Previous Page 2 of 3 Next

Continued: State is sending a message with lakeshore lawsuit

  • Article by: JIM SPENCER , Star Tribune
  • Last update: August 4, 2010 - 11:03 PM

As more homes creep closer to Minnesota's environmentally sensitive lakeshore, the state Department of Natural Resources is pushing back by suing a western Minnesota township that allowed a property owner to build a house 14 feet from Ida Lake. The rare move could signal a new statewide emphasis on controlling building on waterfront land.

"This is a shot across the bow on the part of DNR," said Brad Karkkainen, an environmental law expert at the University of Minnesota.

Karkkainen said the new suit against Cormorant Township will send a message to localities that are allowing more buildings -- often expansive vacation homes -- that exceed state standards for size and distance from the water's edge and create polluting stormwater runoff. "The importance of the suit," he said, "is in setting a policy precedent that DNR will use state resources to prosecute."

The DNR may have been emboldened to act by a June 24 state Supreme Court decision that narrowed the definition of when variances are allowed.

DNR legal actions against localities are rare -- perhaps only one a year -- said Kent Lokkesmoe, director of the agency's waters division. But they are usually meant to have an impact beyond an individual community. "We don't sue local governments very often," Lokkesmoe explained. "When you do sue, these [local governments] talk to each other."

The DNR suit, filed July 6, came less than two weeks after a Star Tribune series revealed that many municipalities in the state routinely grant variances on lakefront development. In some places, the newspaper found, variance approval rates rise to nearly 90 percent.

The Cormorant suit, filed by the state attorney general's office on behalf of the DNR, questions why the township in northwest Minnesota's Becker County agreed to let Richard Hanson build near the lake's edge a house roughly five times larger than a 576-square-foot family cabin. State law allows replacement buildings only the size of the older structures at their original sites. In Hanson's case, the law required that a home larger than 576 square feet be built 100 feet from the lake. But like many local governing bodies, Cormorant's Board of Supervisors exempted a lakefront property owner from the rules, even though planning officials advised against it.

Cormorant Supervisor Steve Sorenson said that most property owners who apply for variances get them. Sorenson, who has held office for 12 years, estimated that during his tenure the township approved 70 to 80 percent of variance requests from lakeshore property owners. Since 2007, the township's lawyer said, Cormorant has granted 12 of 17 or 71 percent of variance requests.

The Star Tribune found an 88 percent variance approval rate from 2005 to 2010 in Cass and Crow Wing counties in north central Minnesota.

DNR's Lokkesmoe said 80 percent approval rates "seem high," but added that variance requests must be judged individually.

What is a hardship?

The state's suit challenges Cormorant's application of the "undue hardship" rule that is supposed to govern who qualifies for a variance. Lake conservation advocates believe loose, inconsistent interpretation of the hardship rule has led to the widespread approval of variances that collectively endanger the states' lakes. On June 24, the Minnesota Supreme Court tightened the undue hardship rule in landmark fashion by saying variances can be issued only if property owners have absolutely no other "reasonable" way to legally use their land.

"Using that standard, a lot of those lakefront variances won't stand up," Karkkainen said.

In the Cormorant case, the state charged that "[t]he variance was unjustified because, among other things, the applicant did not demonstrate undue hardship and Cormorant Township failed to create any record demonstrating that Hanson met the required standards ..." Hanson had room to build his new home with a legal 100-foot setback. Instead, the township let him build entirely in what is supposed to be a restricted area.

"I have a client who thought he was doing exactly what he was supposed to do," said Hanson's lawyer, Charles Ramstad. "He was told he needed a variance, and he got one."

Once the town approved the variance at a May 11 meeting, Hanson had a contractor pour concrete footings for his new house. The footings are now 14 feet from Ida Lake, well inside the environmental impact zone that scientists say could seriously pollute and otherwise hurt Ida Lake's public waters. Ramstad refused to say how much Hanson spent on the concrete, but he called the expense "significant."

Kristi Hastings, a Fergus Falls lawyer hired by the township, declined to discuss the details of the township's actions. But the suit says the board knew that Hanson had room to build 100 feet from the lake and didn't make him do so.

The state wants the variance ruled illegal and Hanson's footings dug out. Hastings and Ramstad hope to meet with state lawyers to settle the case.

With or without a court hearing, the DNR suit in Cormorant leaves localities across the state with a new message, Karkkainen said:

"Variances are not a matter of convenience for property owners."

