Division III hockey: High schoolers pushed aside by older players

  • Article by: DENNIS BRACKIN , Star Tribune
  • Updated: January 12, 2012 - 9:06 AM

Division III hockey used to be a reliable Plan B for high school players failing to land on a Division I roster. But now college coaches -- even in the MIAC, which has no athletic scholarships -- are recruiting older junior hockey players.


St. Thomas’ Chris Hickey and Hamline’s Troy Hesketh — both NHL draft picks — have found a hockey home playing in the MIAC, a Division III conference.

Photo: Kyndell Harkness, Star Tribune

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

Their individual dreams were once the same, of Division I hockey and large, rowdy crowds at places such as Minnesota, Wisconsin or North Dakota.

But the players who fill the rosters of MIAC men's hockey teams offer proof that the Division I dream is as elusive as it is widespread for Minnesota high school players.

The MIAC is comprised of relatively small, private schools that, as NCAA Division III members, can offer no athletic scholarships. Less than a decade ago, the MIAC recruited most of its players directly out of high school. This season 78 percent of the league's varsity players are products of the junior hockey ranks.

It is not an exaggeration, league coaches and players say, to conclude that almost 80 percent of the league's players still carried hopes of playing Division I when they finished high school.

"I don't think being in Minnesota high school hockey, as glorified as it is, that any kid's goal is to be playing Division III,'' said Brian Arrigoni, a former Hill-Murray star who is now a senior at Hamline. "Everyone hopes and wishes for the best, but it doesn't always happen."

And yet, the MIAC can hardly be called a league of broken dreams, although at first glance it might appear that way.

On a recent Friday night, Arrigoni and his Hamline teammates faced St. Thomas at Vadnais Heights Sports Complex, and the bright lights of Division I were in a different galaxy. The game was played in a high school-size arena that has eight rows of bleachers on one side of the rink, three rows on the other.

Plenty of good seats went unfilled.

But the level of hockey belied the surroundings, indicative of the MIAC's recent improvement, coaches say. As the percentage of former junior players has spiked in the past five years, there have been corresponding upgrades in physical traits that come with age, such as strength and speed. MIAC Executive Director Dan McKane said the "level of play is at an all-time high."

"People just aren't educated as to how good this league is," St. John's coach Doug Schueller said. "Every high school kid in the state thinks he can play Division III hockey. That's not the case anymore."

The road to juniors

Arrigoni, who might be the league's most skilled playmaker and a Division III All-America a year ago, is the classic example of the kid who dreamed -- legitimately -- of playing at the highest level. He was a standout at Hill-Murray, playing alongside future Gophers Mike Hoeffel and Nick Larson.

Arrigoni suffered a serious shoulder injury as a high school senior, and surgery at the end of the year required four anchors and eight pins to secure his shoulder in place. So much for his immediate hopes of following his high school teammates to Minnesota.

He moved on to Indiana in the United States Hockey League -- the top American junior league from which most Division I players come. He said he was in essence a role player, miscast in his mind, although at the end of the year he received a Division I offer from Mercyhurst.

"I was young, and I don't know if I was arrogant or what, but as a Minnesota kid I had always dreamed of playing WCHA hockey, so I turned it down," Arrigoni said. "To make a long story short, I struggled a bit the next year and didn't get another offer."

There are countless such stories in the conference, each one with a slightly different twist. The MIAC boasts a pair of NHL draft picks -- Hamline's Troy Hesketh, selected in the third round by Edmonton in 2009, and St. Thomas' Chris Hickey, a seventh-round Wild choice in 2006. There are about a dozen Division I transfers, several former players from Shattuck-St. Mary's in Faribault (Minnesota's equivalent of a hockey prep school), three Swedish teammates at St. John's and 11 Canadians and a Czech player at Concordia (Moorhead).

The reason for the MIAC's shift in recruiting base from high schools to juniors, and in some cases foreign players, is part of a national trend in college hockey. The MIAC, in fact, is a relative latecomer to recruiting juniors compared to many Eastern schools and rival Wisconsin state colleges such as UW-River Falls, Stevens Point and Eau Claire, which average about 90 percent former junior players on their rosters.

The MIAC has not had a team in either of the past two NCAA Division III Final Fours, and never has won an NCAA hockey title.

"If we want to keep up with all the other teams in Division III, and have success, we had to alter our direction and go toward junior kids," St. Thomas coach Jeff Boeser said.

The change in philosophy is not without challenges, McKane said. The varied backgrounds of the players has led to increased scrutiny to ensure eligibility.

McKane said the critical issue is making sure players received no payment that violated NCAA rules, and did not play in a league against professionals. That's especially challenging when reviewing résumés of foreign players, and McKane said he has at times had to rule against players seeking to enterthe league.

"It's completely different than all our other sports," McKane said. "Hockey is the only sport right now having kids delay enrollment because they've pursued their hope of playing at the highest level, Division I."

Juniors required?

St. Mary's coach Bill Moore is a former high school coach and head of the state hockey coaches association. But he said he has not watched a high school game for almost two years.

"I love Minnesota high school hockey, but the fact is you can't win with 18-year-old kids playing against 24-year-old college seniors," Moore said. "You're looking at junior players who are 20-year-old freshmen, with 120 games more experience than high school kids. And some of those juniors are borderline Division I players."

Moore offers this caveat: His preference for juniors is based in part on being in the midst of a rebuilding project at St. Mary's, which he says makes it difficult to attract an elite high school player. He notes that the top conference programs, such as St. Thomas, still attract interest from such players.

An example is Riley Horgan, who jumped directly from Mound-Westonka to St. Thomas. The benefits of taking Horgan out of high school, St. Thomas' Boeser said, extend beyond his obvious talent level.

