Funding natural resources: A fair share?

  • Article by: DOUG SMITH , Star Tribune
  • Updated: October 29, 2008 - 5:01 AM

Lottery revenue never was considered the cure for state environmental and natural resource problems and contributes just a small share.

You've seen the ads touting the Minnesota lottery's contributions to the environment.

And it's true, the lottery -- launched in 1991 -- has directed millions of dollars to the environment and natural resources during the past 18 years.

So why are people pushing for the Clean Water, Land and Legacy Amendment on next week's ballot? That constitutional amendment proposal would increase the state sales tax by three-eighths of 1 percent to fund cleanup of lakes and rivers, pay for fish and wildlife habitat, parks and trails, and arts and cultural projects.

It's because even supporters say the lottery hasn't been -- and was never intended to be -- a panacea to deal with the many environmental and natural resource issues facing the state. Fewer than 12 cents of every dollar spent on the lottery goes to natural resources. Sixty-five cents goes to prizes and commissions, and almost 15 cents goes into the state's general fund.

"People think the lottery dollars are the answers to our problems, but the lottery provides a small fraction of the money needed for environmental issues,'' said former state Rep. Dennis Ozment, R-Rosemount, a 24-year veteran of the Legislature who decided not to seek re-election this year.

Just cleaning up the state's polluted waters could cost $80 million to $100 million yearly for at least the next 10 years, Ozment said. He supports the amendment. About $258 million in lottery funds has been spent on various natural resource projects.

That's an average of about $14.3 million yearly.

"The lottery just doesn't provide enough funds to address critical issues for natural resources," said Steve Morse, executive director of the Minnesota Environmental Partnership and a former state legislator and Department of Natural Resources deputy commissioner. Morse also supports the constitutional amendment, noting it would generate nearly 10 times as much money as the lottery does for natural resources.

Opponents of the constitutional amendment argue the state already generates enough dollars for natural resources. They also object to a tax increase and to using the state constitution to dedicate funding.

"There's not a shortage of revenue, it's how it's being spent," said Phil Krinkie, president of the Taxpayers League of Minnesota, which opposes the amendment.

Supporters counter that the Legislature never has sufficiently funded natural resources, which receive less than 2 percent of the state budget. Morse and others say the lottery's legislative history supports their argument for constitutionally dedicated conservation funding.

Fifty percent of lottery proceeds were originally supposed to go to natural resources. Legislators later changed that to 40 percent and also "taxed" the first 6.5 percent of revenue in lieu of a sales tax and sent the proceeds to the state's general fund.

(Since 2000, 72 percent of that 6.5 percent has gone to fish, wildlife, parks, trails and zoos. The remaining 27 percent still goes to the general fund.)

Amendment supporters also point out that for 40 years, a tax on cigarettes funneled $350 million to natural resources, but legislators diverted that money in 2003 to the general fund because of a budget shortfall.

"Every other fund was raided by the Legislature, but the lottery funds are still there because it was constitutionally dedicated," Morse said.

The Taxpayer's League buttresses its argument by noting that the Environment and Natural Resource Trust Fund has $438 million in it. But the fund was set up to be perpetual; only 5.5 percent of its value -- about $25 million this year -- can be spent annually. (The principle is invested and had been earning about 8 percent annually, but the stock market collapse has caused the fund to lose $27 million in value since June.)

Under the law, lottery funds will stop flowing to the fund in 2025. By then, there should be an estimated $1 billion in the fund, which should generate about $55 million yearly -- forever.

Trust fund appropriation is overseen by the Legislative-Citizens Commission on Minnesota Resources (LCCMR), a group comprised of citizens and legislators. The Legislature and governor must approve the commission's recommendations.

Ozment said the amendment allows voters to decide how important natural resources are to the state. He sees few options. The state is facing another budget deficit. And other issues, such as transportation and health care, always are a priority.

Ozment says the choice is either pay a small sales tax increase now, or pay more later.

"Our environment has the ability to absorb short-term neglect. What it can't do is absorb long-term neglect. If the public doesn't do this now, they will end up paying big sums of money later to try to correct the problem. Because it's not going away.''

For more information, see or

  • related content

  • Environmental expenditures

    Tuesday October 28, 2008

    Since 1991, when the Minnesota Lottery began, about $258 million has been spent from the Environmental Trust Fund, which is funded by lottery proceeds. That averages about $14.3 million a...

