Dennis Anderson: Waterfowler who limits shots will kill more birds

  • Article by: DENNIS ANDERSON , Star Tribune
  • Updated: October 28, 2011 - 7:16 AM

Hunters need to regularly pattern their guns to be aware of changes in shotshells.

hide

Wisconsin firearms safety instructor Brett Bader positioned a mounted duck against a shotgun patterning target to illustrate the bird’s relative size. The “18’’ and “24’’ written with a marker pen represent inches, top to bottom. The target is also 24 inches across.

Photo: Dennis Anderson, Star Tribune

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

Calling ducks close enough so they present good shots can be difficult. So can killing a bird that in some cases flies more than 30 miles per hour. And recovering a downed duck with a dog often is the result of years' worth of training.

All are part of the challenge of duck hunting.

But perhaps nothing is as challenging in waterfowling, and as mysterious, as matching a hunter to a shotgun that fits him or her, and choosing the gun choke and shotshell that gives the hunter the best chance to kill ducks cleanly.

This process has become more complex since the advent in recent decades of nontoxic (primarily steel) shot. First offered for sale in the 1970s, steel or other nontoxic shot is now required for duck and goose hunting, replacing lead, whose use in waterfowling dates to the 16th century.

Lead shot, scientists have demonstrated, harms wildlife and the environment in various, serious ways.

Changes abound

But which steel shot loads work best for ducks and which chokes? That question is often on the minds of waterfowlers, especially after they miss a shot they thought they should have made.

The fact that steel and other nontoxic shotshells are continually being refined is one factor to consider. Shotshell manufacturers, like other manufacturers, are forever trying to improve their products, and changes they make, year to year, can affect performance.

Hunters who fail to regularly pattern their shotguns won't be aware of these changes.

My interest in all of this was piqued after reading a column in Field and Stream magazine by Phil Bourjaily that examined the performance of different shotshell loads fired at various distances through the same gun, using various chokes.

His conclusions, in a nutshell: You'd best pattern your gun to see how different load and choke combinations perform. And it might be a good idea to use a different load in the chamber of your shotgun (for relatively closer shots) than the two rounds (often for longer shots) held in your gun's magazine.

Curious about my shotgun's performance, I called a friend, Wisconsin firearms safety instructor Brett Bader, and he and I blasted a bunch of holes through targets the other morning, testing different shotshells at 25 and 35 yards, using two chokes -- modified and improved cylinder -- in my Browning Maxus 12 gauge.

Our finding: The waterfowler who limits himself to shots of 25 yards or less will kill more birds -- probably a lot more -- than the hunter who fires at ducks (or geese) flying 35 yards or farther away.

Brett and I began by testing two 3-inch shotshells -- 1 1/8-ounce Winchester Xpert #3 and 1¼-ounce Federal Black Cloud #3 -- fired at 25 yards. Through modified chokes, both rounds provided excellent coverage.

About half the cost

Changing to improved cylinder chokes, both shells again provided adequate concentrations of pellets within 24- and 30-inch circles to cleanly kill ducks (or geese). (Federal, I'm sure, would argue the Black Cloud would kill comparatively more cleanly than the Xpert because of the irregular shape of Black Cloud FlightStopper pellets and because the pellets are delivered with more down-range energy.)

On the other hand, the Xpert loads cost about half what Black Cloud costs, about $10 a box to about $20.

Shooting both loads at 35 yards, the patterns opened up significantly, and differences emerged between the two. Bourjaily, in his column, advised that to kill big ducks such as mallards, a minimum of 90 pellet strikes are needed in a 30-inch circle.

Assuming that measure is correct (though I believe a more accurate standard, particularly with steel, is 24 inches), the #3 Black Cloud delivered a lethal load (though not as lethal, measured by pattern density, as at 25 yards), while the #3 Xpert fell somewhat short (switching to #2 loads of Xpert at 35 yards delivered better patterns).

My conclusion, again: Regardless of shotshell used, the best chance a hunter has to kill ducks cleanly with steel loads is to take shots of about 25 yards or less. Beyond that range, tighter patterning (and more expensive) loads might be best to have in a shotgun magazine, among them No. 2 Black Cloud, No. 2 Winchester Supreme High Velocity, some variety of Hevi-Shot (about $3 per shell) or similar shells.

Dennis Anderson • danderson@startribune.com

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

Click here to send us your hunting or fishing photos – and to see what others are showing off from around the region.

