Anderson: In some ways, deer population fix is up to hunters

  • Article by: DENNIS ANDERSON , Star Tribune
  • Updated: March 21, 2014 - 8:45 AM

DNR’s effort to fix the deer population requires understanding and monitoring.

hide

That walk into the woods is easy. Hunters who want to see the deer population grow have other jobs, too.

Photo: KYNDELL HARKNESS • kyndell.harkness@startribune.com,

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

– Described as a “listening session,’’ a gathering in this central Minnesota town Wednesday evening attracted some 60 deer hunters. At issue was the perception among most in attendance, voiced repeatedly, that too few deer inhabit the surrounding region, a complaint shared in many areas statewide. Doing the listening, and taking notes, were Department of Natural Resources wildlife officials.

It’s no easy task, managing deer to socially acceptable population levels, which the DNR attempts to do. For starters, what constitutes such levels is not easily agreed upon. Hunters want a lot of deer. Orchard growers and others in agriculture generally want fewer. In between are homeowners with at-risk shrubbery, car drivers who fear whitetail collisions at freeway speeds, and ecology buffs who believe too many deer inhibit forest plant diversity.

Still, in many parts of the state there are too few deer, in part because weather bets DNR wildlife managers placed a few years back boomeranged. Bad as last winter was, particularly for northern whitetails, this winter is worse. In advance of these, arguably because of bad luck, the DNR allowed hunters to kill too many deer in some parts of the state.

The result, as Dave Sapletal of Brainerd put it Wednesday evening: “The deer are truly down.’’

Added Ron Carlson of Pillager, Minn.: “The deer are down so far I didn’t even hunt my home area.’’

Hearing this, and more, from the frustrated hunters was a phalanx of DNR officials, headed by wildlife section chief Paul Telander. Also present were DNR research boss (and former big game coordinator) Lou Cornicelli, as well as big game program leader Leslie McInenly and wildlife programs manager Steve Merchant, among others.

Organized by the Minnesota Deer Hunters Association, the Brainerd meeting, as well as one held Thursday evening in Cambridge and four others to be held in coming days (none in the Twin Cities), was intended to allow hunters to vent. The underlying assumption — hope — was that the DNR would take the hunters’ concerns to heart and do what’s required to rebuild the state’s whitetail herd.

“I’ve hunted 62 years,’’ said Dave Sapletal of Brainerd, “and in the last three or four years, the bucks just aren’t there. Even in Camp Ripley. I spent 17 hours in a stand there last fall and I didn’t see a single deer.’’

The DNR has begun a multi-year process to recalibrate desired whitetail population levels in various regions of the state. Aiding the undertaking are citizen panels intended to represent a cross-section of affected groups, among them hunters and farmers. The intent is to reach consensus about appropriate whitetail levels in given areas, which, subsequently, the DNR will attempt to achieve by employing various hunter harvest strategies.

Hunters believe they were underrepresented a few years back on similar advisory panels and, as a result, whitetail population goals generally were set too low. The DNR disputes this. But the DNR does not dispute that in many parts of the state, if not most, the agency doesn’t manage deer for maximum density — the land’s “carrying capacity’’ — but instead to levels it believes most everyone can live with, hunter or not.

Given that hunters pay the bills for deer management, more than a few feel gypped by a process that incorporates so completely the interests of other parties, most of whom are wildlife-conservation freeloaders.

Two points:

• If hunters want to ensure that deer in their area and/or statewide are managed at sufficiently high levels, they must do more than come to the odd meeting and complain. Instead, they need to stay engaged in the process of setting population goals to ensure their interests are satisfactorily included in the outcomes. There’s a significant difference between managing for 15 deer per square mile and 25 per square mile, for example, and if the DNR chooses the lower number, it should have to explain why.

• That said, hunters must acknowledge that deer population management includes a lot of guesswork. Harvest strategies are based on information gathered months or even a year earlier. Weather also is a big variable. As is hunter effort. And predators. So hitting a harvest mark, or even a harvest range, isn’t going to happen every year, and DNR deer managers shouldn’t be held to such an impossible standard.

Hunters instead must stay intimately engaged on the front end of the ongoing whitetail population goal-setting process, not only through the advisory panels but afterward, when population levels are announced.

It’s then that hunters should require the DNR to justify its goal numbers and, as necessary, seek their adjustment.

Editor’s note: More on upcoming listening sessions and the goal-setting process is online at www.dnr.state.mn.us/mammals/deer/mgmt.html.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

Click here to send us your hunting or fishing photos – and to see what others are showing off from around the region.