  • Fearful Minnesota arts groups hope for tax windfall

    Tuesday October 28, 2008

    If the Legacy Amendment passes, it could triple the arts budget. But that's not how to do business, critics say.

  • Amendment supporters pitch ballot issue

    Wednesday October 29, 2008

    Supporters of the constitutional amendment that would increase the Minnesota sales tax and dedicate most of the revenue to natural resources held news conferences around the state Tuesday. The group...

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

Click here to send us your hunting or fishing photos – and to see what others are showing off from around the region.


Golden State 7:00 PM
Oklahoma City 9:30 PM
Vancouver 1 1st Prd 5:23
Buffalo 1
Arizona 1 1st Prd 5:30
NY Rangers 1
Montreal 3 1st Prd 4:18
Columbus 1
Philadelphia 6:30 PM
Chicago 6:30 PM
St. Louis 7:00 PM
Minnesota 7:30 PM
Ottawa 9:30 PM
Los Angeles
Detroit 9:30 PM
San Jose
Northern Ky 78 FINAL
Kennesaw St 53
East Tenn St 56 2nd Half 6:50
Citadel 61
Winthrop 21 1st Half 4:53
Campbell 20
Delaware 24 1st Half 6:36
Drexel 17
Jacksonville St 21 1st Half 2:58
Eastern Ky 27
Northeastern 21 1st Half 4:25
Elon 23
Sacred Heart 31 1st Half 5:11
Fair-Dickinson 34
Western Carolina 24 1st Half 4:45
Furman 15
Char Southern 22 1st Half 7:59
Gardner-Webb 28
Western Ill 21 1st Half 7:41
Nebraska Omaha 18 1st Half 7:54
IUPU-Ft Wayne 22
Radford 14 1st Half 7:48
Liberty 24
St Francis-NY 16 1st Half 7:54
Long Island 22
Wofford 27 1st Half 3:05
Mercer 20
Minnesota 19 1st Half 8:37
Michigan State 27
High Point 33 1st Half 5:19
UNC-Asheville 29
Samford 22 1st Half 7:59
UNC Greensboro 24
Nebraska 15 1st Half 4:04
Ohio State 35
Wagner 22 1st Half 6:00
Robert Morris 30
Mount St Marys 12 1st Half 7:40
St Francis-PA 22
Houston 31 1st Half 5:19
Temple 26
Vanderbilt 19 1st Half 5:05
Tennessee 21
Chattanooga 28 1st Half 6:32
Va Military 29
Milwaukee 24 1st Half 6:50
Wright State 20
Coastal Carolina 18 1st Half 7:40
Presbyterian 18
Central Conn St 23 1st Half 5:30
Bryant 21
Ga Southern 6:30 PM
Appalachian St
SIU Edwardsville 7:00 PM
Austin Peay
Green Bay 7:00 PM
Texas-El Paso 7:00 PM
Louisiana Tech
FIU 7:00 PM
Rider 7:00 PM
Eastern Ill 7:00 PM
Murray State
Charlotte 7:00 PM
North Texas
North Dakota St 7:00 PM
Oral Roberts
Old Dominion 7:00 PM
TX-San Antonio 7:00 PM
Southern Miss
UT Martin 7:00 PM
Tennessee St
Fla Atlantic 7:00 PM
Western Ky
Northern Ariz 7:00 PM
North Dakota
Grand Canyon 7:05 PM
Chicago State
Utah Valley U 7:05 PM
ULM 7:05 PM
South Alabama
Texas-Arlington 7:30 PM
Arkansas State
Georgia State 7:30 PM
Ark-Little Rock
Troy 7:30 PM
Texas State
Arizona 8:00 PM
SMU 8:00 PM
Tenn Tech 8:00 PM
Morehead State
Rutgers 8:00 PM
Southern Utah 8:00 PM
Northern Colorado
Montana State 8:05 PM
Eastern Wash
UC Davis 9:00 PM
UC Santa Barbara
UC Irvine 9:00 PM
Cal Poly
Cal State Fullerton 9:00 PM
Montana 9:00 PM