"If Riley would have played juniors, we'd have never gotten him," Boeser said. "He'd be playing Division I right now."

Still, players such as Horgan are more and more becoming the exception, largely because juniors are generally bigger and stronger. That, Moore said, was highlighted for him in fall tryouts, when four of his players suffered concussions. All four were straight out of high school.

Talent upswing

The MIAC's caliber of competition is such that Hesketh doesn't believe his prospects of playing in the NHL will be diminished by his college choice. Hesketh initially went to juniors after graduating from Minnetonka, then suffered a serious concussion that sidelined him almost four months. His perspective of hockey changed, he said, and he opted to decommit from Wisconsin and enroll at Hamline.

Edmonton has effectively cut its ties with Hesketh, but the player remains optimistic another NHL team will give him a look.

"In juniors, you're more of a number than a name; it's run as a business," Hesketh said. "I heard about the Hamline program, how well they were doing, and I wanted to get a good education, so I went with it. It doesn't matter where you play, it's how you play.

"I still have everything in place for me. I'm chasing my [NHL] dream. But I'm going to be further along [with an education] than most kids who start out in pro hockey."

Several MIAC players, including Arrigoni, hope to continue chasing a pro hockey career after they leave school, as former Hamline star Chris Berenguer did this season with Trenton in the East Coast Hockey League.

"You go through an adjustment period after you realize you're not going to Division I or going to the Gophers, wherever it may be," Arrigoni said. "But there's still opportunities to go out and play professionally [out of the MIAC]."

Not everyone views the MIAC as a steppingstone for more hockey. Rob Philipp, a St. Thomas senior, played two years of juniors, got a Division I offer at Air Force and, after weeks of deliberation, opted to decommit and enroll at St. Thomas.

"It's weird, everyone goes to juniors because they want a Division I scholarship," Philipp said. "That was my goal for a long time. But now, after a few years in the MIAC, I'm really happy with my decision."

Philipp has a job offer from Honeywell and has July 11 -- his start date -- circled on his calendar.

Until then, he'll try to help the Tommies chase a conference title in a league that has changed dramatically from the one he entered four seasons ago.

"It's almost necessary now to have played juniors to crack the lineup in Division III," he said. "It's gotten that competitive."

  • related content

  • MIAC coaches go far and wide to find junior hockey talent

    Wednesday January 11, 2012

    The basic components of economics -- supply and demand -- is behind the MIAC's switch to recruiting mostly junior hockey talent.

  • Chart: Makeup of MIAC hockey rosters

    Wednesday January 11, 2012

    A look at the number of players who come straight out of high school to play at MIAC schools:

  • Chris Hickey (7), a senior forward for MIAC-leading St. Thomas, first played junior hockey for the Tri-City Storm in the USHL before joining the Tommies.

  • Hamline’s Troy Hesketh decommitted from Wisconsin and enrolled at Hamline after a serious concussion changed his perspective, but he still harbors NHL dreams.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


Fla Southern 2 FINAL
Detroit 12
Miami 7
Toronto 114 FINAL
Philadelphia 103
Golden State 108 FINAL
Brooklyn 110
Phoenix 98 FINAL
Miami 115
LA Clippers 110 FINAL
Minnesota 105
New Orleans 93 FINAL
Dallas 102
Nashville 1 FINAL
NY Rangers 4
Carolina 2 FINAL
Chicago 5
Montreal 0 FINAL
San Jose 4
Virginia 59 FINAL
Syracuse 47
Baylor 59 FINAL
Texas 61
SE Louisiana 79 FINAL
Northwestern St 92
Central Arkansas 49 FINAL
Sam Houston St 76
Norfolk State 59 FINAL
Howard 61
Bethune-Cookman 50 FINAL
NC A&T 67
Hampton 75 FINAL
Delaware State 85
Lamar 69 FINAL
McNeese State 70
Nicholls 89 FINAL
New Orleans 79
Incarnate Word 62 FINAL
Stephen F Austin 83
NC Central 62 FINAL
Savannah State 49
Texas Southern 77 FINAL
Alabama A&M 75
Prairie View 67 FINAL
Alabama State 65
Oklahoma 70 FINAL
Iowa State 77
Grambling St 62 FINAL
Miss Valley St 66
Boston College 66 FINAL
Virginia Tech 59
Jackson State 62 FINAL
Ark-Pine Bluff 64
Bethune-Cookman 55 FINAL
NC A&T 58
Hampton 78 FINAL
Delaware State 63
Norfolk State 63 FINAL
Howard 60
NC Central 54 FINAL
Savannah State 65
Texas Southern 83 FINAL
Alabama A&M 46
Prairie View 42 FINAL
Alabama State 60
Jackson State 78 FINAL
Ark-Pine Bluff 74
Grambling 56 FINAL
Miss Valley St 61
Tulsa 71 FINAL
Cincinnati 58
(1) Connecticut 88 FINAL
South Florida 65
East Carolina 67
Central Conn St 53 FINAL
Bryant 55
Wagner 66 FINAL
Robert Morris 60
Sacred Heart 75 FINAL
Fairleigh Dickinson 84
St Francis-NY 73 FINAL
Long Island 49
Mount St Marys 87 FINAL
St Francis-PA 90
Temple 56 FINAL
Houston 45
Texas Tech 65 FINAL
(6) Baylor 75
Iowa State 64 FINAL
Kansas 68
Memphis 53
Oklahoma 66 FINAL
Oklahoma St 56
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters





question of the day

Poll: Who is the best center on a Twin Cities sports team?

Weekly Question