ADVERTISEMENT

Buffalo 17 4th Qtr 6:03
New England 9
Cleveland 10 4th Qtr 13:15
Baltimore 3
Dallas 27 4th Qtr 14:30
Washington 10
Indianapolis 20 4th Qtr 14:56
Tennessee 10
Jacksonville 17 4th Qtr 13:34
Houston 21
San Diego 7 4th Qtr 13:00
Kansas City 19
NY Jets 24 3rd Qtr 0:08
Miami 24
Chicago 6 4th Qtr 9:02
Minnesota 13
Philadelphia 24 3rd Qtr 3:43
NY Giants 19
New Orleans 14 4th Qtr 11:00
Tampa Bay 20
Carolina 3:25 PM
Atlanta
Detroit 3:25 PM
Green Bay
Oakland 3:25 PM
Denver
Arizona 3:25 PM
San Francisco
St. Louis 3:25 PM
Seattle
Cincinnati 7:30 PM
Pittsburgh
TBA 1/3/15 2:00 AM
TBA
TBA 1/3/15 2:00 AM
TBA
TBA 1/4/15 2:00 AM
TBA
TBA 1/4/15 2:00 AM
TBA
Detroit 3:30 PM
Cleveland
Houston 6:00 PM
San Antonio
Oklahoma City 6:30 PM
Dallas
New York 8:00 PM
Portland
Toronto 8:00 PM
Denver
Phoenix 8:30 PM
LA Lakers
Toronto 4:00 PM
Florida
Vancouver 7:00 PM
Anaheim
Tulane 57 FINAL
St Johns 82
Central Conn St 48 FINAL
Connecticut 81
Iona 81 FINAL
Drexel 62
Concordia (MI) 42 FINAL
Eastern Mich 100
Harvard 39 2nd Half 8:50
Arizona State 47
Longwood 39 2nd Half 11:53
Ball State 43
Sacred Heart 58 2nd Half 10:53
Brown 55
Colgate 43 2nd Half 10:32
Columbia 48
MD-Eastern Shore 61 2nd Half 9:02
Duquesne 54
UNC Greensboro 34 2nd Half 12:03
East Carolina 57
Marist 28 2nd Half 11:50
Elon 46
NJIT 43 2nd Half 13:13
Lafayette 45
Cincinnati Christian 34 2nd Half 12:59
Liberty 41
Morgan State 27 2nd Half 15:55
Marquette 43
Campbell 29 2nd Half 12:48
Samford 42
Bucknell 52 2nd Half 11:09
Siena 50
Long Beach State 44 2nd Half 16:13
Syracuse 51
Coppin State 49 2nd Half 12:54
Evansville 58
UMKC 35 2nd Half 13:29
Indiana State 39
Hofstra 45 2nd Half
Long Island 25
Coast Guard 7 1st Half 13:07
Army 19
Thomas (GA) 11 1st Half 11:22
High Point 19
Texas Southern 4 1st Half 12:45
Kansas State 13
Rutgers 14 1st Half 9:47
Monmouth 19
NC Wesleyan 13 1st Half 10:35
NC A&T 11
South Dakota St 6 1st Half 11:55
Northern Iowa 9
Central Penn College 4 1st Half 16:28
Radford 12
Bowling Green 17 1st Half 10:28
South Florida 13
Harris-Stowe 15 1st Half 10:30
SE Missouri St 17
Robert Morris-IL 11 1st Half 10:41
SIU Edwardsville 21
Northland College 21 1st Half 11:04
North Dakota St 19
Milwaukee 11 1st Half 11:26
South Dakota 18
Northwestern St 2:30 PM
Arkansas
Saint Peters 3:00 PM
Cornell
St Katherine 3:00 PM
Fresno State
Haskell 3:00 PM
Oral Roberts
Wake Forest 3:00 PM
Richmond
Fla Gulf Coast 3:00 PM
Xavier
SD Christian 3:05 PM
Northern Ariz
Judson 3:30 PM
IUPU-Ft Wayne
Ill-Chicago 4:00 PM
Bradley
Loyola-Maryland 4:00 PM
Fairfield
Miss Valley St 4:00 PM
Houston
Lehigh 4:00 PM
UMBC
Delaware State 4:00 PM
Temple
Belmont 5:00 PM
Butler
Howard 5:00 PM
Fordham
NW Christian 5:00 PM
Nevada
UC Davis 5:00 PM
Washington St
Abilene Christian 5:00 PM
Grand Canyon
UCLA 5:30 PM
Alabama
Stony Brook 7:00 PM
Washington
Buffalo 7:00 PM
Wisconsin
CS-Bakersfield 9:00 PM
California
Cincinnati 17 FINAL
Virginia Tech 33
(15) Arizona State 36 FINAL
Duke 31
Miami-Florida 21 FINAL
So Carolina 24
Boston College 30 FINAL
Penn State 31
(25) Nebraska 42 FINAL
(24) USC 45
Texas A&M 12/29/14 1:00 PM
West Virginia
Oklahoma 12/29/14 4:30 PM
(18) Clemson
Arkansas 12/29/14 8:00 PM
Texas
Notre Dame 12/30/14 2:00 PM
