Anderson: Does feeding help or hurt deer?

  • Article by: DENNIS ANDERSON , Star Tribune
  • Updated: February 9, 2014 - 12:52 AM

Deer Hunters want the deer fed during harsh winters, but the DNR fears it could spread disease.

hide

Some homeowners, driven by concern during cold winters, take it on themselves to feed deer in their back yards.

Photo: CARLOS GONZALEZ, STAR TRIBUNE FILE

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

 

Two things are certain in Minnesota during a tough winter like one the state is experiencing: Some deer are going to die. And the debate over whether to feed deer artificially, particularly in northern Minnesota, in an attempt to minimize losses to the whitetail population will surface.

Such is the case now, as some northern Minnesotans, led by the Minnesota Deer Hunters Association (MDHA), are asking the Department of Natural Resources to initiate a deer feeding program.

“If the DNR doesn’t allow it, I think it would be shortsighted,’’ said Mark Johnson, executive director of the MDHA, headquartered in Grand Rapids. “The public concern in northern Minnesota for our low deer numbers is already intense. No one wants to lose any more animals.’’

So far, however, the DNR is holding fast to its position that deer feeding is ineffective and potentially problematic.

“In recent years we’ve controlled bovine TB in northwest Minnesota and chronic wasting disease in the southeast, and we’ve invested more than $10 million battling those diseases,’’ said Michelle Carstensen, DNR wildlife health program supervisor.

“Feeding deer, because it concentrates animals and brings them into close contact with one another, runs the risk of causing the same problems again.’’

The decision whether to feed deer probably won’t hinge on money availability. For the past 15 years, 50 cents of every deer-hunting license has been assigned to a special deer-feeding fund — an account with a name and purpose that were amended in 2004 so its money also could be spent for CWD and TB studies and eradication.

The fund holds about $800,000.

“We wouldn’t be looking to spend all of it,’’ Johnson said. “I think if we do start a deer-feeding program, it would cost between $100,000 and $200,000.”

Beyond debate is the deadly toll that severe winters can take on deer. A study of northern Minnesota fawn mortality between 1991 and 2005 showed the rate more than doubled in a winter that was above average in severity when compared with an average winter.

Even before the current winter began, many Minnesota deer hunters worried the whitetail population was too small. Last winter was fairly tough, and some animals died. These losses, combined with DNR deer harvest goals that in recent years some hunters believe have been too high, have reduced whitetail numbers unacceptably in many areas, hunters believe.

DNR Commissioner Tom Landwehr said recently he is among hunters who haven’t seen a deer from his stand in four years.

“I also saw zero deer last fall, and I hunted a lot,’’ Johnson said. “I know other hunters who also saw no deer, or few. That’s something the DNR should think about. The multiple licenses I bought last fall cost me $112. Next hunting season I’ll spend just $30 for one license. Multiply the difference between $112 and $30 by hundreds of thousands of deer hunters, and that’s a lot of money.’’

Minnesota’s most recent deer-killing winters occurred back-to-back, in 1995-1996, followed by 1996-1997.

The DNR estimates about 30 percent of the state’s whitetail herd was lost the first winter, followed by about 8 percent the second.

“This winter also has the makings of a severe winter,’’ DNR wildlife section chief Paul Telander said. “But so far it’s not as bad as those two.’’

During those successive bad winters a debate also ensued about deer feeding. The Legislature became involved — not unexpectedly — and ultimately mandated that feeding begin, despite the DNR’s objections.

“Deer have evolved to survive our winters,’’ Telander said. “As a population, they don’t need to be fed.’’

Still, following the tough 1990s-era winters, the Legislature added the 50-cent surcharge to hunters’ licenses to pay for future deer feeding programs, if necessary.

“Even in the last 10 years, after the fund was broadened, the DNR hasn’t attempted to change the name of the account to eliminate ‘deer feeding,’ ’’ Johnson said. “And they’ve never said they wouldn’t feed deer if the situation arose. So we assume that’s what the account is for.’’

