Dennis Anderson: Is the sky the limit with ducks?

  • Article by: DENNIS ANDERSON , Star Tribune
  • Updated: September 16, 2012 - 3:21 AM

The idea to control duck populations with hunting restrictions is shifting with the understanding that habitat and water are much bigger factors.

hide

Some biologists advocate loosening — or losing — duck limits, as they don’t seem to affect numbers much.

Photo: Dennis Anderson, Star Tribune

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

Duck limits: What if they didn't matter?

What if you and I and all of our buddies -- everyone -- could shoot all we wanted ... and it wouldn't make an iota of difference to ducks?

Some waterfowl biologists are beginning to think that way.

Sort of.

"In this day and age, the duck possession limit, at least, is an anachronism,'' said Dave Ankney, a lifelong waterfowler and professor emeritus of zoology at the University of Western Ontario in London, Ontario. "To have a possession limit of only 12 ducks is absurd.

"It's not doing anything positive for ducks. But it is doing something negative for duck hunting.''

Ankney hunts in Canada in the fall and in Texas in the later season. He says when waterfowl possession limits were established decades ago to equal twice the daily limit, the daily limit was 50.

Which translated into a possession limit of 100.

But with daily limits today of only six, keeping possession limits at twice that amount makes no sense, particularly when so many waterfowlers these days travel great distances to hunt for a week at a time and are hamstrung by the number of birds they can keep.

Canadian waterfowl managers already have loosened duck possession limits, allowing hunters to keep three daily limits instead of two -- a relative boatload of birds, considering the daily duck limit across most of Canada is eight.

Now some of the same Canadian waterfowl experts reportedly are considering the end of duck possession limits altogether, or at least liberalizing them considerably. They reason that so relatively few people hunt in Canada anymore that duck populations can't be affected, regardless the possession limit.

Maybe not.

But issues underpinning waterfowl hunting regulations, particularly those affecting ducks, are complex. Unlike virtually all other wildlife, waterfowl are a shared resource, state to state and nation to nation. Their management is significantly controlled by the Migratory Bird Treaty, which ties Canada, the United States and Mexico to common hunting principles.

In the United States, the four flyways established to manage ducks and geese -- Atlantic, Mississippi (which includes Minnesota and Wisconsin), Central (the Dakotas) and Pacific -- were developed in recognition that provinces and states in the north must regulate waterfowl in concert with states in the midlatitudes and south to ensure that everyone gets a fair shot at migrating birds.

Yet increasingly, biologists believe that habitat quality and water availability govern the size of the following year's duck breeding populations far more than hunting regulations.

Example:

For the past decade and a half, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has managed duck seasons under its "liberal'' regulatory scheme, meaning hunting is allowed for 60 days (more in some states), with six-bird daily limits (also more in some states).

Arguably in some years during that period, limits and season lengths could have been reduced, and perhaps should have been, given that certain species saw population downfalls.

But in retrospect, to what end? In the past decade and a half, during "liberal'' regulations, some duck populations have risen and fallen seemingly regardless of the liberal framework.

"When possession limits were first established, part of the reason was to catch commercial hunters,'' Ankney said. "If they couldn't catch them over-shooting ducks in the marsh, they could catch them in their homes or businesses with stockpiles of ducks. Obviously, today, there are no commercial duck hunters.''

Hold your fire

But limits are not only about ducks. They also reflect human values, however intangible.

What, after all, is a "moral'' limit? A "sportsman's'' limit?

"How many ducks can one person or one family eat in a year?'' asked Department of Natural Resources Commissioner Tom Landwehr, a longtime duck hunter. "I tell my kids we eat what we shoot. To shoot ducks and give them away to other people is legal, and some hunters do it. But it crosses my ethical line.''

Landwehr notes that in areas where hunting pressure is intense, duck numbers can be adversely affected, particularly in a duck-breeding state such as Minnesota, which depends on a significant portion of its waterfowl to return in spring to maintain relative population stability.

Still, Minnesota and many other states have fewer duck hunters now than in the past -- in Minnesota's case, about 50 percent fewer, from about 150,000 to about 75,000.

So hunters today collectively harvest far fewer birds than they once did, because fewer guns go afield.

Steve Cordts is the DNR's duck management specialist.

"In the 1970s and at other times in the past, waterfowl managers believed they could affect the following spring's returning breeding duck numbers by making minor changes in the fall hunting regulations,'' Cordts said.

"That thinking has changed now. Yes, we can 'manage harvest' with hunting regulations. But to have any significant effect on harvest, we'd have to take big steps, say down to 30 days and three ducks daily. We don't see a reason to do that. Plus, it would cost us a bunch of hunters who would leave the sport.''

Landwehr says states should perhaps fix daily duck limits at, say, five, like pheasant and grouse limits are fixed, for example.

