Q: If you could have only one type of call, what would it be?
A: A mouth call. You can do things with a mouth call you can’t with other calls. It’s easier to sound just like a turkey. Turkeys in the wild don’t sound like most turkey calls. In fact, if you egg them on when calling them and get them excited, they’ll say things they otherwise never would. They can almost sound like two donkeys fighting. You can imitate that with a mouth call. You can’t with other types of calls.
Q: Is there a brand of call you prefer?
A: I make my own mouth calls. Ray Eye, who lives in Missouri, taught me how. I purchase various thicknesses of latex and frames and hand-stretch the latex to precisely the tension that works for me. Because the call is handmade, you can make calls you otherwise couldn’t. Ray really knows turkeys. As a teenager he followed them through the woods two or three days at a time.
Q: Handicap other call types.
A: I primarily use a slate call and a mouth call. A lot of days I’ll hunt with just those two. Other days I’ll also use a box call. Also, push-button calls are realistic sounding, and they take 30 seconds to learn how to use. Whatever you bring into the woods, make sure you sound like a turkey. If you don’t sound good on a mouth call, for instance, leave it home.
Q: What is a turkey’s tolerance for call quality?
A: Perhaps 80 percent of the time, turkeys have zero tolerance for you not sounding like a turkey. There are exceptions on certain days, when toms come running regardless. But most days, if you don’t sound real, they won’t come to you.
Q: Does that vary day to day?
A: It can vary hour to hour, depending on weather and other factors. I was in the Black Hills once when response from toms to calling was terrific. That night, it snowed. The next day the birds totally shut down.
Q: Do you call more as a hen, or a tom?
A: Probably half and half. But I can get toms more excited about coming to me when I sound like a hen. Also, if I make a mistake by moving or something, I think toms called to as if I were a hen are more forgiving. Also, when they’re coming to you, I believe in calling them all the way in, rather than going quiet, as some people suggest.