Anderson: Guns at the Capitol? Beware of the recoil

  • Article by: DENNIS ANDERSON , Star Tribune
  • Updated: August 23, 2013 - 12:03 AM

Too strong a push might have an unexpected effect.

American politics have long been rife with deployment of guns, large and small, so much so that this nation arguably was founded, shaped and advanced as much by ordnance as philosophy. So the debate, now current, at the State Capitol in St. Paul over whether legally armed citizens should be allowed in that building’s hallowed halls brandishing holstered side arms represents only the latest chapter in our history, not a new one.

Yet take comfort that dueling has fallen out of fashion.

History buffs will recall that on July 11, 1804, the sitting vice president of the United States, Aaron Burr, and the nation’s former secretary of the treasury, Alexander Hamilton, resolved their long-running quarrels through the sights of Wogdon dueling pistols. When the air cleared — between them the two had participated in about a dozen previous duels — Hamilton lay mortally wounded, a murder for which Burr was later indicted, but never convicted — an important distinction, as Bill Murray reminded us in the movie “Stripes.’’

For perspective, note that Minnesota is one of only about a dozen states that allow handgun packing in their statehouses. Count Texas among these also, though curiously during a recent spat over abortion legislation there, guards at its Capitol confiscated tampons as possible threats to lawmakers’ safety, while waving through without worry our old pals Mr. Smith and Mr. Wesson. Go figure.

In Minnesota, where authorized handgun carriers must notify State Capitol security of their intent to carry at the statehouse, the issue is more clear-cut — kind of.

Here, gun advocates rightly make the point that certain among them have been approved by the state to carry handguns in public, and that the people’s chambers should not be exclusionary as a destination in which this right can be exercised.

Opponents, meanwhile, counter that firearms, whether concealed or exposed, lugged into the Capitol are intimidating, if not utterly wacky, and therefore undercut, or possibly undercut, the free exchange of competing ideas whose proper resolution is impossible when one side battles with words, while the other fights with words and, if only by their presence, our old friends Mr. Smith and Mr. Wesson.

As the novelist Chuck Palahniuk said, “Everyone smiles with that invisible gun to their head.’’

But there’s a bigger issue.

The Minnesota Capitol, a wondrous, historic structure now undergoing a $272 million facelift, is and always has been a fortress without protection. Most days there’s no guard at its doors, not even a moat or helium-filled balloon in the shape of a German shepherd.

Granted, it’s cool that schoolchildren and other gawkers can come and go freely without having their backpacks scanned and their shoes removed. But it’s not very smart policy, and it invites trouble, particularly at a time when, as the front page of this newspaper reports nearly daily, anything goes.

The point is, if we’re going to debate Capitol security, and propriety, then relativity of threats, and problems, should be considered.

So:

Even if, as gun opponents assert (weakly), handgun carriers at the Capitol might gain undeserving consideration of some viewpoints, and/or might implicitly threaten opponents, thereby undermining the Capitol’s long-practiced decorum and even-handed consideration of divergent opinions, by far the greater worry among Capitol regulars and visitors should be that the building isn’t secure.

In this way, Minnesota’s most important structure presents itself to the public differently than most other major businesses (including the Star Tribune) and institutions (think courthouses) in the Twin Cities.

It’s this that should be of far greater concern to the citizenry and especially legislators than the statistically nonexistent “threat’’ posed by legal owners of legal guns legally carried, in the Capitol or elsewhere.

That said, gun advocates should know that the public’s good will on this issue is finite, that most people in this state don’t carry handguns, don’t want to carry handguns, and aren’t comfortable seeing others with handguns, perhaps especially in public meetings where fair play is expected to be — and must be — the governing principle.

So in the end, should handgun advocates insist their rights supersede all others in all instances, the salvo that could ring loudest from this debate is the sound of gun owners shooting themselves in the foot.

Burr did in fact outduel Hamilton.

But in the end, the onetime vice president of the United States ended up a political nobody who was later tried for treason and died in relative obscurity.

Hardly the victory he envisioned.

 

Dennis Anderson • danderson@startribune.com

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

Click here to send us your hunting or fishing photos – and to see what others are showing off from around the region.