In establishing the account, the Legislature also directed the DNR and MDHA leaders to develop deer-feeding guidelines.

The resulting plan calls for the DNR’s Winter Severity Index (WSI) to trigger feeding initiatives. The index, which measures cold temperatures and snow depth to gauge a winter’s severity, must hit 100 points by mid-February for feeding to begin.

So far this winter, the WSI hasn’t reached 100 anywhere in Minnesota, Telander said.

“In northwest Minnesota, it’s in the low 50s,’’ he said. “In Roseau it’s in the mid-70s. It’s highest near International Falls, because of the deep snow they have. It’s probably in the 80-90 range there.’’

The state’s deer-feeding plan also directs the DNR to provide technical assistance, and to order and distribute feed to nonprofit sportsmen’s organizations such as MDHA chapters.

The chapters in turn would distribute the feed.

Johnson questions the accuracy of the DNR’s winter severity readings and says that in any event, deer are hurting.

“Look,’’ he said. “The possibility of disease transfer is the DNR’s best argument against deer feeding. But if they’re confident their negative testing for TB and CWD is accurate, that shouldn’t be an issue.

“Most deer up north don’t get old enough to get sick, anyway. Wolves kill them first.’’

Friday afternoon, Telander, DNR fish and wildlife division director Ed Boggess and Johnson held a conference call, after which the DNR officials said they would take the MDHA’s concerns to Landwehr and have a DNR determination on deer feeding by midweek.

Meanwhile, the wild card in the controversy has been played.

Northern Minnesota legislators, including powerful committee chairs and Senate Majority Leader Tom Bakk, DFL-Cook, are aware of the fray, Johnson said, and likely will support deer feeding.

 

Dennis Anderson danderson@startribune.com

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

Click here to send us your hunting or fishing photos – and to see what others are showing off from around the region.

