Dennis Anderson: Undercover angler investigates invasive species security

  • Article by: DENNIS ANDERSON , Star Tribune
  • Updated: June 3, 2012 - 1:07 AM

Are there cracks in security when it comes to the fight against invasive species at two west-metro lakes? Or could they be models for others? This fisherman went to find out.

hide

Carver County watercraft inspector Ben Bonar looks over a boat owned by Gene Herzan (back, left) of Minnetonka after Herzan pulled the boat from Lake Minnewashta, where he had been panfishing. The boat launch at Minnewashta is staffed virtually all hours it is open by a Department of Natural Resources trained inspector.

Photo: Dennis Anderson, Star Tribune

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

How much "protection" against invasive species are the state's most protected lakes receiving this summer?

I went to find out last week, visiting with my boat and trailer Lake Minnewashta and Christmas Lake, both in the west metro.

Unlike the state's other 5,491 fishable lakes, Minnewashta and Christmas are staffed nearly continuously by trained invasive species inspectors.

Both lakes also have gates limiting entry to their single public accesses, and inspectors at both accesses check boats going in, and coming out.

Carver County and the Minnehaha Creek watershed district foot the bill for county inspectors at Lake Minnewashta, while at Christmas Lake, affected homeowners and the Minnehaha watershed district cover costs of a private security firm whose Department of Natural Resources-trained inspectors staff the entrance.

Gating systems at the two lakes are similar but different.

At Minnewashta, a regional park surrounds the boat access, and entry to the park is gated. Passage is allowed by fee between 6 a.m. and 10 p.m.

At Christmas Lake, entry and exit gates were installed last November at a cost of about $26,000, about half of which was paid by lakeshore owners and the rest by the watershed district and the city of Shorewood.

The intent at both lakes is to keep out zebra mussels in particular, as well as other invasive species.

Boaters wanting to drop watercraft into either lake must answer questions posed by inspectors, and must also submit their boats for inspection.

The inspectors can deny access if they suspect a boat or trailer is carrying zebra mussels, Eurasian watermilfoil or something equally evil. If necessary, the inspectors can call DNR conservation officers or other authorities to mitigate disputes or enforce laws.

Contrast those protection systems with -- for example -- the one in force this summer at Mille Lacs, where at any given time, DNR inspectors are stationed at only one or two (or none) of the lake's more than 15 public accesses.

Mille Lacs' 50-plus private accesses, meanwhile, aren't ever staffed.

Thus a question: By dint of their gated entrances and trained watercraft inspectors, are Minnewashta and Christmas more likely than other less closely monitored lakes to escape the plague of bad-news plants and animals invading Minnesota?

Or are these "inspectors," their DNR certifications notwithstanding, little more than college kids intent on working on their tans while on someone's payroll.

I took my boat and trailer to each lake to try to find out.

• • •

First stop was Minnewashta, where at the regional park's gatehouse I bought an annual visitor pass for $24, good also for Carver, Anoka and Washington county parks.

Then it was on to the lake's boat landing, where Ben Bonar, a graduate student working as a Carver County inspector, introduced himself, inquiring if he could begin his overview of my boat by asking a few questions.

I presented myself only as a boater interested in fishing Minnewashta, saying nothing about my affiliation with the Star Tribune, or that I was working on a story. "Sure," I said.

Among Bonar's first questions: "When was the boat last in the water, and where?"

My answer: White Bear Lake, less than 24 hours before.

What Bonar didn't ask was: What lakes, if any, had my boat been in during the previous five days -- the time, the DNR says, it takes an unwashed boat to "dry," killing any zebra mussels attached to it?

My answer would have been: Four days earlier, the St. Croix; three days earlier, Deer Lake, Wis.; and one day earlier, White Bear.

Otherwise, Bonar's questions about invasive species were straightforward, and he recorded my answers on a personal digital assistant (PDA) to be downloaded later into a DNR database.