Consideration should also be given to removing species restrictions, Ankney says, to be replaced, perhaps, with a limit of "four splashes and you're done'' regardless of species in the bag, or their gender.

"It's crazy, all these restrictions on different species,'' Ankney said. "For the average guy, or a kid, or someone just starting to duck hunt, figuring all of this out is a headache -- two of this and one of that.

"Are there duck species that might need special protection? Maybe canvasbacks. But even those have bounced back after they've been down.

"I would say let's try some of these changes. These regulations are costing us hunters, and they're not helping ducks.

"It's not regulations that dictate duck numbers, after all. It's weather and water.''

Dennis Anderson danderson@startribune.com

  • related content

  • 2012 duck season primer

    Saturday September 15, 2012

    • The 2012 duck season opens a half-hour before dawn on Saturday.• Shooting is allowed until 4 p.m. daily through...

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

Click here to send us your hunting or fishing photos – and to see what others are showing off from around the region.

ADVERTISEMENT

New England 2/1/15 5:30 PM
Seattle
Milwaukee 54 2nd Qtr 2:08
Orlando 38
New York 45 2nd Qtr 1:21
Indiana 48
Denver 2 1st Qtr 10:19
Memphis 4
Chicago 9:30 PM
LA Lakers
Montreal 0 2nd Prd
NY Rangers 0
Winnipeg 2 2nd Prd
Philadelphia 2
Boston 2 2nd Prd 19:57
NY Islanders 0
Arizona 0 1st Prd 5:18
Toronto 0
Dallas 3 1st Prd 8:02
Ottawa 0
Detroit 1 1st Prd 5:29
Tampa Bay 1
Columbus 0 1st Prd 3:50
Florida 0
Nashville 7:00 PM
St. Louis
Minnesota 8:00 PM
Calgary
Buffalo 8:30 PM
Edmonton
Anaheim 9:00 PM
San Jose
DePaul 72 FINAL
Providence 83
Michigan State 71 FINAL
Rutgers 51
Boston Univ 37 2nd Half
Army 32
Fla Atlantic 25 2nd Half
Charlotte 41
Youngstown St 22 2nd Half
Detroit 34
East Tenn St 24 2nd Half 20:00
Furman 29
Saint Louis 24 2nd Half
George Mason 29
USC Upstate 44 2nd Half
Jacksonville 34
High Point 33 2nd Half
Liberty 26
Central Conn St 31 2nd Half 15:17
Long Island 44
Western Ky 23 2nd Half 19:30
Louisiana Tech 31
Dayton 42 2nd Half 17:02
Massachusetts 42
Chattanooga 26 2nd Half 18:50
Mercer 38
Wofford 30 2nd Half
UNC Greensboro 22
Maryland 26 2nd Half
Ohio State 34
FIU 26 2nd Half
Old Dominion 34
Fair-Dickinson 28 2nd Half 20:00
Robert Morris 41
Mount St Marys 27 2nd Half 20:00
St Francis-NY 26
Bryant 37 2nd Half 17:47
St Francis-PA 42
Northern Ky 27 2nd Half
Stetson 37
Coll of Charleston 19 2nd Half
Towson 33
Western Carolina 40 2nd Half
Va Military 36
Sacred Heart 33 2nd Half
Wagner 30
Lipscomb 25 2nd Half 20:00
Fla Gulf Coast 37
Kennesaw St 23 2nd Half 20:00
North Florida 48
Appalachian St 12 1st Half 6:17
Ga Southern 24
Holy Cross 11 1st Half 6:30
Loyola-Maryland 15
Eastern Ill 19 1st Half 6:33
UT Martin 28
Jacksonville St 7:00 PM
Belmont
Connecticut 0 1st Half 18:13
Cincinnati 6
Rider 7:00 PM
Saint Peters
SIU Edwardsville 3 1st Half 18:17
SE Missouri St 1
Marshall 7:00 PM
Southern Miss
Tenn Tech 0 1st Half 20:00
Tennessee St 0
Middle Tennessee 7:00 PM
TX-San Antonio
Ill-Chicago 7:00 PM
Milwaukee
Weber State 7:00 PM
North Dakota
Denver 7:00 PM
North Dakota St
IUPU-Ft Wayne 7:00 PM
South Dakota
Louisiana 7:05 PM
South Alabama
Georgia State 7:15 PM
Texas-Arlington
Ark-Little Rock 7:30 PM
