Chip Scoggins: Peculiarities of BCS system leave Big Ten out

  • Article by: CHIP SCOGGINS , Star Tribune
  • Updated: October 29, 2011 - 12:33 AM

The conference has big obstacles to overcome if it is to send a one-loss team to the championship game.


Keith Nichol's 44-yard Hail Mary touchdown catch for Michigan State might have been good for the Spartans, but it might have cost the Big Ten its only chance at a national championship this year by handing Wisconsin its first loss.

Photo: Al Goldis, Associated Press

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

The Big Ten Conference was at the forefront of instant replay in college football. And Big Ten Commissioner Jim Delany has been a staunch supporter of the Bowl Championship Series formula for deciding a national champion.

That's what made the irony of last week's nail-biting finish in East Lansing richer than Bill Gates.

Instant replay overturned an official's ruling that a Hail Mary by Michigan State at the final horn came a whisker short of the goal line. The improbable finish sent the Spartans and their fans into a frenzy, left stunned Wisconsin with its first loss and all but assured the Big Ten is out of the national title picture before November.

The Badgers' loss left the conference without a team in the top 10 in the BCS standings this week. Michigan State is the highest-ranked Big Ten team at No. 11, followed by Nebraska (14) and Wisconsin (15).

Seven teams ahead of them remain unbeaten, meaning the Big Ten needs help and perhaps a different kind of Hail Mary to send a participant to the BCS title game for the first time since the 2007 season.

For those who crave a college football playoff, though, don't hold your breath.

"I don't know about ever," Delany said Thursday when asked about the potential for a playoff. "But I don't see that kind of thing in the near future."

Too bad. As much as we love college football and the drama that unfolds on a weekly basis, the sport's method for determining a national champion still drives us crazy. There has to be a better system than combining human polls and computer rankings. It's too confusing, which is why newspapers run an "explanation key" under the weekly BCS rankings. Here's an excerpt:

"Six computer rankings are used to determine the overall computer component. The highest and lowest ranking for each team is dropped -- and the remaining four are added and divided to produce a Computer Rankings Percentage."

Make sense? This might sound wishy-washy, but we're not advocating for the destruction of the bowl system. Bowl games are wonderful, even some of the minor ones. Not always, of course, but they often provide compelling matchups that keep you from nodding off in the Barcalounger during the holidays.

It just seems sort of strange to know a conference probably doesn't have a shot at the national title before all the leaves fall. That's not a Big Ten-centric complaint. That sentiment applies to any of the major conferences.

Maybe that's the beauty and curse of college football. BCS backers have long espoused the belief that the regular season is made more meaningful because teams face a win-or-else edict every week.

Wisconsin -- and the Big Ten, by extension -- certainly felt that sting this week. Granted, the conference will still send one and possibly two teams to BCS bowls. That brings a nice payday for all conference members, especially if a second team receives an at-large bid.

The SEC has cornered the market on BCS titles of late, and LSU and Alabama look head and shoulders above the competition this season, too. (Some are even speculating that the BCS title game will be a rematch of next Saturday's clash between those two teams.)

The Badgers represented the Big Ten's best hope to at least be in that conversation -- until they stumbled on the road against a quality opponent. Now they must recalibrate their goals, even if they wouldn't dare admit so publicly.

"It's going to be hard to go through this conference unbeaten," Nebraska coach Bo Pelini said this week.

The good news for the Big Ten is that the addition of Nebraska allows for a conference championship game, which gives the league another stage to showcase itself. The lack of a title game and traditional pre-Thanksgiving finish to the regular season always left the Big Ten with an out-of-sight-out-of-mind feel to it.

"I do think that having a 13th game -- where that eventual champion would beat another football team with a lot of wins -- is going to give that power rating a big boost and maybe that can happen," Michigan State coach Mark Dantonio said. "But I guess it's dependent on what everybody else does as well."

That's precisely the point.

Chip Scoggins •

  • related content

  • The Call: Gophers vs. Iowa

    Saturday October 29, 2011

    The Hawkeyes, with an offense that starts only three seniors, have ridden a surprisingly strong passing game and the rushing of Marcus Coker.

  • Bronze pig is still worth fighting for

    Saturday October 29, 2011

    A year after the Gophers reclaimed Floyd of Rosedale, its presence is rekindling confidence.

  • Big Ten, not top 10

    Friday October 28, 2011

    Team Record BCS avg.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


Washington - D. Fister 12:10 PM
NY Mets - D. Gee
Philadelphia - S. Gonzalez 12:10 PM
Miami - J. Cosart
Toronto - D. Hutchison 12:10 PM
Cleveland - T. Bauer
Cincinnati - J. Cueto 12:35 PM
Atlanta - J. Teheran
Tampa Bay - N. Karns 12:35 PM
Baltimore - W. Chen
Chicago WSox - J. Danks 1:10 PM
Minnesota - M. Pelfrey
Detroit - A. Sanchez 1:10 PM
Kansas City - J. Guthrie
Seattle - J. Happ 1:10 PM
Houston - R. Hernandez
Pittsburgh - V. Worley 1:15 PM
St. Louis - M. Wacha
Milwaukee - J. Nelson 1:20 PM
Chicago Cubs - J. Hammel
Oakland - S. Gray 2:05 PM
Texas - Y. Gallardo
LA Angels - J. Weaver 3:05 PM
San Francisco - T. Lincecum
Colorado - K. Kendrick 3:10 PM
San Diego - J. Shields
Arizona - C. Anderson 3:10 PM
Los Angeles - B. Anderson
NY Yankees - A. Warren 7:05 PM
Boston - J. Kelly
Washington 12:00 PM
Memphis 2:30 PM
Golden State
Tampa Bay 5:00 PM
Minnesota 7:30 PM
Calgary 9:00 PM
Chicago 4:00 PM
Sporting Kansas City
Seattle 6:00 PM
New York City
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters





question of the day

Poll: Does it bother you that Tyus Jones chose Duke over Minnesota?

Weekly Question