Jim Spencer • 612-673-4029

  • related content

  • Losing Our Lakes

    Tuesday April 26, 2011

    Home builders are routinely allowed to break the rules on shoreline development. Polluters are allowed to keep polluting. And clean-up efforts are falling short. While public officials are trying to...

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

Click here to send us your hunting or fishing photos – and to see what others are showing off from around the region.

ADVERTISEMENT

Philadelphia 12/20/14 3:30 PM
Washington
San Diego 12/20/14 7:25 PM
San Francisco
Minnesota 12/21/14 12:00 PM
Miami
Baltimore 12/21/14 12:00 PM
Houston
Detroit 12/21/14 12:00 PM
Chicago
Cleveland 12/21/14 12:00 PM
Carolina
Atlanta 12/21/14 12:00 PM
New Orleans
Green Bay 12/21/14 12:00 PM
Tampa Bay
Kansas City 12/21/14 12:00 PM
Pittsburgh
New England 12/21/14 12:00 PM
NY Jets
NY Giants 12/21/14 3:05 PM
St. Louis
Buffalo 12/21/14 3:25 PM
Oakland
Indianapolis 12/21/14 3:25 PM
Dallas
Seattle 12/21/14 7:30 PM
Arizona
Denver 12/22/14 7:30 PM
Cincinnati
Utah 81 4th Qtr 11:25
Orlando 66
Charlotte 85 3rd Qtr 1:10
Philadelphia 68
Brooklyn 49 3rd Qtr
Cleveland 54
Washington 54 3rd Qtr
Miami 55
Minnesota 54 3rd Qtr 9:11
Boston 59
Toronto 52 3rd Qtr
Detroit 52
Chicago 35 2nd Qtr 5:36
Memphis 30
Portland 30 2nd Qtr 6:18
San Antonio 32
LA Clippers 8:00 PM
Denver
Oklahoma City 9:30 PM
LA Lakers
Tampa Bay 1 3rd Prd
New Jersey 2
Anaheim 0 2nd Prd 10:53
Ottawa 2
NY Islanders 1 2nd Prd 9:19
Detroit 1
Boston 0 2nd Prd
Winnipeg 1
Dallas 8:00 PM
Calgary
Wilberforce 71 FINAL
Youngstown St 92
Jackson State 49 FINAL
Tulane 56
Siena 66 FINAL
Radford 76
Stillman 39 2nd Half 7:40
Alabama 56
Case Western Reserve 65 FINAL
Bucknell 88
Niagara 47 2nd Half 9:02
Buffalo 65
SD Christian 46 FINAL
UC Santa Barbara 69
Concordia (MI) 58 2nd Half 1:22
Central Mich 94
Northern Ill 43 2nd Half 0:40
Dartmouth 46
North Florida 73 2nd Half 3:55
Florida A&M 55
Hiwassee 71 FINAL
Gardner-Webb 91
Tennessee St 49 2nd Half 3:15
Hampton 59
NC A&T 49 2nd Half 4:25
Kent State 56
Central Penn College 65 2nd Half 1:47
Liberty 90
Eastern Ky 60 2nd Half 4:02
Miami-Florida 38
Northern Ky 76 2nd Half 2:37
Morehead State 56
Northern Ariz 58 2nd Half 0:49
Norfolk State 79
MD-Eastern Shore 43 2nd Half 0:26
Old Dominion 60
St Marys-CA 42 2nd Half 7:07
St Johns 45
Clemson 39 2nd Half 3:57
South Carolina 65
Tenn Tech 53 2nd Half 0:46
Tennessee 58
Washington-MD 46 FINAL
William & Mary 86
Bethune-Cookman 26 2nd Half 15:49
Mercer 40
Furman 34 2nd Half
Fla Gulf Coast 38
South Dakota St 36 2nd Half 10:10
CS-Bakersfield 40
Milligan 24 2nd Half
Lamar 48
LSU-Alexandria 27 2nd Half
ULM 31
Southern Utah 20 1st Half 0:50
Loyola-Chicago 38
Chattanooga 18 1st Half 0:51
Middle Tennessee 29
Seattle 15 1st Half 5:11
Minnesota 33
Lipscomb 27 2nd Half
Princeton 44
Winthrop 32 2nd Half
SE Louisiana 44
Dickinson State 13 1st Half 0:05
North Dakota 33
