Chip Scoggins: Kill made right call in removing freshman QB's redshirt

  • Article by: CHIP SCOGGINS , Star Tribune
  • Updated: October 20, 2012 - 9:43 PM

The Gophers need to start preparing for the future, and getting Philip Nelson onto the field this year is a necessary step.

hide

True freshman Philip Nelson of Mankato endured a baptism-by-fire debut against Wisconsin. (MARLIN LEVISON/STARTRIBUNE(mlevison@startribune.com

Photo: Marlin Levison, Star Tribune

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

MADISON, WIS. - Jerry Kill probably felt like a human piñata this past week. At every turn -- thwack! -- the Gophers football coach absorbed blunt-force frustration from fans and media over his decision to fork over $800,000 to cancel a home-and-home series against North Carolina.

That announcement likewise proved costly in public relations goodwill, but Kill quietly made a second critical decision that was right on the mark.

Kill's willingness to remove the redshirt from freshman quarterback Philip Nelson on Saturday was prompted by injuries at that position, but it absolutely was the right call to turn the page and give Nelson control of the offense, even if the result was entirely predictable.

Nelson endured a baptism-by-fire debut in a 38-13 loss to Wisconsin at Camp Randall Stadium. He passed for 149 yards and two touchdowns with two interceptions. He also rushed for a team-high 67 yards on 16 carries.

Nelson did some good things and had some tough moments, but he finished the game and will benefit because of it. That's all that matters right now.

The Gophers have lost their first three Big Ten games and clearly have miles to go before they are competitive in conference play. They still have a chance to reach bowl eligibility, but they can't lose sight of the big picture. They're trying to build a program, and getting Nelson experience this season is an important step in that process.

"There's no question we made a good decision," Kill said.

Granted, they didn't have too many other good options. MarQueis Gray's body is battered to the point that he was available only as a wide receiver. Max Shortell suffered an injury last week that required a midweek MRI and affected his ability to throw the ball. The Gophers could have pieced something together to preserve Nelson's redshirt, but at this point, why not start his clock and let him get his feet wet?

"With the lack of durability at that position, we said, 'Hey, we need to get this guy some experience,'" Kill said. "I feel like it's going to help us a lot in the long run."

Fans tend to become overly annoyed whenever a coach removes a freshman's redshirt during the season. That's understandable, and it's certainly reckless if that happens late in the season with only a few games remaining. But Nelson took over at the season's halfway point. He gets six Big Ten games to gain valuable experience. That shouldn't be discounted or dismissed as a wasted season.

College football is so fluid and unpredictable that it's not always prudent to become consumed by what might happen four years from now. It's not like Kill and his staff aren't going to recruit more quarterbacks behind Nelson. A lot can happen between now and 2016, which is when Nelson would have been a fifth-year senior.

The Gophers need Nelson to take his lumps and growing pains so that he returns next season more confident and comfortable with everything. On a smaller scale, the situation feels similar to the plan the Vikings used with Christian Ponder last season. Throw him into the fire, let him learn on the job and, presumably, he'll benefit from that experience in Year 2.

"It will benefit greatly," Nelson said. "We'll be able to build some team chemistry between me and the offensive line and the receivers. It will make things go smoothly next year."

That's their hope, anyway. Nelson's development suddenly becomes the overriding theme the rest of the season. He is the starter even when Gray and Shortell regain their health.

Kill indicated that Gray will still get an occasional series at quarterback as a change of pace, but wide receiver is his primary position now. Shortell simply did not capitalize on his opportunity in Gray's absence, so he becomes a backup.

In a perfect world, Nelson would have started from Day 1, but he wasn't ready and Gray deserved the opportunity to see if he could build on last season. The landscape changed because of injuries and ineffectiveness, and the Gophers find themselves in a different place.

They need to see if the young blue-chip quarterback from Mankato is as good everyone believes and get him experience so he's not starting from scratch next fall.

"We've got to look down the road here a little bit," Kill said. "We'll still redshirt over 20 kids. But we also need some kids to get experience because we don't want to keep coming to Wisconsin with somebody who's not experienced."

Chip Scoggins • ascoggins@startribune.com

  • PHILIP NELSON'S DEBUT

    True freshman Philip Nelson, a former standout at Mankato West, saw his first college action Saturday, starting and playing the entire game against Wisconsin. Here is a brief look at his debut:

    The numbers: 13-for-24 passing for 149 yards, two TDs and two interceptions. Also ran the ball 16 times for 67 yards.

    The highs: Led two impressive scoring drives (65 and 66 yards), capping both with touchdown passes. ... Looked poised and generally made good decisions.

