Moose study reveals pain and deaths but not answers

  • Article by: DOUG SMITH , Star Tribune
  • Updated: April 13, 2013 - 4:51 PM

The DNR’s look at what has caused the population to fall has revealed only hints involving diseases and wolves.


This radio-collared northern Minnesota moose was severely infected with brainworm and could be heard grinding its teeth in apparent pain when researchers located it. The moose also likely was blind in one eye from a parasite, possibly a brainworm.

The mysterious screeching coming from the woods was unlike anything the moose researchers had ever heard.

Shuffling through the snow, they edged closer to the sound and spotted a weak and distraught moose.

“It was grinding its teeth,’’ said Erika Butler, Department of Natural Resources wildlife veterinarian. “Cattle and horses do that when they are in extreme pain.’’

The researchers euthanized the dying moose and determined it was severely infected with brainworm. They hadn’t stumbled on the animal by accident. It was one of 111 moose captured this winter and fitted with unique GPS-equipped radio collars, so they can be located, and electronics that alert researchers if a moose is immobile for a long period, indicating death or near-death.

“Our collar went into mortality mode and sent us a text message,’’ Butler said. “We were able to get out there and find it [before it died]. It’s awesome technology.’’

Researchers hope that technology will unravel the mystery of why Minnesota’s moose population is plummeting — half the herd has died off in just two years. The population, now estimated at 2,760, is down from 8,840 as recently as 2006. Wildlife officials say that at that rate they could be gone from the state in a matter of years.

So far, only eight of the study moose have died, and four of those deaths were blamed on the capture process, in which the moose were sedated.

“We think it was due to the very poor condition the animals were in,’’ Butler said.

Of the four other moose, one was the animal found with brainworm, two were killed by wolves and a third died after a wolf bite became infected — another unique observation credited to the technology. Researchers got to the animal before wolves did.

“We found it got a bacterial infection from the wolf bite, and spread,’’ Butler said.

Though wolves were responsible for three of the four moose deaths, Butler said it’s too early to draw any conclusions.

“This is the time of year we’d expect to see wolves take moose,’’ she said. Moose are weakened from a long winter with little food and are most vulnerable to predation, she said. “They’re living off fat reserves.’’

Researchers don’t believe wolves are responsible for the moose population decline, despite such claims by some residents.

“We believe it’s health-related,’’ Butler said. “We’re seeing prime-age animals dying, which isn’t normal when you look at other moose populations. We’re also seeing them dying in seasons they shouldn’t be — June, July, August and September. Other moose populations do really well at that time.’’

Ironically, the researchers need more of the collared moose to die so they can determine the causes.

A second phase of the first-of-its-kind study will begin next month when researchers, using a helicopter, locate 50 of the radio-collared moose, which were pregnant when captured, and put radio collars on their newborn calves to study calf mortality. Calves are vulnerable to wolves, black bears and other predators, and that part of the study will help researchers understand how calf mortality might be impacting the population.

Still, it’s the death of adult moose that is most puzzling.

Some have theorized that eastern equine encephalitis, which was first found in 2007 in northeast Minnesota moose and which is lethal in horses, could be a smoking gun. It is spread by mosquitoes, which get it from birds, not horses, Butler said. “When horses get it, they usually don’t have enough of it in their blood to infect another mosquito. They usually die quickly. We call them dead-end hosts.’’

Butler said researchers aren’t sure what impact, if any, the disease is having on moose, but the study should reveal that.

Another theory is that increases of sulfur and mercury in the environment could be to blame. High sulfur levels can cause polioencephalomalacia (PEM), which causes death. But Butler said no Minnesota moose have been found with PEM or high mercury levels.

Brainworm remains a better possibility. Deer carry it (and are unaffected by it), and slugs and terrestrial land snails spread it. And it’s deadly to moose. Some wonder if the relatively high densities of deer in northern Minnesota could be contributing to the problem.

Though hunting mortality wasn’t considered a factor in the population drop, officials in February suspended future hunts indefinitely.

Butler believes the study will solve the moose mystery, though it could be a year or two before answers are revealed. But even if the problem is identified, the question is whether officials will be able to do anything about it. Inoculating moose from disease isn’t practical.

Meanwhile, there’s still snow in the northern Minnesota woods, which could help moose. Winter ticks, which infest moose and can kill them, fall off now to lay eggs.

“If they drop off in snow, much fewer of them survive,’’ Butler said.


Doug Smith •

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

Click here to send us your hunting or fishing photos – and to see what others are showing off from around the region.