ADVERTISEMENT

Cleveland 11/23/14 12:00 PM
Atlanta
Tennessee 11/23/14 12:00 PM
Philadelphia
Detroit 11/23/14 12:00 PM
New England
Green Bay 11/23/14 12:00 PM
Minnesota
Jacksonville 11/23/14 12:00 PM
Indianapolis
Cincinnati 11/23/14 12:00 PM
Houston
Tampa Bay 11/23/14 12:00 PM
Chicago
Arizona 11/23/14 3:05 PM
Seattle
St. Louis 11/23/14 3:05 PM
San Diego
Miami 11/23/14 3:25 PM
Denver
Washington 11/23/14 3:25 PM
San Francisco
Dallas 11/23/14 7:30 PM
NY Giants
NY Jets 11/24/14 6:00 PM
Buffalo
Baltimore 11/24/14 7:30 PM
New Orleans
Chicago 11/27/14 11:30 AM
Detroit
Philadelphia 11/27/14 3:30 PM
Dallas
Seattle 11/27/14 7:30 PM
San Francisco
Phoenix 6:00 PM
Indiana
Miami 6:00 PM
Orlando
Philadelphia 6:30 PM
New York
Toronto 6:30 PM
Cleveland
Dallas 7:00 PM
Houston
Sacramento 7:00 PM
Minnesota
Brooklyn 7:30 PM
San Antonio
Washington 7:30 PM
Milwaukee
New Orleans 8:00 PM
Utah
St. Louis 3 2nd Prd 1:38
Ottawa 2
Montreal 6:00 PM
Boston
Detroit 6:00 PM
Toronto
Minnesota 6:00 PM
Tampa Bay
Pittsburgh 6:00 PM
NY Islanders
Columbus 6:00 PM
Philadelphia
Buffalo 6:00 PM
Washington
Florida 7:00 PM
Nashville
Los Angeles 7:00 PM
Dallas
Carolina 8:00 PM
Colorado
New Jersey 9:00 PM
Calgary
Chicago 9:00 PM
Edmonton
Arizona 9:30 PM
San Jose
Incarnate Word 79 FINAL
Princeton 68
Robert Morris 66 FINAL
Georgetown 80
Notre Dame 81 FINAL
Massachusetts 68
Saint Peters 50 FINAL
La Salle 59
Ball State 69 FINAL
IUPUI 71
Utah State 63 FINAL
Miss State 71
High Point 56 FINAL
Richmond 80
Appalachian St 65 FINAL
Virginia Tech 63
Drake 75 FINAL
Western Mich 91
Samford 72 FINAL
CS-Northridge 79
Colgate 53 FINAL
Campbell 48
North Carolina 90 FINAL
Davidson 72
North Florida 49 FINAL
Northern Iowa 66
UMass Lowell 63 FINAL
NJIT 61
Nebraska Omaha 95 2nd Half 0:18
Marquette 89
Clemson 59 FINAL
Nevada 50
Florida State 54 FINAL
Providence 80
South Alabama 38 2nd Half 7:37
Detroit 52
Texas State 59 2nd Half 8:36
TX-San Antonio 60
Trinity Christian 29 2nd Half 16:41
Chicago State 51
Liberty 22 1st Half 2:52
Miami-Ohio 20
Western State 28 1st Half 4:58
Air Force 32
Elon 25 1st Half 5:19
Northwestern 20
Canisius 25 1st Half 3:35
St Bonaventure 20
MD-Eastern Shore 19 1st Half 2:45
St Francis-PA 29
Cleveland State 25 1st Half 7:01
Savannah State 26
SE Missouri St 29 1st Half 4:25
Central Arkansas 19
UMKC 3:30 PM
Ark-Little Rock
Southern U 5 1st Half 15:42
Middle Tennessee 13
Longwood 6 1st Half 15:42
Youngstown St 7
Towson 4:00 PM
Bethune-Cookman
Loyola-Maryland 4:00 PM
Butler
San Jose St 4:00 PM
Cal State Fullerton
Texas Southern 4:00 PM
Norfolk State
Yale 4:00 PM
Southern Ill
LSU 4:00 PM
Weber State
South Dakota 4:00 PM
Wofford
Duquesne 4:00 PM
Abilene Christian
Wright State 4:30 PM
Char Southern
Miles 4:30 PM
Jacksonville St
Binghamton 4:30 PM
Manhattan
Alcorn State 4:30 PM
Kennesaw St
