15:30
(17) Florida State 64
Georgia Tech 47 2nd Half 11:40
Virginia 45
(22) Georgia 35 2nd Half 15:21
(5) Tennessee 30
Drake 65 2nd Half 7:57
Evansville 52
Iona 44 2nd Half
Canisius 32
Fairfield 16 2nd Half
Monmouth 28
Northwestern 47 2nd Half 15:12
Penn State 49
Wisconsin 44 2nd Half 11:46
Michigan State 50
Ohio State 39 2nd Half 12:50
Purdue 47
Northern Iowa 37 2nd Half 16:28
Indiana State 27
Butler 30 1st Half 0:40
Xavier 33
Creighton 10 1st Half 14:01
Marquette 4
Northeastern 7 1st Half 16:12
Elon 6
(2) Connecticut 20 1st Half 14:31
Cincinnati 0
Oregon 10 1st Half 11:07
Arizona 10
NC State 10 1st Half 13:35
(23) Syracuse 12
(7) Maryland 5 1st Half 15:49
Indiana 7
Illinois State 4 1st Half 14:10
Missouri State 4
Colorado 3:00 PM
Washington St
Tulane 3:00 PM
South Florida
(14) Kentucky 3:00 PM
Providence 3:00 PM
(9) Oregon State 3:00 PM
(13) Arizona State
Bradley 3:00 PM
Vermont 3:30 PM
UMass Lowell
Iowa State 3:30 PM
(8) Texas
Southern Ill 3:45 PM
Wichita State
(15) Duke 4:00 PM
(12) North Carolina
Miami-Florida 4:00 PM
(4) Louisville
(21) Minnesota 4:15 PM
(25) Rutgers
California 5:00 PM
(11) Stanford 7:00 PM
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters





question of the day

Poll: How optimistic are you about the 2015 Twins?

Weekly Question