Anderson: Does feeding help or hurt deer?

  • Article by: DENNIS ANDERSON , Star Tribune
  • Updated: February 9, 2014 - 12:52 AM

Deer Hunters want the deer fed during harsh winters, but the DNR fears it could spread disease.

hide

Some homeowners, driven by concern during cold winters, take it on themselves to feed deer in their back yards.

Photo: CARLOS GONZALEZ, STAR TRIBUNE FILE

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

 

Two things are certain in Minnesota during a tough winter like one the state is experiencing: Some deer are going to die. And the debate over whether to feed deer artificially, particularly in northern Minnesota, in an attempt to minimize losses to the whitetail population will surface.

Such is the case now, as some northern Minnesotans, led by the Minnesota Deer Hunters Association (MDHA), are asking the Department of Natural Resources to initiate a deer feeding program.

“If the DNR doesn’t allow it, I think it would be shortsighted,’’ said Mark Johnson, executive director of the MDHA, headquartered in Grand Rapids. “The public concern in northern Minnesota for our low deer numbers is already intense. No one wants to lose any more animals.’’

So far, however, the DNR is holding fast to its position that deer feeding is ineffective and potentially problematic.

“In recent years we’ve controlled bovine TB in northwest Minnesota and chronic wasting disease in the southeast, and we’ve invested more than $10 million battling those diseases,’’ said Michelle Carstensen, DNR wildlife health program supervisor.

“Feeding deer, because it concentrates animals and brings them into close contact with one another, runs the risk of causing the same problems again.’’

The decision whether to feed deer probably won’t hinge on money availability. For the past 15 years, 50 cents of every deer-hunting license has been assigned to a special deer-feeding fund — an account with a name and purpose that were amended in 2004 so its money also could be spent for CWD and TB studies and eradication.

The fund holds about $800,000.

“We wouldn’t be looking to spend all of it,’’ Johnson said. “I think if we do start a deer-feeding program, it would cost between $100,000 and $200,000.”

Beyond debate is the deadly toll that severe winters can take on deer. A study of northern Minnesota fawn mortality between 1991 and 2005 showed the rate more than doubled in a winter that was above average in severity when compared with an average winter.

Even before the current winter began, many Minnesota deer hunters worried the whitetail population was too small. Last winter was fairly tough, and some animals died. These losses, combined with DNR deer harvest goals that in recent years some hunters believe have been too high, have reduced whitetail numbers unacceptably in many areas, hunters believe.

DNR Commissioner Tom Landwehr said recently he is among hunters who haven’t seen a deer from his stand in four years.

“I also saw zero deer last fall, and I hunted a lot,’’ Johnson said. “I know other hunters who also saw no deer, or few. That’s something the DNR should think about. The multiple licenses I bought last fall cost me $112. Next hunting season I’ll spend just $30 for one license. Multiply the difference between $112 and $30 by hundreds of thousands of deer hunters, and that’s a lot of money.’’

Minnesota’s most recent deer-killing winters occurred back-to-back, in 1995-1996, followed by 1996-1997.

The DNR estimates about 30 percent of the state’s whitetail herd was lost the first winter, followed by about 8 percent the second.

“This winter also has the makings of a severe winter,’’ DNR wildlife section chief Paul Telander said. “But so far it’s not as bad as those two.’’

During those successive bad winters a debate also ensued about deer feeding. The Legislature became involved — not unexpectedly — and ultimately mandated that feeding begin, despite the DNR’s objections.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

Click here to send us your hunting or fishing photos – and to see what others are showing off from around the region.