Bob Jones Univ 5:00 PM
Citadel
Piedmont Coll 5:00 PM
Coastal Carolina
Johnson University 5:00 PM
Ga Southern
Brown 5:00 PM
Indiana State
Colorado 5:00 PM
Wyoming
Quinnipiac 6:00 PM
Albany
Mount St Marys 6:00 PM
Bucknell
Master's College 6:00 PM
UC Santa Barbara
UNC-Asheville 6:00 PM
East Tenn St
Clermont College 6:00 PM
Eastern Ky
UNC Greensboro 6:00 PM
Eastern Mich
Sam Houston St 6:00 PM
Fairfield
American Univ 6:00 PM
Louisiana Tech
Army 6:00 PM
Marist
Hartford 6:00 PM
Niagara
Lafayette 6:00 PM
Penn
Nebraska 6:00 PM
Rhode Island
Vermont 6:00 PM
Saint Josephs
Eastern Wash 6:00 PM
SMU
UNLV 6:00 PM
Temple
Chattanooga 6:00 PM
Tenn Tech
UNC-Wilmington 6:00 PM
Va Military
Ohio Midwestern 6:00 PM
Northern Ky
UC Davis 6:30 PM
Furman
Ill-Chicago 6:30 PM
Kent State
Transylvania 6:30 PM
Lipscomb
Central Conn St 6:30 PM
Monmouth
Oakwood 7:00 PM
Alabama A&M
Morgan State 7:00 PM
Houston
Lamar 7:00 PM
Indiana
Northeastern 7:00 PM
Navy
William & Mary 7:00 PM
Rice
Missouri State 7:00 PM
Texas Tech
TX A&M-Kingsville 7:00 PM
TX-Pan American
Southern-New Orleans 7:00 PM
Tulane
SE Louisiana 7:00 PM
Western Ill
Belmont 7:00 PM
Western Ky
Hampton 7:00 PM
North Dakota St
UMBC 7:30 PM
Minnesota
Houston Baptist 7:30 PM
Texas-Arlington
St Thomas Aquinas 8:00 PM
Gonzaga
Utah Valley U 8:00 PM
Southern Utah
New Mexico St 8:00 PM
Texas-El Paso
Stanford 8:30 PM
Duke
Morehead State 8:30 PM
Presbyterian
SIU Edwardsville 9:00 PM
Portland
Boise State 9:00 PM
Wisconsin
Valparaiso 11/23/14 8:30 AM
Maine
Kent State 0 Cancelled
Buffalo 0
Texas-El Paso 13 FINAL
Rice 31
Air Force 14 FINAL
San Diego St 30
San Jose St 7 FINAL
Utah State 41
Char Southern 9 FINAL
(9) Georgia 55
South Alabama 12 FINAL
So Carolina 37
Rutgers 3 FINAL
(10) Michigan State 45
Minnesota 28 FINAL
(21) Nebraska 24
Northwestern 38 FINAL
Purdue 14
(18) Marshall 23 FINAL
UAB 18
Kansas 7 4th Qtr 5:44
(23) Oklahoma 44
Indiana 27 FINAL 0:00
(7) Ohio State 42
Penn State 14 FINAL
Illinois 16
(14) Eastern Ky 3 FINAL
Florida 52
TX-San Antonio 7 FINAL
Western Ky 45
SMU 7 FINAL
UCF 53
Tulsa 28 FINAL
Houston 38
Virginia Tech 3 FINAL
Wake Forest 6
Washington St 24 4th Qtr 0:27
(13) Arizona State 52
Louisiana Tech 27 FINAL
Old Dominion 30
Western Mich 32 FINAL
Central Mich 20
New Mexico 20 4th Qtr 4:32
(22) Colorado State 58
Eastern Mich 16 4th Qtr 13:30
Ball State 35
Appalachian St 21 4th Qtr 12:35
Louisiana 16
(15) Arizona 7 2nd Qtr 5:39
(20) Utah 0
FIU 7 2nd Qtr 6:05
North Texas 14
(8) Ole Miss 0 2nd Qtr 13:00
Arkansas 17
Louisville 17 2nd Qtr 9:01
Notre Dame 6
Maryland 3 2nd Qtr 7:41
Michigan 6
Texas Tech 14 2nd Qtr 9:29
Iowa State 14
(14) Wisconsin 9 2nd Qtr 4:11
Iowa 3
Syracuse 0 2nd Qtr 5:10
Pittsburgh 10
Boston College 10 2nd Qtr 3:51
(1) Florida State 10
Georgia State 0 2nd Qtr 6:48
Clemson 14
Tulane 3 2nd Qtr 9:22
East Carolina 10
