Souhan: Masters and Woods both take the low road

  • Article by: JIM SOUHAN , Star Tribune
  • Updated: April 13, 2013 - 11:48 PM

Perhaps the greatest golfer ever and the greatest golf tournament in existence should have held themselves to higher standards Saturday.

– Tiger Woods and the Masters should have been embarrassed on Saturday. Neither seems capable of that emotion.

Perhaps the greatest golfer ever and the greatest golf tournament in existence should have held themselves to higher standards.

The tournament should have recognized Woods’ rules violation during the second round, then should have intervened before Woods could sign his scorecard. Woods should have displayed a golfing form of honor by withdrawing when he realized he broke the rules while attempting to give himself a competitive advantage, even if his mistake was honest.

Instead, the Masters invoked a rule that shouldn’t necessarily apply to obvious mistakes like the one Woods made, to allow him to remain in the tournament with a two-shot penalty. By the end of Saturday, Woods stood four behind the lead, with a chance to win a tainted major.

“Under the rules of golf, I can play,” Woods said.

While the Masters and Woods adhered to the letter of the rules, the series of events made Augusta National smell about as bad as it does when the groundskeepers spread fertilizer to soak up a heavy rain, especially when the efforts to salvage Woods’ eligibility came one day after the tourney penalized a 14-year-old for slow play on a day filled with slow players.

Don’t take my word for it. Take it from one of golf’s most respected elders.

“I’m a pro now, since ’89,” said Ernie Els. “I’ve never seen a guy sign for a scorecard and then come back and play the next day after a rules infringement. It’s as simple as that. Nothing against nobody. The rules of the game is there, and it’s always been there, and this has never happened.”

Zach Johnson, who won the Masters in 2007, said: “Taking yourself out of the tournament is definitely an option. To formulate an opinion, I would like to understand what sequentially happened. I’d like to hope that any and all of my peers, if they knowingly or unknowingly violated the rules, would do what they feel is necessary to protect the field.”

What sequentially happened was this: Woods, playing the 15th hole on Friday, hit his third shot off the flagstick and into the water. When he dropped his ball for his next shot, he did not obey the rules that require him to drop as near as possible to his previous position. He dropped a couple of yards behind his previous divot, and on an incorrect line.

In most sports, he would have been excused or even commended for seeking an advantage. Golf is not like any other sport. Golfers pride themselves on calling penalties on themselves, and in golf ignorance of the rules is not an excuse. Woods could have called over a rules official but declined to.

He dropped his ball in a different place to gain an advantage on his next shot, and admitted that in a postround interview.

There are a dozen things wrong with this scenario and the way golf rules are applied. Tournament officials should have recognized Woods’ mistake before a television viewer called it in. Major championships should not be affected by phone calls. Golf’s rulebook is ridiculously long and impenetrable.

What matters is the spirit of the rules that govern a sport based on the honor code, and the spirit of the rules contends that if a player breaks a rule while seeking an advantage, he is disqualified. Saturday, the Masters let Woods off the hook and Woods accepted the charity.

If Woods wins on Sunday and winds up with 19 majors, breaking Jack Nickaus’ record, his achievement will deserve an asterisk.

“Disqualification, this morning, was not even on the table,” said Fred Ridley, the chairman of competition committee.

Friday afternoon, after signing his scorecard, Woods was asked about 14-year-old Guan Tianlang being penalized for slow play. Woods said, “Rules are rules.”

Saturday, Guan proved wiser than Woods or the Masters. Asked what he thought of Woods’ penalty, he said, “I think that rules are rules.”

  • related content

  • Photo gallery: Saturday at the Masters

    Saturday April 13, 2013

    Masters stunner: Tiger Woods gets 2-stroke penalty, but at least he gets to play on weekend

  • Cabrera, Snedeker tied for Masters lead but several are in contention

    Saturday April 13, 2013

    Brandt Snedeker and 2009 champion Angel Cabrera lead a pack of Aussies.