BYU 9:00 PM
Pacific 9:00 PM
Santa Clara
Arizona State 9:30 PM
San Diego 10:00 PM
St Marys-CA 10:00 PM
San Francisco
Oregon State 10:00 PM
Long Beach State 10:59 PM
Rice 68 FINAL
Old Dominion 83
Georgia Southern 39 FINAL
Appalachian St 66
Manhattan 67 FINAL
Monmouth 84
Marshall 74 FINAL
FIU 50
TX-Arlington 52 2nd Half 7:01
Arkansas State 54
ULM 35 2nd Half 7:18
South Alabama 30
Georgia State 31 2nd Half
Ark-Little Rock 33
Troy 43 2nd Half 18:35
Texas State 33
LSU 11 1st Half 8:34
Ole Miss 17
(11) Miss State 10 1st Half 8:22
(2) South Carolina 17
North Texas 17 1st Half 9:10
Charlotte 24
Western Ky 23 1st Half 9:03
Florida Atlantic 14
William & Mary 33 1st Half 5:26
Coll of Charleston 26
Delaware 22 1st Half 4:42
UNC-Wilmington 16
UMBC 10 1st Half 6:51
Maine 24
UMass Lowell 27 1st Half 3:57
Vermont 23
Albany 23 1st Half 4:02
Hartford 14
Stony Brook 12 1st Half 7:57
Binghamton 15
Boston College 9 1st Half 10:30
(8) Louisville 22
(23) Syracuse 17 1st Half 10:20
Clemson 13
(16) Duke 13 1st Half 7:50
Georgia Tech 25
Florida 18 1st Half 6:34
Alabama 15
NC State 18 1st Half 6:57
(9) Florida State 28
Miami-Florida 26 1st Half 5:03
Wake Forest 29
Fairfield 27 1st Half 5:40
Iona 17
Marist 21 1st Half 4:54
Saint Peters 19
Quinnipiac 27 1st Half 8:33
Rider 7
Virginia 18 1st Half 7:47
(15) North Carolina 19
Pittsburgh 19 1st Half 6:22
(4) Notre Dame 34
Ohio State 27 1st Half 5:21
Penn State 24
Indiana 25 1st Half 4:51
(5) Maryland 36
Massachusetts 18 1st Half 7:53
Dayton 26
(22) George Washington 25 1st Half 7:24
Richmond 22
Saint Louis 8 1st Half 6:21
Rhode Island 31
Wright State 28 1st Half 4:56
Detroit 24
Green Bay 33 1st Half 4:14
Oakland 15
Central Arkansas 6:30 PM
Sam Houston St
SE Louisiana 6:30 PM
Northwestern St
Missouri 7:00 PM
(12) Texas A&M
Denver 7:00 PM
No Dakota State
IUPU-Ft Wayne 7:00 PM
Nebraska Omaha
South Dakota
Lamar 7:00 PM
McNeese State
Incarnate Word 7:00 PM
Stephen F Austin
Nicholls 7:00 PM
New Orleans
Western Ill 7:00 PM
South Dakota St
Southern Miss 7:00 PM
TX-San Antonio
(13) Kentucky 7:00 PM
Wisconsin 7:00 PM
(17) Iowa
(20) Rutgers 7:00 PM
(25) Northwestern
North Dakota 7:30 PM
Northern Ariz
(24) California 8:00 PM
(19) Stanford 8:00 PM
(7) Oregon State
USC 8:00 PM
Portland 8:00 PM
Gonzaga 8:00 PM
San Diego
San Francisco 8:00 PM
St Marys-CA
Northern Colorado 8:00 PM
Southern Utah
Auburn 8:00 PM
(6) Tennessee 8:00 PM
Chicago State 8:00 PM
Grand Canyon
UMKC 8:00 PM
Utah Valley U
Eastern Washington 8:00 PM
Montana State
Idaho 8:00 PM
Louisiana Tech 0 Postponed
Texas-El Paso 0
UCLA 9:00 PM
Washington St
Santa Clara 9:00 PM
CS-Northridge 9:00 PM
Cal State Fullerton
UC Santa Barbara 9:00 PM
Hawaii 9:00 PM
Long Beach St
Cal Poly 9:00 PM
UC Davis
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters





question of the day

Poll: Should the lake where the albino muskie was caught remain a mystery?

Weekly Question