Stanford 10 1st Qtr 4:20
California 0
Western Carolina 7 1st Qtr 3:16
(2) Alabama 10
ULM 10 1st Qtr 1:51
New Mexico St 0
So Florida 3 1st Qtr 2:54
Memphis 7
Colorado 3:30 PM
(3) Oregon
Fla Atlantic 6:00 PM
Middle Tennessee
Samford 6:00 PM
(16) Auburn
Miami-Florida 6:00 PM
Virginia
Vanderbilt 6:30 PM
(4) Miss State
(19) Missouri 6:30 PM
Tennessee
Oklahoma State 6:30 PM
(6) Baylor
(24) USC 7:00 PM
(11) UCLA
Cincinnati 7:00 PM
Connecticut
Boise State 9:15 PM
Wyoming
Oregon State 9:30 PM
Washington
Fresno State 9:30 PM
Nevada
UNLV 10:00 PM
Hawaii
Ohio U 11/25/14 6:00 PM
Miami-Ohio
LSU 11/27/14 6:30 PM
Texas A&M
(5) TCU 11/27/14 6:30 PM
Texas
Northern Ill 11/28/14 10:00 AM
Western Mich
(21) Nebraska 11/28/14 11:00 AM
Iowa
Western Ky 11/28/14 11:00 AM
(18) Marshall
UCF 11/28/14 11:00 AM
So Florida
Houston 11/28/14 11:00 AM
SMU
Akron 11/28/14 12:00 PM
Kent State
Ball State 11/28/14 12:00 PM
Bowling Green
Buffalo 11/28/14 12:00 PM
Massachusetts
Toledo 11/28/14 12:00 PM
Eastern Mich
Arkansas 11/28/14 1:30 PM
(19) Missouri
Navy 11/28/14 2:00 PM
South Alabama
(13) Arizona State 11/28/14 2:30 PM
(15) Arizona
Stanford 11/28/14 2:30 PM
(11) UCLA
(22) Colorado State 11/28/14 2:30 PM
Air Force
Virginia 11/28/14 7:00 PM
Virginia Tech
East Carolina 11/28/14 7:30 PM
Tulsa
BYU 11/29/14 2:00 AM
California
(20) Utah 11/29/14 2:00 AM
Colorado
(3) Oregon 11/29/14 2:00 AM
Oregon State
Kentucky 11/29/14 2:00 AM
Louisville
Notre Dame 11/29/14 2:00 AM
(24) USC
So Carolina 11/29/14 2:00 AM
Clemson
Florida 11/29/14 2:00 AM
(1) Florida State
Wake Forest 11/29/14 2:00 AM
(25) Duke
Pittsburgh 11/29/14 2:00 AM
Miami-Florida
North Texas 11/29/14 11:00 AM
TX-San Antonio
Old Dominion 11/29/14 11:00 AM
Fla Atlantic
(17) Georgia Tech 11/29/14 11:00 AM
(9) Georgia
West Virginia 11/29/14 11:00 AM
Iowa State
Rice 11/29/14 11:00 AM
Louisiana Tech
Michigan 11/29/14 11:00 AM
(7) Ohio State
Purdue 11/29/14 11:00 AM
Indiana
Illinois 11/29/14 11:00 AM
Northwestern
Cincinnati 11/29/14 11:00 AM
Temple
NC State 11/29/14 11:30 AM
North Carolina
Syracuse 11/29/14 11:30 AM
Boston College
Louisiana 11/29/14 11:30 AM
Troy
Texas State 11/29/14 1:00 PM
Georgia State
Idaho 11/29/14 1:00 PM
Appalachian St
Wyoming 11/29/14 2:00 PM
New Mexico
New Mexico St 11/29/14 2:00 PM
Arkansas State
UAB 11/29/14 2:30 PM
Southern Miss
(4) Miss State 11/29/14 2:30 PM
(8) Ole Miss
(10) Michigan State 11/29/14 2:30 PM
Penn State
Minnesota 11/29/14 2:30 PM
(14) Wisconsin
(6) Baylor 11/29/14 2:30 PM
Texas Tech
Rutgers 11/29/14 2:30 PM
Maryland
San Jose St 11/29/14 2:30 PM
San Diego St
Tennessee 11/29/14 3:00 PM
Vanderbilt
Kansas 11/29/14 3:00 PM
(12) Kansas State
Connecticut 11/29/14 3:00 PM
Memphis
ULM 11/29/14 5:00 PM
Ga Southern
Middle Tennessee 11/29/14 6:00 PM
Texas-El Paso
Hawaii 11/29/14 6:00 PM
Fresno State