(22) LSU
(13) Georgia 12/30/14 5:45 PM
(20) Louisville
Maryland 12/30/14 9:00 PM
Stanford
(9) Ole Miss 12/31/14 11:30 AM
(6) TCU
(21) Boise State 12/31/14 3:00 PM
(12) Arizona
(8) Miss State 12/31/14 7:00 PM
(10) Georgia Tech
(19) Auburn 1/1/15 11:00 AM
(17) Wisconsin
(7) Michigan State 1/1/15 11:30 AM
(4) Baylor
(16) Missouri 1/1/15 12:00 PM
Minnesota
(2) Florida State 1/1/15 4:00 PM
(3) Oregon
(5) Ohio State 1/1/15 7:30 PM
(1) Alabama
Houston 1/2/15 11:00 AM
Pittsburgh
Iowa 1/2/15 2:20 PM
Tennessee
(11) Kansas State 1/2/15 5:45 PM
(14) UCLA
Washington 1/2/15 9:15 PM
Oklahoma State
East Carolina 1/3/15 11:00 AM
Florida
Toledo 1/4/15 8:00 PM
Arkansas State
Drexel 71 FINAL
Miami-Ohio 54
Holy Cross 63 FINAL
Norfolk State 62
East Carolina 62 FINAL
South Florida 69
(10) Oregon State 63 FINAL
(8) Tennessee 74
Providence 51 FINAL
Boston College 79
Florida A&M 47 FINAL
Miami-Florida 83
Oakland 69 FINAL
Central Michigan 74
Chattanooga 59 FINAL
SIU-Edwardsville 49
Fairfield 59 FINAL
La Salle 73
St Francis-PA 32 2nd Half 13:12
Pittsburgh 57
Milwaukee 45 2nd Half 11:10
IUPU-Ft Wayne 46
Gardner-Webb 38 2nd Half 11:32
Longwood 38
New Hampshire 36 2nd Half 8:58
Manhattan 38
Bucknell 48 2nd Half 11:14
Binghamton 42
Northeastern 53 2nd Half 7:38
Albany 49
George Mason 39 2nd Half 10:06
Towson 46
Richmond 34 2nd Half 13:38
William & Mary 41
Tulane 32 2nd Half 18:58
Cincinnati 20
North Florida 32 2nd Half 14:12
Florida 42
(14) Georgia 41 2nd Half 12:36
Seton Hall 39
Tennessee St 45 2nd Half 15:20
(12) Kentucky 59
American Univ 43 2nd Half 12:01
Wake Forest 55
Massachusetts 58 2nd Half 13:56
Boston U 38
Quinnipiac 43 2nd Half 14:16
Saint Josephs 39
Lafayette 38 2nd Half 9:08
Saint Peters 22
Northwestern 45 2nd Half 11:45
(20) Michigan State 33
Duquesne 60 2nd Half 8:08
Lehigh 60
George Washington 46 2nd Half 12:00
Loyola-Maryland 32
(17) Rutgers 34 2nd Half 14:30
Indiana 29
(24) Green Bay 52 2nd Half 9:59
Dayton 46
Western Mich 20 1st Half 2:53
Stony Brook 21
Davidson 30 2nd Half
Virginia 34
UNC Greensboro 0 1st Half 19:23
LSU 4
Denver 8 1st Half 11:10
North Texas 8
VA Commonwealth 8 1st Half 10:10
Coppin State 20
Huston-Tillotson 6 1st Half 8:15
Houston Baptist 29
Lamar 16 1st Half 9:31
Rice 20
Miss Valley St 14 1st Half 8:57
Alabama 14
Saint Louis 18 1st Half 10:45
Eastern Illinois 4
Middle Tennessee 19 1st Half 11:59
Tenn Tech 14
Penn State 7 1st Half 12:23
(23) Iowa 16
Purdue 18 1st Half 9:15
Illinois 11
DePaul 10 1st Half 13:58
Illinois State 12
Sam Houston St 4 1st Half 12:32
Wichita State 15
South Dakota 2:30 PM
TX-San Antonio
(4) Notre Dame 3:00 PM
UCLA
Coll of Charleston 3:00 PM
SC State
Alcorn State 3:00 PM
Texas-El Paso
Dartmouth 3:00 PM
Niagara
Colgate 3:00 PM
Siena
Michigan 3:00 PM
Wisconsin
Fla Gulf Coast 3:00 PM
CS-Northridge
Yale 3:30 PM
(25) Arizona State
UC Santa Barbara 4:00 PM
(16) Stanford
Long Island 4:00 PM
Long Beach St
Jackson State 4:00 PM
Louisiana
Eureka 4:30 PM
Western Ill
Cornell 5:00 PM
(22) Syracuse
Temple 7:30 PM
Memphis
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Should the lake where the albino muskie was caught remain a mystery?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close