ADVERTISEMENT

Tennessee 10 3rd Qtr 1:50
Jacksonville 14
Philadelphia 12/20/14 3:30 PM
Washington
San Diego 12/20/14 7:25 PM
San Francisco
Minnesota 12/21/14 12:00 PM
Miami
Baltimore 12/21/14 12:00 PM
Houston
Detroit 12/21/14 12:00 PM
Chicago
Cleveland 12/21/14 12:00 PM
Carolina
Atlanta 12/21/14 12:00 PM
New Orleans
Green Bay 12/21/14 12:00 PM
Tampa Bay
Kansas City 12/21/14 12:00 PM
Pittsburgh
New England 12/21/14 12:00 PM
NY Jets
NY Giants 12/21/14 3:05 PM
St. Louis
Buffalo 12/21/14 3:25 PM
Oakland
Indianapolis 12/21/14 3:25 PM
Dallas
Seattle 12/21/14 7:30 PM
Arizona
Denver 12/22/14 7:30 PM
Cincinnati
New York 89 4th Qtr 4:14
Chicago 90
New Orleans 70 4th Qtr 10:56
Houston 70
Milwaukee 13 1st Qtr 4:38
Sacramento 20
Oklahoma City 9:30 PM
Golden State
Florida 2 FINAL(SO)
Philadelphia 1
Colorado 0 FINAL(OT)
Pittsburgh 1
Toronto 1 FINAL
Carolina 4
Washington 5 FINAL(OT)
Columbus 4
Anaheim 1 3rd Prd 11:53
Montreal 1
St. Louis 9:30 PM
Los Angeles
Edmonton 9:30 PM
San Jose
St Thomas (TX) 61 FINAL
Rice 72
Stony Brook 59 FINAL
Canisius 60
Temple 82 FINAL
Delaware 62
FIU 58 FINAL
Long Island 69
Lehigh 65 FINAL
Quinnipiac 80
South Alabama 54 FINAL
Richmond 65
Seton Hall 89 FINAL
South Florida 69
Ga Southern 76 FINAL
Stetson 67
Yale 57 FINAL
Vermont 56
Cleveland State 54 FINAL
Virginia 70
Wright State 69 FINAL
Western Carolina 56
Nicholls 54 FINAL
Louisiana Tech 79
Morgan State 48 FINAL
Rider 62
Idaho State 72 FINAL
South Dakota St 75
Oakland City 52 FINAL
Austin Peay 76
Eureka 38 FINAL
Bradley 80
Appalachian St 65 FINAL
Charlotte 75
Connecticut 56 FINAL
Duke 66
Southern Miss 46 FINAL
Jackson State 66
Coastal Carolina 68 FINAL
Ole Miss 71
Montana State 53 FINAL
South Dakota 55
LSU 58 2nd Half 11:21
UAB 51
Ohio 50 2nd Half 13:34
Evansville 46
CS-Dominguez 4 1st Half 11:48
Cal State Fullerton 5
Walla Walla 19 1st Half 11:46
Idaho 11
DePaul 8 1st Half 12:35
Oregon State 20
Nevada 7 1st Half 11:50
Pacific 10
Portland State 11 1st Half 9:20
San Francisco 15
CS-Bakersfield 3 1st Half 18:05
Utah State 0
Nevada 12/20/14 10:00 AM
Louisiana
Utah State 12/20/14 1:20 PM
Texas-El Paso
(23) Utah 12/20/14 2:30 PM
Colorado State
Western Mich 12/20/14 4:45 PM
Air Force
South Alabama 12/20/14 8:15 PM
Bowling Green
BYU 12/22/14 1:00 PM
Memphis
Marshall 12/23/14 5:00 PM
Northern Ill
Navy 12/23/14 8:30 PM
San Diego St
Central Mich 12/24/14 11:00 AM
Western Ky
Fresno State 12/24/14 7:00 PM
Rice
Niagara 76 FINAL
Cleveland State 58
High Point 59 FINAL
VA Commonwealth 81
Towson 64 FINAL
Wake Forest 74
Presbyterian 50 FINAL
Charlotte 66
Chicago State 62 FINAL
Bradley 59
Northwestern Coll 58 FINAL
Drake 102
Vanderbilt 67 FINAL
Marquette 80
Temple 78 FINAL
Howard 48
Southern Miss 66 FINAL
Ole Miss 68
UMBC 55 FINAL
Rider 67
Miami-Florida 74 FINAL
UCLA 67
St Mary-KS 51 FINAL
South Dakota 115
William & Mary 71 FINAL
Wofford 51
Troy 82 FINAL
Evansville 94
Loyola Marymount 54 FINAL
USC 96
St Francis-PA 52 FINAL
Duquesne 92
Indiana-Southeast 45 FINAL
IUPUI 95
Delaware State 52 FINAL
Detroit 74
Tenn Temple 48 FINAL
Gardner-Webb 68
West Virginia St 58 FINAL
Radford 52
Fairfield 47 FINAL
Seton Hall 79
Dartmouth 44 FINAL
New Hampshire 60
Ball State 47 FINAL
Pittsburgh 59
Jacksonville 61 FINAL
Tennessee St 64
Trine 45 FINAL
Western Mich 81
Tenn Tech 53 FINAL
Lipscomb 72
Samford 56 FINAL
Tulane 57
New Orleans 55 FINAL
Tulsa 78
Incarnate Word 61 FINAL
TX-Pan American 65
Ark-Little Rock 42 FINAL
South Dakota St 67
CS-Northridge 72 2nd Half 0:47
Northern Ariz 68
Santa Clara 59 2nd Half 8:57
Oregon 49
(19) Oklahoma St 36 2nd Half 13:08
Weber State 33
Washington 45 2nd Half 9:33
San Diego State 34
Cal Poly 46 2nd Half 12:20
New Mexico 55
(10) Louisville 44 2nd Half 12:34
Grand Canyon 31
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Should the lake where the albino muskie was caught remain a mystery?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close