New England 2/1/15 5:30 PM
Detroit 43 3rd Qtr 8:27
Philadelphia 53
Portland 51 3rd Qtr 9:27
Cleveland 58
Sacramento 47 2nd Qtr 3:07
Toronto 46
Boston 11 1st Qtr 4:39
Minnesota 10
Dallas 21 1st Qtr 4:49
Houston 14
Denver 18 1st Qtr 4:13
New Orleans 11
Brooklyn 19 1st Qtr 5:03
Atlanta 13
Oklahoma City 11 1st Qtr 5:20
New York 15
Charlotte 7:30 PM
San Antonio
LA Clippers 8:00 PM
Washington 9:30 PM
Toronto 0 2nd Prd
New Jersey 0
Pittsburgh 0 1st Prd 12:25
Washington 1
Chicago 9:30 PM
Los Angeles
Temple 55 2nd Half 11:45
UCF 29
Winthrop 50 2nd Half 11:03
Coastal Carolina 50
Lafayette 42 2nd Half 12:00
Colgate 45
Northeastern 35 2nd Half 11:40
Drexel 38
Wake Forest 43 2nd Half 13:44
Florida State 46
Rhode Island 41 2nd Half 13:41
Fordham 43
Delaware 59 2nd Half 10:01
James Madison 61
South Carolina 40 2nd Half 13:28
LSU 39
New Hampshire 38 2nd Half 10:33
Maine 34
Seton Hall 60 2nd Half 10:24
Marquette 38
Binghamton 33 2nd Half 16:00
American Univ 42 2nd Half 10:16
Navy 55
Elon 41 2nd Half 13:18
UNC-Wilmington 57
Wright State 47 2nd Half 11:29
Oakland 37
Minnesota 39 2nd Half 11:53
Penn State 43
Duquesne 34 2nd Half 14:40
Richmond 60
SMU 46 2nd Half 11:10
South Florida 40
Hartford 43 2nd Half 11:57
Stony Brook 37
Albany 31 2nd Half 10:00
Vermont 24
Hofstra 48 2nd Half 11:42
William & Mary 63
UNC-Asheville 46 2nd Half 14:00
Longwood 41
Radford 45 2nd Half
Char Southern 35
Holy Cross 0 Postponed
Loyola-Maryland 0
Duke 39 2nd Half
Notre Dame 36
Texas Tech 16 2nd Half
Oklahoma 37
Oregon State 16 1st Half 9:57
Arizona State 24
Morehead State 18 1st Half 11:51
Austin Peay 10
Drake 22 1st Half 11:12
Bradley 15
Lehigh 9 1st Half 11:16
Bucknell 8
Rice 8 1st Half 11:40
Houston 12
Missouri State 5 1st Half 11:39
Illinois State 6
Loyola-Chicago 6 1st Half 13:20
Wichita State 7
Nebraska Omaha 10 1st Half 11:30
South Dakota St 23
Northern Iowa 13 1st Half 10:47
Southern Ill 8
Louisville 8:00 PM
Boston College
St Johns 8:00 PM
East Carolina 8:00 PM
Georgia Tech 8:00 PM
Miss State 8:00 PM
Ole Miss
Clemson 8:00 PM
NC State
Indiana 8:00 PM
Kansas 8:00 PM
Oregon 9:00 PM
Air Force 9:00 PM
San Jose St
Stanford 10:00 PM
Rider 56 FINAL
Siena 49
Dayton 76 FINAL
Richmond 62
Eastern Kentucky 53 FINAL
Jacksonville St 73
Saint Josephs 0 Postponed
Saint Louis 0
UMBC 45 2nd Half 11:30
Binghamton 41
Akron 45 2nd Half 10:45
Ohio U 48
Ball State 61 2nd Half 11:15
Miami-Ohio 35
Memphis 45 2nd Half 11:30
Cincinnati 28
East Carolina 20 2nd Half 15:45
(2) Connecticut 55
Murray State 52 2nd Half 7:59
Eastern Illinois 59
Kent State 45 2nd Half 9:55
Central Michigan 52
UT Martin 53 2nd Half 10:46
Tennessee St 39
Eastern Michigan 35 2nd Half 15:29
Western Mich 55
Bucknell 48 2nd Half 10:52
Lehigh 58
Indiana 41 2nd Half 13:31
Michigan State 52
Colgate 48 2nd Half 10:20
Lafayette 37
Fordham 47 2nd Half 9:29
Davidson 37
Duquesne 49 2nd Half 12:07
St Bonaventure 41
George Mason 43 2nd Half 11:29
VA Commonwealth 49
Detroit 36 2nd Half 8:24
Youngstown St 39
Army 0 Postponed
Boston U 0
Loyola-Maryland 0 Postponed
Holy Cross 0
SMU 14 1st Half 12:56
Tulsa 15
Oklahoma St 6 1st Half 14:03
Kansas State 1
West Virginia 11 1st Half 11:48
Texas Tech 15
Denver 14 1st Half 12:38
South Dakota 11
Northwestern St 11 1st Half 12:02
Central Arkansas 7
Austin Peay 16 1st Half 8:13
SIU-Edwardsville 27
Kansas 11 1st Half 11:55
Iowa State 9
Bowling Green 7 1st Half 11:55
Northern Ill 14
Penn State 14 1st Half 14:10
Minnesota 13
San Jose St 8:00 PM
Air Force
Boise State 8:00 PM
Colorado State
Utah State 8:00 PM
San Diego State 9:00 PM
Fresno State
Nevada 9:00 PM
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters





question of the day

Poll: Should the lake where the albino muskie was caught remain a mystery?

Weekly Question