  • Tiger Woods watches his drive from the 15th tee box during third-round...

  • The scoreboard registered the impact of a two-stroke penalty assessed to Tiger Woods for a violation on the 15th hole during Friday’s second round.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

ADVERTISEMENT

Baltimore 2 FINAL
Detroit 15
NY Yankees 5 FINAL
Philadelphia 5
Northeastern 1 FINAL
Boston 2
Miami-Fla 1 FINAL
Miami 7
Pittsburgh 8 FINAL
Toronto 7
San Francisco 4 FINAL
Oakland 9
Cleveland 0 FINAL
Cincinnati 10
Boston College 0 FINAL
Boston 1
Arizona State 0 FINAL
Arizona 4
Boston 79 FINAL
Cleveland 110
LA Lakers 103 FINAL
Charlotte 104
Sacramento 124 FINAL
New York 86
Houston 96 FINAL
Atlanta 104
Utah 89 4th Qtr 2:54
Memphis 76
Washington 72 4th Qtr 8:13
Chicago 80
Milwaukee 50 2nd Qtr 2:44
Denver 50
Nashville 1 FINAL
New Jersey 3
Calgary 3 FINAL(OT)
Philadelphia 2
Washington 5 FINAL
Columbus 3
Buffalo 0 3rd Prd :29
Tampa Bay 3
Toronto 3 3rd Prd 14:06
Florida 2
Ottawa 2 3rd Prd 16:38
Minnesota 2
NY Islanders 1 2nd Prd 3:29
Dallas 0
Anaheim 1 2nd Prd 17:35
Arizona 0
Los Angeles 1 1st Prd 6:12
Edmonton 0
San Jose 9:00 PM
Vancouver
Ole Miss 82 FINAL
Alabama 74
Eastern Mich 67 FINAL
Ball State 60
Kent State 81 FINAL
Bowling Green 80
Ohio 66 FINAL
Buffalo 93
Georgetown 60 FINAL
Butler 54
Toledo 77 FINAL
Central Mich 85
Rhode Island 59 FINAL
Dayton 75
Youngstown St 67 FINAL
Detroit 77
North Carolina 81 FINAL
Georgia Tech 49
Loyola-Maryland 45 FINAL
Holy Cross 62
Iowa 77 FINAL
Indiana 63
Akron 63 FINAL
Miami-Ohio 70
Army 52 FINAL
Navy 56
Maryland 60 FINAL
Rutgers 50
Kennesaw St 54 FINAL
USC Upstate 90
Jacksonville 63 FINAL
Fla Gulf Coast 81
Lipscomb 76 FINAL
Northern Ky 73
Stetson 67 FINAL
North Florida 81
Wright State 57 FINAL
Ill-Chicago 60
Western Mich 62 2nd Half 0:24
Northern Ill 64
Nebraska Omaha 80 FINAL
North Dakota 78
Houston Baptist 71 FINAL
Abilene Christian 83
NC State 20 2nd Half 20:00
Clemson 21
Texas A&M 23 2nd Half
Florida 26
Kentucky 32 1st Half 0:28
Georgia 30
West Virginia 40 2nd Half
Kansas 26
Auburn 30 2nd Half
Missouri 30
Michigan 34 2nd Half 20:00
Northwestern 27
Villanova 19 1st Half 3:28
Creighton 24
Longwood 55 FINAL
Gardner-Webb 63
Charleston Southern 39 FINAL
Presbyterian 47
Coastal Carolina 54 FINAL
UNC-Asheville 68
NJIT 51 FINAL
UMass Lowell 60
West Virginia 55 FINAL
Kansas State 59
TCU 45 FINAL
Texas 79
Fresno State 30 2nd Half
Air Force 24
San Jose St 28 2nd Half
Boise State 48
Nevada 24 2nd Half
Colorado State 37
UNLV 18 2nd Half
San Diego State 26
Wyoming 29 2nd Half
Utah State 28
Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close