Arkansas State
ULM 7:30 PM
Troy
Portland 8:00 PM
Gonzaga
Kentucky 8:00 PM
Missouri
Eastern Ky 8:00 PM
Murray State
UAB 8:00 PM
Texas-El Paso
Idaho State 8:00 PM
Northern Colorado
UMKC 8:00 PM
Grand Canyon
Chicago State 8:05 PM
Utah Valley U
Colorado 8:30 PM
USC
Cal Poly 9:00 PM
UC Irvine
Hawaii 9:00 PM
CS-Northridge
Pepperdine 9:00 PM
Pacific
Santa Clara 9:00 PM
San Diego
Utah 9:00 PM
UCLA
UC Santa Barbara 9:00 PM
UC Davis
Montana 9:05 PM
Portland State
Montana State 9:05 PM
Sacramento St
Long Beach State 9:30 PM
Cal State Fullerton
Loyola Marymount 9:30 PM
St Marys-CA
San Francisco 10:00 PM
BYU
California 10:00 PM
Washington St
Louisiana 47 FINAL
South Alabama 57
Saint Josephs 51 FINAL
Saint Louis 52
Appalachian St 77 FINAL
Georgia Southern 74
Niagara 58 FINAL
Saint Peters 65
Old Dominion 80 FINAL
FIU 67
Southern Miss 65 FINAL
Marshall 67
Georgia State 45 FINAL
TX-Arlington 57
Ark-Little Rock 69 FINAL
Arkansas State 70
ULM 39 2nd Half 3:51
Troy 83
Pittsburgh 37 2nd Half 5:25
(17) Duke 58
(6) Tennessee 25 2nd Half
(10) Kentucky 31
(24) Oklahoma 35 2nd Half 18:54
(14) Texas 32
Nebraska Omaha 30 2nd Half 17:48
IUPU-Ft Wayne 39
UC-Riverside 35 2nd Half
CS-Northridge 32
Army 40 2nd Half 18:26
Boston U 17
New Orleans 20 2nd Half
Nicholls 28
Charlotte 30 2nd Half
Florida Atlantic 37
Towson 27 2nd Half 15:15
Delaware 40
Hofstra 35 2nd Half
Northeastern 25
New Hampshire 24 2nd Half
Maine 40
Albany 39 2nd Half 20:00
Vermont 22
Hartford 31 2nd Half
Stony Brook 33
UNC-Wilmington 33 2nd Half 15:58
William & Mary 43
Clemson 28 2nd Half
Wake Forest 34
Alabama 21 2nd Half
(1) South Carolina 38
(23) Syracuse 30 2nd Half 18:23
(8) Louisville 34
Missouri 30 2nd Half
Florida 29
Iona 38 2nd Half 16:54
Fairfield 41
Manhattan 15 2nd Half 18:32
Marist 39
NC State 39 2nd Half 16:44
Virginia 41
(4) Notre Dame 43 2nd Half
Virginia Tech 17
(22) Rutgers 26 2nd Half 20:00
Purdue 22
(5) Maryland 48 2nd Half
Michigan 36
Milwaukee 26 2nd Half 20:00
Cleveland State 33
Wright State 52 2nd Half 20:00
Oakland 41
Jacksonville 25 2nd Half
USC Upstate 28
North Florida 20 2nd Half
Kennesaw St 16
Stetson 19 2nd Half
Northern Ky 37
Loyola-Maryland 28 2nd Half 15:23
Holy Cross 26
Lamar 24 1st Half 8:32
Sam Houston St 19
Fla Gulf Coast 20 1st Half 6:06
Lipscomb 10
Vanderbilt 7:00 PM
(18) Miss State
IUPUI 7:00 PM
Western Ill
Abilene Christian 7:00 PM
Houston Baptist
Incarnate Word 7:00 PM
TX A&M-CC
McNeese State 7:00 PM
SE Louisiana
Oral Roberts 7:00 PM
South Dakota St
Louisiana Tech 7:00 PM
Western Ky
TX-San Antonio 7:00 PM
Middle Tennessee
Auburn 7:00 PM
Arkansas
Grand Canyon 7:00 PM
UMKC
Illinois 7:00 PM
(15) Nebraska
(20) Iowa 7:00 PM
Northwestern
Texas-El Paso 0 1st Half 20:00
UAB 0
Utah Valley U 7:05 PM
Chicago State
Green Bay 0 1st Half 20:00
Valparaiso 0
Ole Miss 8:00 PM
LSU
Portland State 8:00 PM
Montana
Sacramento St 8:00 PM
Montana State
North Dakota 8:00 PM
Weber State
Ohio State 8:00 PM
Wisconsin
Northern Colorado 8:00 PM
Idaho State
BYU 9:00 PM
San Francisco
St Marys-CA 9:00 PM
Loyola Marymount
Pacific 9:00 PM
Pepperdine
Cal-Irvine 9:00 PM
UC Santa Barbara
San Diego 9:00 PM
Santa Clara
UC Davis 9:00 PM
Cal Poly
Long Beach St 10:59 PM
Hawaii
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Should the lake where the albino muskie was caught remain a mystery?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close