8-point deer is a gender-bender

  • Article by: DOUG SMITH , Star Tribune
  • Updated: November 23, 2013 - 9:15 PM

A Champlin hunter saw the rack, took the shot and was stunned to find he’d killed a doe.

Phil Klein of Champlin with an 8-point doe — yes, doe — that he shot recently. The rare critter’s rack was still in full velvet.

Photo: Photo courtesy of Phil Klein,

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

Phil Klein peered into the woods from his deer stand in north-central Minnesota, hunting near his father, when he heard the sound of a doe bleating nearby.

“I knew it was my dad’’ trying to attract a buck by mimicking a doe, he said.

“Five minutes later, this deer comes crashing out of the swamp, about 50 or 60 yards away,’’ Klein said. “At first I thought it was a doe, then I noticed it had antlers. But it looked really odd. I counted 8 points, so I shot.’’

Klein, 29, of Champlin, and his dad, Jeff, 57, of Rogers, were in for a surprise.

“My dad came over to help me find it, and he got to the deer first. All I could hear him yell was ‘velvet!’ ”

The 8-point deer’s antlers were covered in velvet, which should have been long gone by November. “It was in full velvet, 100 percent perfect.’’

Then Klein field-dressed the deer and noticed something else odd: “It didn’t have any male genitalia.’’

His 8-point buck was actually an 8-point doe.

“It really didn’t dawn on me for a while,’’ Klein said. “Then at lunch I told my dad, ‘That thing’s a doe.’ He thought I was crazy.’’

But the pair checked the gut pile for evidence they might have missed, and concluded the deer with male headgear was indeed a female. About 10 family members hunt in his group, and they were astounded.

“My grandpa and his brother have been hunting this land for 40-plus years, and this is the first time we’ve seen anything like this,’’ Klein said. He took some ribbing from his group. “You get a lot of grief for shooting a deer like this,’’ he said.

It could be jealousy. The odds of bagging such a deer are astronomical.

“They’re not common at all,’’ said Lou Cornicelli, Department of Natural Resources wildlife research manager. “It’s an anomaly. We shoot one every couple of years.’’

Last year, hunters killed about 90,000 does, and there were no reports any of them had antlers, Cornicelli said. In 2011, hunters killed about 107,000 does, and just one was reported to have antlers. “There might be one or two killed that we don’t hear about, or that hunters don’t even know it’s not a doe,’’ he said.

The cause is an overproduction of testosterone. Whitetails of both sexes produce testosterone, but if a doe produces too much, antlers can result — sometimes small, but sometimes big.

“Someone shot an 11-point or 14-point doe a few years ago,’’ Cornicelli said. And those rare does may have antlers one year but not the next, he said. Most antlered does lack enough testosterone to lose the velvet on their antlers, he said. Spotting or shooting a doe with a hardened, velvet-free rack would be even more unusual, Cornicelli said.

Antlered does still generally have female reproductive organs, he said. Though rare, he said the DNR isn’t interested in examining or studying the carcass of such deer.

“From an anomaly perspective it’s interesting, from a biological perspective, it happens,’’ Cornicelli said. “It’s just too much testosterone.’’

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

Click here to send us your hunting or fishing photos – and to see what others are showing off from around the region.


New England 2/1/15 5:30 PM
Toronto 73 3rd Qtr 2:44
Indiana 57
Cleveland 47 3rd Qtr
Detroit 39
Milwaukee 54 3rd Qtr
Miami 50
Memphis 2 1st Qtr 9:44
Dallas 6
Chicago 9:30 PM
Golden State
Washington 9:30 PM
LA Lakers
NY Rangers 0 3rd Prd
NY Islanders 2
Arizona 3 3rd Prd
Philadelphia 3
Winnipeg 2 3rd Prd
Pittsburgh 2
Washington 2 3rd Prd
Columbus 3
Tampa Bay 1 2nd Prd 14:13
Carolina 2
Dallas 1 2nd Prd 14:59
Montreal 3
Detroit 2 2nd Prd 14:02
Florida 2
Colorado 1 1st Prd :03
Nashville 0
Buffalo 8:00 PM
Minnesota 8:30 PM
Anaheim 9:00 PM
Ball State 44 2nd Half 4:05
Akron 54
Northern Ill 41 2nd Half 4:53
Bowling Green 49
Western Mich 57 2nd Half 3:47
Buffalo 66
Ohio 38 2nd Half 1:31
Eastern Mich 68
Xavier 48 2nd Half 7:55
Georgetown 35
Vanderbilt 50 2nd Half 3:44
Georgia 57
West Virginia 46 2nd Half 9:32
Kansas State 41
Central Mich 40 2nd Half 7:06
Kent State 47
Saint Josephs 46 2nd Half 3:05
La Salle 45
Nebraska 41 2nd Half 2:07
Michigan 56
Miami-Ohio 57 2nd Half 2:21
Toledo 65
Tulsa 55 2nd Half 3:08
Tulane 42
George Washington 35 2nd Half 7:31
VA Commonwealth 53
Pittsburgh 53 2nd Half 5:15
Virginia Tech 49
Indiana State 26 1st Half 6:30
Evansville 28
Tabor College 17 1st Half 3:42
Oral Roberts 34
Florida 8:00 PM
Tennessee 8:00 PM
Texas A&M 8:00 PM
Baylor 8:00 PM
Oklahoma State
DePaul 0 Postponed
Providence 0
Michigan State 0 Postponed
Rutgers 0
Wyoming 8:00 PM
Utah State
Fresno State 8:05 PM
San Diego St
UNLV 9:00 PM
SD Christian 9:00 PM
Colorado State 10:00 PM
Boise State
Columbia International 33 FINAL
Charleston Southern 74
Temple 66 2nd Half 4:22
UCF 45
Campbell 40 2nd Half 5:08
Presbyterian 44
Coastal Carolina 54 2nd Half 3:44
High Point 69
Gardner-Webb 41 2nd Half 5:21
Radford 50
UNC-Asheville 53 2nd Half 2:47
Liberty 56
Winthrop 57 2nd Half 1:55
Longwood 55
Tulane 24 1st Half 2:46
Houston 18
(3) Baylor 46 1st Half 0:05
TCU 34
Navy 19 1st Half 2:23
American Univ 27
Valparaiso 13 1st Half 0:59
Illinois-Chicago 22
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters





question of the day

Poll: Should the lake where the albino muskie was caught remain a mystery?

Weekly Question