New Orleans 21 1st Half 1:48
Southern Ill 29
TX-Pan American 8:00 PM
Creighton
Colorado State 8:00 PM
Denver
Alabama A&M 8:00 PM
Marquette
Ark-Pine Bluff 8:00 PM
Texas Tech
Eastern Wash 9:00 PM
California
Idaho State 9:05 PM
Utah State
Arizona 10:00 PM
Texas-El Paso
Hawaii 10:59 PM
Chaminade
Nevada 12/20/14 10:00 AM
Louisiana
Utah State 12/20/14 1:20 PM
Texas-El Paso
(23) Utah 12/20/14 2:30 PM
Colorado State
Western Mich 12/20/14 4:45 PM
Air Force
South Alabama 12/20/14 8:15 PM
Bowling Green
BYU 12/22/14 1:00 PM
Memphis
Marshall 12/23/14 5:00 PM
Northern Ill
Navy 12/23/14 8:30 PM
San Diego St
Central Mich 12/24/14 11:00 AM
Western Ky
Fresno State 12/24/14 7:00 PM
Rice
Illinois 12/26/14 12:00 PM
Louisiana Tech
Rutgers 12/26/14 3:30 PM
North Carolina
NC State 12/26/14 7:00 PM
UCF
Ohio Valley 33 FINAL
Youngstown St 84
East Tenn St 48 FINAL
UNC-Wilmington 61
Cal-Irvine 44 FINAL
Purdue 69
Campbell 63 FINAL
Stetson 76
Jacksonville St 70 FINAL
Charleston Southern 43
Louisiana 64 FINAL
Alcorn State 57
Denver 63 FINAL
Wright State 72
Blue Mountain 30 FINAL
Central Arkansas 71
Texas State 51 FINAL
Bethune-Cookman 40
Albany 62 FINAL
Pepperdine 36
TX-San Antonio 53 FINAL
Houston 56
Yale 66 FINAL
Bucknell 73
Northern Colorado 56 FINAL
Fla Gulf Coast 69
Belmont 86 FINAL
Mercer 83
Massachusetts 66 FINAL
Georgia State 71
George Mason 69 FINAL
Winthrop 57
Portland State 33 FINAL
Princeton 104
UCLA 71 FINAL
Samford 52
Mobile 30 FINAL
Alabama State 66
Nicholls 49 FINAL
Texas Tech 76
Toledo 65 FINAL
Nevada 56
UMass Lowell 48 FINAL
(13) Duke 95
McMurry 49 FINAL
Houston Baptist 69
Siena 62 FINAL
Binghamton 53
(19) Syracuse 72 FINAL
(9) Baylor 74
Canisius 43 FINAL
Michigan 79
St Marys-CA 44 2nd Half 2:18
Virginia 49
McNeese State 45 2nd Half 3:02
Rice 48
NJIT 62 2nd Half 1:04
Seton Hall 74
(6) North Carolina 61 2nd Half 3:40
Maine 32
Lafayette 58 2nd Half 0:03
Stony Brook 60
Longwood 46 2nd Half 3:33
Clemson 65
Savannah State 46 2nd Half 3:11
Florida State 85
Buffalo 60 2nd Half 2:49
Manhattan 51
Davidson 59 2nd Half 1:52
NC State 74
Northern Ky 60 2nd Half 1:54
Delaware 56
Saint Louis 42 2nd Half 15:59
Austin Peay 51
(25) DePaul 42 2nd Half 14:50
(2) Connecticut 66
Ohio U 44 2nd Half
La Salle 38
Florida Atlantic 33 1st Half 0:31
Long Beach St 35
Miami-Florida 13 1st Half 10:00
Tulane 10
Miss Valley St 19 2nd Half
Memphis 32
Ark-Pine Bluff 61 2nd Half 4:12
UAB 32
Bowling Green 25 1st Half 2:30
Illinois State 16
Arkansas State 31 2nd Half
Missouri State 37
ULM 14 2nd Half
Wichita State 30
(16) Oregon State 8:00 PM
Southern Ill
Utah Valley U 8:30 PM
Montana
Pacific 9:00 PM
New Mexico St
No Dakota State 9:00 PM
Cal State Fullerton
Utah State 9:00 PM
Sacramento St
Bethesda (CA) 9:00 PM
Fresno State
LSU 9:30 PM
UC Santa Barbara
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Should the lake where the albino muskie was caught remain a mystery?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close