ADVERTISEMENT

NY Mets 1 Top 3rd Inning
Atlanta 2
Philadelphia 1 Top 3rd Inning
NY Yankees 0
Detroit 0 Top 3rd Inning
Baltimore 0
Toronto 1 Bottom 2nd Inning
Pittsburgh 0
Cincinnati 2:05 PM
Cleveland
San Diego 2:05 PM
Seattle
Chicago WSox 2:05 PM
Los Angeles
Kansas City 2:05 PM
Texas
Oakland 2:05 PM
San Francisco
Wisc-Milwaukee 2:05 PM
Milwaukee
Arizona 2:10 PM
Colorado
Univ of Minnesota 6:05 PM
Minnesota
New York 6:00 PM
Indiana
Phoenix 6:00 PM
Orlando
Cleveland 6:30 PM
Toronto
Utah 6:30 PM
Boston
Charlotte 6:30 PM
Brooklyn
Denver 7:00 PM
Minnesota
Detroit 7:00 PM
New Orleans
LA Lakers 7:00 PM
Miami
Philadelphia 7:00 PM
Oklahoma City
Memphis 7:00 PM
Houston
Sacramento 7:30 PM
San Antonio
Milwaukee 9:30 PM
Golden State
Portland 9:30 PM
LA Clippers
Ottawa 6:30 PM
Winnipeg
NY Rangers 7:00 PM
Detroit
Pittsburgh 9:00 PM
Colorado
Montreal 9:00 PM
Anaheim
Longwood 61 2nd Half 3:30
Presbyterian 56
Campbell 1:00 PM
Gardner-Webb
Liberty 5:00 PM
UNC-Asheville
Ohio State 5:00 PM
Penn State
Maine 6:00 PM
Albany
Duquesne 6:00 PM
Fordham
George Washington 6:00 PM
George Mason
Tennessee 6:00 PM
LSU
Notre Dame 6:00 PM
Louisville
SE Missouri St 6:00 PM
Morehead State
St Francis-PA 6:00 PM
Mount St Marys
Hartford 6:00 PM
New Hampshire
Wagner 6:00 PM
Robert Morris
Long Island 6:00 PM
St Francis-NY
La Salle 6:00 PM
Saint Josephs
Providence 6:00 PM
Seton Hall
UCF 6:00 PM
South Florida
Binghamton 6:00 PM
Stony Brook
UMBC 6:00 PM
Vermont
Sacred Heart 6:00 PM
Bryant
Richmond 6:30 PM
Massachusetts
Wake Forest 7:00 PM
Duke
Purdue 7:00 PM
Michigan State
Miami-Florida 7:00 PM
Pittsburgh
St Bonaventure 7:00 PM
Saint Louis
New Mexico St 7:00 PM
TX-Pan American
Houston 7:00 PM
Tulane
Howard 7:00 PM
NJIT
SIU Edwardsville 8:00 PM
Eastern Ill
St Johns 8:00 PM
Marquette
TCU 8:00 PM
Oklahoma State
Cincinnati 8:00 PM
Tulsa
USC 8:00 PM
UCLA
Miss State 8:00 PM
Vanderbilt
Utah State 8:00 PM
Wyoming
Air Force 9:00 PM
Fresno State
Nebraska 9:00 PM
Illinois
Colorado State 9:00 PM
Nevada
Boise State 9:00 PM
San Jose St
San Diego St 10:00 PM
UNLV
Oregon 10:00 PM
Oregon State
UC Santa Barbara 10:59 PM
Hawaii
Toledo 61 2nd Half 0:59
Northern Ill 64
Wake Forest 21 1st Half 8:30
Boston College 15
Eastern Illinois 19 2nd Half
UT Martin 33
Austin Peay 2:00 PM
SIU-Edwardsville
Virginia Tech 2:30 PM
NC State
Massachusetts 3:30 PM
St Bonaventure
Auburn 4:00 PM
Florida
Penn State 5:00 PM
Indiana
Clemson 5:30 PM
Georgia Tech
Davidson 6:00 PM
La Salle
Youngstown St 6:00 PM
Cleveland State
Coll of Charleston 6:00 PM
James Madison
Delaware 6:00 PM
Elon
Drexel 6:00 PM
Northeastern
Hofstra 6:00 PM
UNC-Wilmington
Towson 6:00 PM
William & Mary
Miami-Ohio 6:00 PM
Akron
Ball State 6:00 PM
Central Michigan
Buffalo 6:00 PM
Bowling Green
Western Mich 6:00 PM
Eastern Michigan
Ohio U 6:00 PM
Kent State
Illinois-Chicago 6:00 PM
Wright State
Loyola-Maryland 6:00 PM
Lafayette
Boston U 6:00 PM
Colgate
Alabama 6:25 PM
Vanderbilt
Detroit 7:00 PM
Milwaukee
Purdue 7:25 PM
Wisconsin
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Should the lake where the albino muskie was caught remain a mystery?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close