    The lows: Threw two second-half interceptions, both into tight coverage, helping seal the Gophers' fate. ... The offense gained just 245 yards, the lowest total of the season.

    The quote: "I think no question, it's a good move for us." -- Gophers coach Jerry Kill on starting Nelson at quarterback Saturday.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

ADVERTISEMENT

Atlanta 6 FINAL
Detroit 4
Philadelphia 3 FINAL
Houston 6
St. Louis 4 FINAL
Miami 1
Baltimore 3 FINAL
Tampa Bay 2
NY Yankees 2 FINAL
Pittsburgh 1
Chicago Cubs 6 FINAL
San Francisco 8
Los Angeles 6 FINAL
Chicago WSox 1
San Diego 4 FINAL
Seattle 9
Cleveland 9 FINAL
Cincinnati 3
Milwaukee 2 FINAL
LA Angels 3
Oakland 2 FINAL
Chicago Cubs 2
Texas 4 FINAL
Kansas City 5
Colorado 3 FINAL
Arizona 4
NY Mets 4 FINAL
Washington 5
Boston 8 FINAL
Minnesota 9
Toronto 0 FINAL
Baltimore 5
Oklahoma City 105 FINAL
Chicago 108
Dallas 75 FINAL
Portland 94
Calgary 4 FINAL(SO)
Boston 3
St. Louis 1 FINAL
Philadelphia 3
Minnesota 2 FINAL
Washington 1
Toronto 2 FINAL
Tampa Bay 4
Dallas 4 FINAL(SO)
Florida 3
NY Islanders 4 FINAL
Nashville 3
Vancouver 2 FINAL(SO)
Arizona 3
Montreal 3 FINAL(SO)
Los Angeles 4
Morgan State 76 FINAL
MD-Eastern Shore 89
Niagara 54 FINAL
Siena 71
Holy Cross 83 FINAL
Bucknell 90
Western Ky 88 FINAL
Charlotte 84
Navy 62 FINAL
Colgate 72
Temple 70 FINAL
East Carolina 56
UAB 59 FINAL
Fla Atlantic 62
Boston Univ 64 FINAL
Lafayette 89
American Univ 68 FINAL
Lehigh 62
Wisconsin 76 FINAL
Minnesota 63
Fairfield 33 FINAL
Saint Peters 63
Arkansas 78 FINAL
South Carolina 74
Morehead State 76 FINAL
UT Martin 65
USC Upstate 63 FINAL
Fla Gulf Coast 62
Lipscomb 57 FINAL
North Florida 71
Southern Ill 55 FINAL
Missouri State 48
Texas State 64 FINAL
Appalachian St 67
SC State 62 FINAL
Bethune-Cookman 72
Delaware State 104 FINAL
Coppin State 92
Middle Tennessee 54 FINAL
FIU 59
Texas-Arlington 64 FINAL
Ga Southern 76
Norfolk State 80 FINAL
Hampton 69
NC A&T 58 FINAL
NC Central 69
Savannah State 57 FINAL
Florida A&M 64
Southern Miss 61 FINAL
Louisiana Tech 72
Marshall 50 FINAL
Old Dominion 67
Rice 76 FINAL
TX-San Antonio 74
South Alabama 81 FINAL
Arkansas State 76
Alabama State 78 FINAL
Grambling St 46
Alabama A&M 54 FINAL
Jackson State 72
Sam Houston St 67 FINAL
Lamar 61
Georgia State 58 FINAL
ULM 50
Central Arkansas 70 FINAL
Nicholls 77
Portland State 51 FINAL
Northern Ariz 58
Southern U 77 FINAL
Prairie View 73
Alcorn State 73 FINAL
Texas Southern 94
Houston Baptist 72 FINAL
TX A&M-CC 85
Ark-Little Rock 69 FINAL
Louisiana 75
SE Louisiana 79 FINAL
New Orleans 85
California 60 FINAL
Arizona 99
Memphis 54 FINAL
Connecticut 53
VA Commonwealth 55 FINAL
Davidson 82
Ark-Pine Bluff 0 Postponed
Miss Valley St 0
Sacramento St 65 FINAL
Southern Utah 69
Northwestern St 66 FINAL
Stephen F Austin 92
North Texas 60 FINAL
Texas-El Paso 83
Colorado 64 FINAL
Washington 47
Idaho 63 FINAL
Weber State 74
Abilene Christian 52 FINAL
Incarnate Word 64
Eastern Wash 85 FINAL
Idaho State 81
Marist 80 FINAL
Quinnipiac 74
Eastern Ill 64 FINAL
Belmont 97
Bradley 52 FINAL
Drake 50
Cal State Fullerton 62 FINAL