ADVERTISEMENT

Team Irvin 7:15 PM
Team Carter
Miami 48 3rd Qtr 11:44
Chicago 38
Oklahoma City 2:30 PM
Cleveland
Dallas 5:00 PM
New Orleans
Indiana 5:00 PM
Orlando
LA Clippers 5:00 PM
Phoenix
Minnesota 5:00 PM
Atlanta
Detroit 6:00 PM
Toronto
Milwaukee 6:00 PM
San Antonio
Boston 7:00 PM
Golden State
Washington 7:00 PM
Denver
Houston 8:30 PM
LA Lakers
Team Toews 4:00 PM
Team Foligno
South Florida 53 FINAL
Connecticut 66
Boston College 34 2nd Half 17:39
Georgia Tech 26
Virginia 33 2nd Half 17:04
Virginia Tech 34
Indiana 25 1st Half 4:00
Ohio State 30
Stony Brook 4 1st Half 15:57
Binghamton 6
Cincinnati 3 1st Half 18:14
UCF 2
Maine 7 1st Half 15:23
Hartford 2
Monmouth 7 1st Half 13:33
Manhattan 11
Fairfield 10 1st Half 15:06
Marist 8
Rowan 8 1st Half 13:20
Princeton 8
St Bonaventure 6 1st Half 16:18
Rhode Island 4
Duke 2 1st Half 18:28
St Johns 3
Saint Peters 13 1st Half 13:07
Siena 10
Drake 2 1st Half 16:17
Wichita State 9
Vermont 8 1st Half 14:02
UMass Lowell 7
Seton Hall 2:00 PM
Butler
NJIT 2:05 PM
South Alabama
Northern Iowa 3:00 PM
Illinois State
Louisville 3:00 PM
Pittsburgh
UMBC 3:30 PM
Albany
Niagara 3:30 PM
Iona
Notre Dame 5:30 PM
NC State
Belmont 5:30 PM
Tennessee St
Creighton 6:00 PM
Villanova
Northwestern 6:30 PM
Maryland
Washington 7:30 PM
Utah
Senior-North 34 FINAL
Senior-South 13
Seton Hall 99 FINAL
Georgetown 85
St Johns 69 FINAL
Villanova 81
Arkansas 58 FINAL
Florida 72
Maine 34 2nd Half 14:11
UMBC 24
Vanderbilt 37 2nd Half 14:42
Alabama 31
Lafayette 32 2nd Half 15:59
Lehigh 34
Delaware 1:00 PM
Drexel
Towson 1:00 PM
UNC-Wilmington
Iona 1:00 PM
Canisius
Fairfield 1:00 PM
Monmouth
UCF 2 1st Half 19:25
SMU 0
Utah 2 1st Half 15:18
Washington 14
James Madison 5 1st Half 17:03
Coll of Charleston 1
Hofstra 6 1st Half 15:10
William & Mary 15
Hartford 3 1st Half 16:23
Albany 4
Binghamton 8 1st Half 16:06
Stony Brook 8
Wake Forest 8 1st Half 16:05
(17) Florida State 13
Georgia Tech 6 1st Half 15:41
Virginia 6
(22) Georgia 2 1st Half 14:38
(5) Tennessee 2
Drake 18 1st Half 12:53
Evansville 12
Northwestern 10 1st Half 14:16
Penn State 8
Wisconsin 10 1st Half 12:57
Michigan State 12
Ohio State 7 1st Half 15:59
Purdue 8
Northern Iowa 2 1st Half 16:05
Indiana State 5
Butler 1:30 PM
Xavier
Creighton 2:00 PM
Marquette
Providence 2:00 PM
DePaul
Northeastern 2:00 PM
Elon
(2) Connecticut 2:00 PM
Cincinnati
Oregon 2:00 PM
Arizona
Bradley 2:00 PM
Loyola-Chicago
NC State 2:00 PM
(23) Syracuse
(7) Maryland 2:00 PM
Indiana
Illinois State 2:05 PM
Missouri State
Colorado 3:00 PM
Washington St
Tulane 3:00 PM
South Florida
(14) Kentucky 3:00 PM
Missouri
(9) Oregon State 3:00 PM
(13) Arizona State
Vermont 3:30 PM
UMass Lowell
Iowa State 3:30 PM
(8) Texas
Southern Ill 3:45 PM
Wichita State
(15) Duke 4:00 PM
(12) North Carolina
Miami-Florida 4:00 PM
(4) Louisville
(21) Minnesota 4:15 PM
(25) Rutgers
California 5:00 PM
UCLA
(11) Stanford 7:00 PM
USC
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Should the lake where the albino muskie was caught remain a mystery?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close