Then Bonar checked my boat, and his inspection was more than a drive-by. He felt below the craft's waterline for the sandpaper-like presence of juvenile mussels, checked that the bait well and live wells were empty of water, looked at the intakes on the outboard, and otherwise gave the boat a thorough once-over.

When he was finished, I told him I didn't intend to launch the boat, and was interested only in observing the inspection process and, ultimately, writing about it for the Star Tribune.

I asked: "What if I had told you I just came from [zebra mussel-infested] Lake Minnetonka?" Bonar indicated his inspection might then have been somewhat more detailed.

"Have you denied anyone access to the lake?" I asked. Only three times, Bonar said, each to lakeshore residents who tried to launch pontoons that had been stored over the winter and were laced with dried vegetation.

I left thinking that a) Bonar did a good job and b) the DNR's list of questions, the foundation for its inspection protocol, needs amending, in part to better alert inspectors about the whereabouts of boats not just in the day previous, but the week previous, and more importantly to give policy-makers a more detailed understanding of the mobility of Minnesota boat owners -- anglers in particular.

• • •

Next stop, Christmas Lake, where I was greeted by Kian Amani, who works for Volt Workforce Solutions. Like Bonar, Amani was trained by the DNR, and he asked the same questions, recording them not on a PDA, but on paper.

Then Amani inspected my boat -- though for a long moment, I didn't think he would, settling instead only for the questions and answers. Was he thorough? Generally, yes. But not as thorough as Bonar.

Again, I told Amani I hadn't intended to launch and that I was writing a story, the central question of which would be:

Is all this effort, with gates and inspectors, worth the time and money required in the fight against invasive species?

In the end, my answer: probably, as a deterrent. But there are no guarantees, and the chances the lakes will remain mussel-free probably decrease over time, as these critters spread to more surrounding lakes.

Left unsaid in all of this is not the threat posed by traveling anglers, of whom this state has a lot. The focus instead -- or also -- should be on wakeboard boats, which are frequently moved from lake to lake, particularly in and out of Minnetonka (and Christmas Lake), and which can't be completely emptied of their ballasts, virtually guaranteeing them as possible vectors for infestation.

Meanwhile, summer unfolds and inspections continue -- more so at Minnewashta and Christmas lakes than at other waters.

Perhaps some good will result.

But don't bet on it.

Dennis Anderson • danderson@startribune.com

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

Click here to send us your hunting or fishing photos – and to see what others are showing off from around the region.