UC Irvine 68
CS-Northridge 58 FINAL
Long Beach State 69
UC Riverside 59 FINAL
UC Davis 61
Stanford 62 FINAL
Arizona State 67
Utah 67 FINAL
Washington St 59
Monmouth 68 FINAL
Canisius 56
Wake Forest 85 FINAL
(22) Syracuse 79
Saint Louis 65 FINAL
VA Commonwealth 58
Saint Peters 62 FINAL
Rider 54
UNC-Asheville 51 FINAL
Liberty 59
UNC Greensboro 44 FINAL
(17) Chattanooga 78
Michigan State 69 FINAL
Michigan 49
Arkansas 72 FINAL
Ole Miss 61
Manhattan 51 FINAL
Niagara 57
Massachusetts 63 FINAL
Richmond 67
Virginia 52 FINAL
Miami-Florida 62
Jacksonville St 45 FINAL
Belmont 55
Morgan State 65 FINAL
MD-Eastern Shore 50
Campbell 65 FINAL
Winthrop 52
Furman 65 FINAL
Samford 54
Oregon 64 FINAL
Washington St 66
Indiana 52 FINAL
(23) Rutgers 63
Pepperdine 67 FINAL
Loyola Marymount 68
Auburn 47 FINAL
(18) Texas A&M 57
Morehead St 66 FINAL
Tennessee St 81
George Mason 43 FINAL
Saint Josephs 71
Western Carolina 53 FINAL
East Tenn St 73
Arizona 62 FINAL
UCLA 80
FIU 30 FINAL
Middle Tennessee 79
Texas State 55 FINAL
Appalachian St 61
TX-Arlington 66 FINAL
Georgia Southern 41
SC State 57 FINAL
Bethune-Cookman 56
Delaware State 51 FINAL
Coppin State 80
Portland 58 FINAL
Santa Clara 66
Norfolk State 49 FINAL
Hampton 64
Florida Atlantic 56 FINAL
UAB 59
NC A&T 67 FINAL
NC Central 46
Savannah State 72 FINAL
Florida A&M 51
Virginia Tech 51 FINAL
Pittsburgh 45
Central Arkansas 43 FINAL
Nicholls 53
Houston Baptist 48 FINAL
TX A&M-CC 73
Gardner-Webb 70 FINAL
Radford 56
Georgia 75 FINAL
Missouri 64
Old Dominion 67 FINAL
Marshall 55
Ark-Little Rock 68 FINAL
Louisiana 66
South Alabama 60 FINAL
Arkansas State 70
Georgia State 66 FINAL
ULM 61
Sam Houston St 73 FINAL
Lamar 92
SE Louisiana 75 FINAL
New Orleans 84
Northwestern St 45 FINAL
Stephen F Austin 56
Alabama A&M 58 FINAL
Jackson State 66
Alabama State 68 FINAL
Grambling 62
Southern U 78 FINAL
Prairie View 50
Alcorn State 55 FINAL
Texas Southern 73
Ark-Pine Bluff 0 Postponed
Miss Valley St 0
Wofford 54 FINAL
Mercer 75
Abilene Christian 72 FINAL
Incarnate Word 62
La Salle 60 FINAL
Rhode Island 65
Illinois 71 FINAL
Nebraska 86
TX-San Antonio 60 FINAL
Rice 49
Valparaiso 55 FINAL
Oakland 70
Missouri State 65 FINAL
Indiana State 56
Georgia Tech 64 FINAL
(15) North Carolina 84
Charlotte 72 FINAL
Western Ky 80
Texas-El Paso 69 FINAL
North Texas 61
Wichita State 77 FINAL
Evansville 63
Loyola-Chicago 64 FINAL
Northern Iowa 69
Bradley 70 FINAL
Drake 86
Presbyterian 62 FINAL
High Point 75
Vanderbilt 61 FINAL
(12) Kentucky 67
Colorado 75 FINAL
USC 63
San Francisco 74 FINAL
Pacific 64
Idaho State 58 FINAL
Eastern Washington 62
Weber State 42 FINAL
Idaho 71
Purdue 78 FINAL
Minnesota 82
Cal-Irvine 54 FINAL
Cal State Fullerton 66
Long Beach St 60 FINAL
CS-Northridge 77
Hawaii 60 FINAL
UC Santa Barbara 36
UC Davis 56 FINAL
UC-Riverside 61
Northern Ariz 79 FINAL
Portland State 62
Southern Utah 73 FINAL
Sacramento St 107
Utah 64 FINAL
Washington 75
BYU 65 FINAL
St Marys-CA 64
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: Who is the best center on a Twin Cities sports team?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close