5-foot strip of land on Medicine Lake provokes two-year war

  • Article by: KELLY SMITH , Star Tribune
  • Updated: March 1, 2014 - 7:54 AM

Dan Gustafson bought a 5-foot strip of land, about as wide as his arms are stretched, between two homes on the shoreline of Medicine Lake.

Photo: Richard Sennott • richard.sennott@startribune.com,

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

Dan Gustafson bought a 5-foot-wide sliver of land wedged between two homes on Medicine Lake just so he could dock his boat there.

The narrow strip of land on the popular Twin Cities lake — a leftover old fire lane — is close to his Minnetonka home, he said, cheaper than buying a lake home and more cost-effective long term than paying thousands of dollars a year in boat slip rentals.

But two years later, he’s still unable to build the dock. The city of Plymouth says zoning rules restrict Gustafson from having a dock and it’s too close to his neighbors.

“We’re trying to do what everybody on the lake and across the state does,” he said. “You own lakeshore, so you want to put up a dock.”

It’s the latest clash between water rights and regulations in Minnesota, where access to water is cherished and the scramble to get a slice of it is intensified with rising lake home prices.

On Wednesday, Gustafson is making his case to the city again, arguing he’s being deprived of his riparian rights as a lake property owner.

“I bought it with the expectation I’d put a dock on it,” he said.

The 5-foot-wide by 100-foot-long property is off South Shore Drive along Medicine Lake, a 925-acre lake near Hwy. 169. Gustafson bought it in 2012 for $30,000, thinking the “anomaly” was the perfect permanent place to dock the 16-foot boat he, his wife and 3- and 1-year-old daughters take to swim, water ski and fish on the lake — without buying a lake home or renting a boat slip.

The city says many lakes used to have these old fire lanes, but most of them were bought up by homeowners. This one remained. Gustafson said the previous owner had a dock on it without issue.

But the city rejected his request, followed by the City Council denying his appeal in October, saying that a dock is an accessory use. City code prevents accessory structures without a principal building — like a house — in that residential zoning area. To clarify the rule, the City Council updated its city code Tuesday to explicitly list docks as an accessory structure.

Changing the rules

Now, Gustafson, a print shop owner, is returning to City Hall on Wednesday, armed with a thick blue binder full of legal paperwork. He’ll ask the Planning Commission to change zoning rules to allow the dock as a principal structure and without setback rules.

In a city report, Planning Manager Barbara Thomson points out that the city already allows docks on some vacant land, and recommends the Planning Commission approve the change to allow docks without a principal building in that particular zoning area.

But she also recommends that docks be set back 6 feet or more from side lot lines — a requirement Gustafson’s 5-foot-wide property wouldn’t meet.

In an interview, she said the setback rule is the same for any accessory structure like a shed, and is needed to prevent conflicts between land uses.

In city documents, City Attorney Roger Knutson advised the commission to make a decision, “based upon public policy and good planning not upon the legal issues” Gustafson raised.

Gustafson argues that common laws give him the right to put up a dock on his shoreline property. He points to a 2006 case where the state Court of Appeals agreed with a Greenwood couple that the Lake Minnetonka Conservation District couldn’t require them to remove a dock on their 12-foot property, even though it didn’t meet 5-foot setback rules.

Similar dock disputes

  • related content

  • DNR opens Pelican Lake in Wright County to unlimited fishing

    Friday February 28, 2014

    The Department of Natural Resources announced the change on Friday, and said liberalized bag limits will continue until sunset March 9. The reason: Low oxygen levels

  • An aerial photo of the 5-foot strip of land owned by Dan Gustafson, where he would like to put in a dock for easy access to the lake.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

Click here to send us your hunting or fishing photos – and to see what others are showing off from around the region.


Atlanta - LP: J. Teheran 2 FINAL
Philadelphia - WP: C. Hamels 9
Washington 0 FINAL
Miami 8
Boston 4 FINAL
Minnesota 4
Detroit 2 FINAL
Houston 3
Toronto - WP: C. Hynes 9 FINAL
Boston - LP: D. Hinojosa 7
Tampa Bay - WP: J. Norberto 3 FINAL
NY Yankees - LP: C. Whitley 0
St. Louis 5 FINAL
NY Mets 4
Los Angeles 4 FINAL
Kansas City 4
LA Angels 1 FINAL
Oakland 4
San Diego 8 FINAL
Chicago WSox 2
Chicago WSox 12 FINAL
Seattle 4
Cleveland 2 FINAL
San Francisco 5
Milwaukee 7 FINAL
Chicago Cubs 11
Arizona 3 FINAL
Cincinnati 0
Texas 4 FINAL
Colorado 10
Pittsburgh 3 Top 10th Inning
Baltimore 3
Detroit 78 FINAL
Charlotte 102
Philadelphia 93 FINAL
Washington 106
San Antonio 103 FINAL
Orlando 91
Indiana 87 FINAL
Boston 100
Brooklyn 96 4th Qtr 1:19
New York 95
Chicago 71 3rd Qtr 1:38
Milwaukee 70
Dallas 101 3rd Qtr 0:04
Oklahoma City 100
Sacramento 88 4th Qtr 11:09
Houston 100
Toronto 86 4th Qtr 11:44
Minnesota 69
Denver 33 2nd Qtr 5:57
Utah 40
LA Clippers 9:00 PM
New Orleans 9:30 PM
LA Lakers
Toronto 3 3rd Prd 9:26
Buffalo 4
Philadelphia 2 3rd Prd
Pittsburgh 1
Edmonton 9:00 PM
Colorado 9:30 PM
San Jose
Loyola-Chicago 59 2nd Half 3:33
ULM 58
Michigan 65
Temple 58 FINAL
West Virginia 66
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters





question of the day

Poll: Should the lake where the albino muskie was caught remain a mystery?

Weekly Question