Carleton 49, Augsburg 41: Knights remain without a flaw

A back-and-forth game turned on Augsburg and left Carleton in first place in the MIAC with its first 5-0 mark since 1992.

By MYRON P. MEDCALF, Star Tribune

Last update: October 12, 2008 - 8:59 AM

NORTHFIELD, MINN. - Saturday's Augsburg-Carleton football matchup was such an intense back-and-forth battle that one of the refs cramped up and had to leave the game.

The Auggies and Knights went tit for tat the majority of the matchup before an onside kick, a blocked punt returned for a touchdown and a game-ending interception sealed a 49-41 Carleton victory. The Knights are off to their first 5-0 start since 1992 and took over first place in the MIAC by going 3-0 in conference.

Carleton's Jon Lien scored on a 14-yard run in the third quarter to tie the game 35-35, and the Knights followed by surprising Augsburg (4-1, 2-1 MIAC) with an onside kick that they recovered. Will McGivern-Smith ended that series with a 5-yard touchdown catch, giving Carleton its first lead of the afternoon at its homecoming game.

Drew Ziller built on that momentum when he blocked an Augsburg punt and returned it 25 yards for a touchdown on Augsburg's next possession. A fourth-quarter touchdown by Augsburg's Royce Winford made it 49-41, after a missed extra-point attempt. The Auggies had one last shot, but Ziller intercepted a pass intended for Winford with 27 seconds left.

"We finally got that blocked punt, it finally gave us ... even actually before that with the pooch kick recovered, the momentum shifted and it just stayed in our favor," Ziller said.

Augsburg dominated offensively. Jordan Berg completed 42 of 62 passes for 508 yards and four touchdowns. Muneer Al-Hameed caught 13 of the passes for 146 yards and two touchdowns, and Winford hauled in another 10 catches for 162 yards and two scores.

But that offensive production couldn't negate a stack of defensive penalties. The Auggies committed 12 penalties for 117 yards in all.

"We lost momentum with the penalties," said Winford, who picked up a personal foul while playing cornerback. "Penalties kill drives."

The first half ended in a 28-28 tie after a wacky 30 minutes that included three goal-line touchdown catches -- Al-Hameed caught two of them and Carleton's Dylan Bothun caught another -- that might have been reversed with the help of instant replay. The entertaining game, played in front of an announced crowd of 4,000, saw the teams alternate scoring 10 touchdowns up until the Knights recovered their onside kick.

Lien, a freshman, ran for 168 yards on 25 carries and scored twice for Carleton. Shane Henfling added 266 passing yards and four touchdowns, even though his leading receiver, Matt Frank, missed the game because of a separated shoulder.

Carleton was picked to finish eighth in the conference in a preseason poll. Henfling admitted that his team's No. 1 conference ranking is hard to believe.

"It feels great obviously, but I can't say whether or not I expected it at the beginning of the year," Henfling said. "Luckily, we came out on top so far. We just gotta keep it going."

Recent Sports stories

ITF president says hefty fine — not ban — likely for Serena Williams over US Open tirade - October 12, 2008

ITF president says hefty fine — not ban — likely for Serena Williams over US Open tirade - Top-ranked Serena Williams will most likely receive a "significant" fine but no suspension for her U.S. Open tirade, the president of the International Tennis Federation said. More