(16) Auburn 11/29/14 6:45 PM
(2) Alabama
Utah State 11/29/14 9:15 PM
Boise State
Washington 11/29/14 9:30 PM
Washington St
Nevada 11/29/14 9:30 PM
UNLV
Montreal 11/23/14 12:00 PM
Hamilton
Edmonton 11/23/14 3:30 PM
Calgary
TBA 11/30/14 5:00 PM
TBA
Grand Canyon 77 FINAL
Austin Peay 84
Bowling Green 60 FINAL
Milwaukee 50
St Bonaventure 68 FINAL
Detroit 56
Illinois-Chicago 72 FINAL
Miami-Ohio 69
Louisiana Tech 55 FINAL
Louisiana 58
MD-Eastern Shore 57 FINAL
Marshall 74
Butler 77 FINAL
Fairfield 81
Central Conn St 81 FINAL
UMass Lowell 58
Bucknell 61 FINAL
Fairleigh Dickinson 60
St Marys-CA 57 FINAL
UC Davis 55
UNC-Asheville 53 FINAL
South Florida 97
Colgate 51 FINAL
Drexel 59
Niagara 64 FINAL
Buffalo 73
Vermont 61 FINAL
Boston U 66
Marist 51 FINAL
Northeastern 58
UNC-Wilmington 72 FINAL
Appalachian St 82
Duquesne 52 FINAL
Green Bay 84
Saint Josephs 75 FINAL
Liberty 76
Army 81 FINAL
Manhattan 49
Eastern Michigan 75 FINAL
TX-Pan American 81
Southern Ill 50 FINAL
Wright State 70
Youngstown St 70 FINAL
Radford 44
Stetson 62 FINAL
Indiana State 52
Rockhurst 56 2nd Half 4:32
UMKC 47
Ark-Little Rock 49 2nd Half 4:30
Rice 30
(23) Syracuse 71 2nd Half 6:10
Jacksonville 39
NC Central 37 2nd Half 8:10
Gardner-Webb 63
New Orleans 48 2nd Half 3:41
Jacksonville St 58
(22) Rutgers 50 2nd Half 8:19
LSU 43
Missouri State 30 2nd Half 4:06
(21) Oklahoma St 70
Eastern Washington 37 2nd Half 8:57
SMU 57
Houston Baptist 50 2nd Half 5:20
Texas State 53
TX-Arlington 41 2nd Half 11:00
Wichita State 46
(9) Maryland 29 2nd Half
George Washington 30
Presbyterian 37 2nd Half 13:23
Western Carolina 30
St Francis-NY 23 1st Half 3:45
Rider 23
Central Arkansas 23 1st Half 5:07
Jackson State 16
Kennesaw St 28 1st Half 2:00
Georgia Southern 22
Loyola-Chicago 18 1st Half 4:55
Northern Ky 10
Howard 21 1st Half 5:45
La Salle 26
San Jose St 4:00 PM
Cal-Irvine
Tennessee St 4:00 PM
Lipscomb
San Francisco 4:00 PM
UC-Riverside
Temple 4:00 PM
Kansas
San Diego 4:00 PM
Idaho
Concordia (OR) 4:00 PM
(20) Oregon State
Corban 4:00 PM
Portland State
Charleston Southern 5:00 PM
Wofford
UT Martin 5:00 PM
Pepperdine
Eastern Kentucky 5:00 PM
Mercer
Weber State 5:00 PM
Utah Valley U
North Dakota 5:30 PM
Towson
Seton Hall 6:00 PM
Penn State
LSU-Shreveport 6:00 PM
Grambling
Brown 6:00 PM
New Hampshire
Penn 6:00 PM
Navy
Xavier 6:00 PM
Binghamton
Georgetown 6:30 PM
Alabama
(13) Kentucky 7:00 PM
Central Michigan
Texas Southern 7:00 PM
TCU
South Dakota St 7:00 PM
(18) DePaul
Talladega 7:00 PM
Ark-Pine Bluff
Arkansas State 7:00 PM
Colorado
Alcorn State 7:00 PM
UAB
Tenn Tech 7:05 PM
Valparaiso
Dayton 7:30 PM
(19) Iowa
Nevada 8:30 PM
BYU
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Should the lake where the albino muskie was caught remain a mystery?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close