ADVERTISEMENT

Minnesota 17 4th Qtr
Miami 14
Baltimore 7 3rd Qtr 11:00
Houston 16
Detroit 10 4th Qtr 13:26
Chicago 14
Cleveland 6 4th Qtr 14:48
Carolina 10
Atlanta 20 4th Qtr 15:00
New Orleans 7
Green Bay 13 4th Qtr 8:30
Tampa Bay 3
Kansas City 6 4th Qtr 14:54
Pittsburgh 17
New England 17 4th Qtr 13:39
NY Jets 13
NY Giants 3:05 PM
St. Louis
Buffalo 3:25 PM
Oakland
Indianapolis 3:25 PM
Dallas
Seattle 7:30 PM
Arizona
Denver 12/22/14 7:30 PM
Cincinnati
New York 2:30 PM
Toronto
Memphis 3:30 PM
Cleveland
Boston 5:00 PM
Miami
Detroit 5:00 PM
Brooklyn
LA Lakers 5:00 PM
Sacramento
Philadelphia 5:00 PM
Orlando
Phoenix 5:00 PM
Washington
Indiana 6:00 PM
Minnesota
New Orleans 6:00 PM
Oklahoma City
Colorado 5:00 PM
Detroit
Dallas 5:00 PM
Edmonton
Buffalo 6:00 PM
Boston
Carolina 6:00 PM
NY Rangers
Toronto 6:00 PM
Chicago
Philadelphia 8:00 PM
Winnipeg
Harvard 27 FINAL
Virginia 76
Maine 67 1st OT 0:17
Army 69
Ferris State 82 FINAL
Bowling Green 68
San Francisco 65 FINAL
Cleveland State 69
Oregon State 52 FINAL
Quinnipiac 60
Coastal Carolina 72 FINAL
Central Arkansas 55
Holy Cross 31 2nd Half 13:08
Canisius 33
Southern Miss 35 2nd Half 11:04
Georgia State 49
Western Carolina 37 2nd Half 14:17
UNC-Asheville 47
Creighton 26 2nd Half 14:09
North Texas 51
Maryland 49 2nd Half 13:18
Oklahoma State 35
Cornell 40 2nd Half 15:12
Radford 50
Vermont 36 2nd Half 11:07
Saint Louis 38
Loyola-Maryland 37 2nd Half 12:41
Stony Brook 42
Reinhardt 40 2nd Half 15:51
Winthrop 55
Ark-Little Rock 36 2nd Half 10:07
Green Bay 51
TX-Pan American 42 2nd Half 14:11
Nebraska Omaha 53
Alabama State 55 2nd Half 16:27
Evansville 47
FIU 31 2nd Half
Hartford 42
Goshen 25 2nd Half
Valparaiso 38
Bryant 2 1st Half 13:04
Denver 4
Austin Peay 4 1st Half 12:08
Lipscomb 14
Tennessee St 0 1st Half 16:00
Middle Tennessee 11
South Dakota 14 1st Half 14:35
Montana 10
ULM 2:25 PM
Samford
Coker 2:30 PM
South Carolina
USC 3:00 PM
Boston College
Northern Ariz 3:00 PM
Hampton
SD Christian 3:00 PM
San Diego
UC Irvine 3:30 PM
Bradley
Troy 3:30 PM
Nicholls
Seton Hall 5:00 PM
Georgia
Appalachian St 5:30 PM
Alabama
North Dakota St 6:00 PM
Kent State
San Jose St 6:00 PM
Washington St
Alcorn State 8:00 PM
Texas-El Paso
Sacramento St 9:00 PM
Seattle
Nevada 3 FINAL
Louisiana 16
Utah State 21 FINAL
Texas-El Paso 6
(23) Utah 45 FINAL
Colorado State 10
Western Mich 24 FINAL
Air Force 38
South Alabama 28 FINAL
Bowling Green 33
BYU 12/22/14 1:00 PM
Memphis
Marshall 12/23/14 5:00 PM
Northern Ill
Navy 12/23/14 8:30 PM
San Diego St
Central Mich 12/24/14 11:00 AM
Western Ky
Fresno State 12/24/14 7:00 PM
Rice
Illinois 12/26/14 12:00 PM
Louisiana Tech
Rutgers 12/26/14 3:30 PM
North Carolina
NC State 12/26/14 7:00 PM
UCF
Cincinnati 12/27/14 12:00 PM
Virginia Tech
Duke 12/27/14 1:10 PM
(15) Arizona State
Miami-Florida 12/27/14 3:00 PM
So Carolina
Boston College 12/27/14 3:30 PM
Penn State
(25) Nebraska 12/27/14 7:00 PM
(24) USC
Cal-Irvine 55 FINAL
Denver 63
St Marys-CA 52 FINAL
George Washington 70
TX-San Antonio 49 FINAL
Nicholls 57
Portland State 71 FINAL
Columbia 66
Tenn Tech 62 FINAL
Morgan State 56
SMU 43 FINAL
Auburn 56
Quinnipiac 70 FINAL
Hartford 58
Hofstra 75 FINAL
Boston College 61
Eastern Washington 55 FINAL
Georgia Southern 42
Liberty 44 FINAL
(1) South Carolina 84
Fairleigh Dickinson 74 FINAL
Brown 79
Buffalo 73 FINAL
Long Island 79
Bucknell 74 FINAL
Mount St Marys 49
Stony Brook 70 FINAL
Wagner 76
FIU 83 FINAL
Wofford 75
Duquesne 56 FINAL
Providence 67
Maine 54 FINAL
William & Mary 51
Alabama State 43 FINAL
Samford 56
TX-Pan American 43 FINAL
VA Commonwealth 64
South Dakota St 64 FINAL
Marist 82
Saint Josephs 50 FINAL
(5) Notre Dame 64
Radford 60 FINAL
Virginia Tech 73
(3) Texas 55 2nd Half 6:58
(4) Texas A&M 59
Rhode Island 60 2nd Half 0:10
Bryant 56
South Florida 37 2nd Half
Penn State 34
Sam Houston St 30 2nd Half 14:08
TCU 53
Evansville 29 2nd Half 15:26
IUPUI 41
(14) Maryland 74 2nd Half 14:17
Coppin State 74
Mercer 41 2nd Half 11:13
Coll of Charleston 54
NC A&T 21 2nd Half 17:45
Chattanooga 36
Princeton 64 2nd Half 12:19
Monmouth 36
Eastern Illinois 56 2nd Half 9:39
Lehigh 57
Rider 47 2nd Half 12:59
Binghamton 39
SC State 30 2nd Half 12:20
Clemson 40
Fairfield 41 2nd Half 13:12
Iowa State 48
Richmond 61 2nd Half 7:34
Eastern Kentucky 40
Cleveland State 52 2nd Half 10:56
Morehead St 52
Kent State 45 2nd Half 13:03
Colgate 35
South Alabama 27 2nd Half 8:13
UAB 62
Saint Peters 26 2nd Half 11:49
Navy 52
Youngstown St 35 2nd Half 10:18
Pittsburgh 51
NJIT 30 2nd Half 14:36
Lafayette 43
Davidson 15 2nd Half 16:04
Charlotte 47
Indiana State 26 1st Half 2:57
St Johns 22
Southern U 16 1st Half 1:22
Florida 38
Wright State 16 2nd Half
Purdue 31
Elon 2:00 PM
(6) North Carolina
Ill-Springfield 2:00 PM
SE Missouri St
(19) Oklahoma St 9 1st Half 11:59
USC 13
Houston 10 1st Half 9:54
Texas Tech 10
Ark-Little Rock 10 1st Half 12:55
Tulsa 8
Dayton 5 1st Half 15:07
Vanderbilt 10
Northern Ariz 9 1st Half 13:20
New Mexico 6
UNC-Asheville 8 1st Half 15:28
USC Upstate 4
North Dakota 8 1st Half 13:37
South Dakota 15
Western Ill 11 1st Half 14:02
Marquette 8
Ball State 7 1st Half 12:42
Western Ky 19
(8) Kentucky 8 1st Half 12:16
(13) Duke 17
New Orleans 41 1st Half 12:17
Alabama 52
Chicago State 6 1st Half 14:36
Milwaukee 11
Bowling Green 7 1st Half 16:07
Bradley 2
Northern Ill 4 1st Half 15:38
Northern Iowa 7
(23) Iowa 13 1st Half 13:52
Drake 14
Central Michigan 2:30 PM
Minnesota
Western Carolina 2:30 PM
North Florida
Wyoming 3:00 PM
Colorado
Portland 3:00 PM
Boise State
Cal Poly 3:00 PM
Colorado State
No Dakota State 3:00 PM
Grand Canyon
Albany 3:00 PM
Cal State Fullerton
Oklahoma 3:00 PM
Arkansas
Idaho State 3:00 PM
Seattle
(18) Michigan State 3:00 PM
(19) Syracuse
Northwestern 3:30 PM
Arizona State
TX-Arlington 3:30 PM
North Texas
Fresno State 4:00 PM
Oregon
St Francis-PA 4:00 PM
Coastal Carolina
UNLV 4:00 PM
CS-Bakersfield
UCLA 4:00 PM
(2) Connecticut
(10) Louisville 4:00 PM
(24) California
Howard 5:00 PM
Virginia
Miami-Ohio 6:00 PM
(21) Miss State
Illinois-Chicago 8:30 PM
Old Dominion
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Should the lake where the albino muskie was caught remain a mystery?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close