Supporters don't want 1A hockey to be a class dismissed

  • Article by: JIM PAULSEN , Star Tribune
  • Updated: March 4, 2014 - 10:24 PM

Often maligned or ignored, the Class 1A state tournament serves a noble and needed purpose, its supporters point out.


Scott Wasbotten (23) celebrated his goal in the second period during the 2013 Class 1A boys' hockey tournament in St. Paul.

Photo: Carlos Gonzalez, Star Tribune

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

Luverne coach Derrick Brown saw this coming as hockey was beginning to take a skate-hold on Minnesota’s southwestern corner. It showed in the youth ranks.

A little patience and whole lot of hope later, what once seemed like stargazing became reality when the Cardinals, in only their 12th year in existence, joined an exclusive club by qualifying for the boys’ hockey state tournament.

“We’d been breaking through for a while,” Brown said. “But it’s a special feeling to actually get to the state tournament.”

It’s a tale certainly worth telling, but it comes with a caveat: Luverne, sporting a 27-0-1 record, will make its debut in the Class 1A bracket of smaller schools. Those teams gained entry after the Minnesota State High School League added a second class in 1992 and, to many hockey fans, messed with perfection by diluting a national high school sports showcase.

To those pining for the old days, Brown said, “This is about growing hockey in this part of the state. Hockey is all about numbers. It’s not realistic for us to try to compete with Edina. But in Class 1A, we don’t have to.”

The Class 1A tournament, which begins Wednesday at Xcel Energy Center, has all the trappings of the Class 2A show, but it lacks the fan interest. It never sells out and draws about one-third of the fans. While it can spawn hopes of a Hoosiers-type of run, in which the little guys rise up and smite the behemoths, it rarely happens.

When the tournament has drawn media attention of late, it’s been aimed at why perennial power St. Thomas Academy was playing in the tournament at all. The Cadets moved up to Class 2A this season.

Bloomington Kennedy coach Dave Dillon used to think that Class 2A was the only way to go. But the reality of the Eagles’ situation changed his mind. Dwindling participation numbers had eaten away at the program. There always was a core of dedicated kids, just not enough to stay competitive with their large suburban brethren.

“This year, we had 26, 27 players try out,” Dillon said. “That’s less than some schools cut. I wanted to stay in Class 2A as long as we could, to see if we could turn the program around and compete, but we were on life support.”

The Eagles dropped to Class 1A this season and made it to the Section 2 semifinals before losing to Orono in overtime. The hope that came with their best playoff showing in years has resulted in a huge payoff, Dillon said.

“This was the shot in the arm we needed,” he said. “People are excited again. If this hadn’t happened, we’d have been a cooperative in a few years, I’m sure.”

Paul Gibson, coach of tournament-entrant Chisago Lakes, agreed. His Wildcats are making their first appearance since 1995. Gibson said he has yet to encounter a supporter who isn’t giddy about it.

“For those who think it means less, you haven’t been in our community for the last week and seen the energy this has created and the renewed optimism this has brought to our youth program,” he said.

“The two-class system provides more teams to experience the excitement of a state tournament atmosphere.”

Luverne belongs

Often, first-timers to tournament have been given a boost by a pocketful of luck in the section playoffs, perhaps an early round upset or a goalie doing handstands while stopping pucks.

That’s not the case for Luverne, a school of 308 students. There were no lucky breaks. This one was earned.

Seven players have 35 or more points. Sophomore wing Chaz Smedsrud has 87 points, senior Logan Norman has 71 and eighth-grade wunderkind Jaxon Nelson has 70. Speedy junior defenseman Toby Sengvongxay a skill set that has him on a path to play in the Elite League next fall. Goalie Kendall Meyer has been a rock.

  • related content

  • 1A wonderlandThen of Warroad, U.S. Olympic star T.J. Oshie’s heroics in the Class 1A boys’ hockey state tournament are among our memorable moments. C6On A1: Tournament has lost some luster • Coming Thursday: Class 2A preview

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


Cleveland 45 3rd Qtr
Indiana 51
Washington 42 2nd Qtr 0:06
Philadelphia 47
Golden State 27 2nd Qtr
Toronto 11
New York 23 2nd Qtr 10:32
Detroit 32
Orlando 16 2nd Qtr 11:41
Atlanta 28
Charlotte 26 2nd Qtr 8:57
Boston 31
LA Clippers 7:00 PM
Brooklyn 7:00 PM
Miami 7:00 PM
New Orleans
Minnesota 7:00 PM
Utah 8:00 PM
San Antonio 9:00 PM
Milwaukee 9:30 PM
LA Lakers
Oklahoma City 9:30 PM
Boston 1 2nd Prd 12:01
New Jersey 0
Calgary 0 2nd Prd 14:10
NY Islanders 1
Washington 0 2nd Prd 18:07
Carolina 1
Chicago 0 1st Prd 4:27
Tampa Bay 0
Colorado 7:30 PM
Los Angeles 9:00 PM
Siena 58 2nd Half 1:58
Quinnipiac 73
Harvard 39 2nd Half 5:00
Cornell 42
Penn 30 2nd Half 18:03
Brown 44
Fairfield 34 2nd Half
Canisius 34
Manhattan 35 2nd Half
Iona 41
Saint Peters 25 2nd Half
Marist 43
Princeton 35 2nd Half
Yale 32
Ohio 0 1st Half 20:00
Akron 0
Dartmouth 7:00 PM
Valparaiso 9:00 PM
Cleveland State
Louisiana Tech 75 FINAL
Texas-El Paso 88
Seton Hall 50 2nd Half 15:54
Xavier 31
Cornell 27 2nd Half
Harvard 23
Yale 18 2nd Half 18:15
(14) Princeton 40
Elon 27 2nd Half 15:28
Drexel 35
Northeastern 25 2nd Half
James Madison 36
St Johns 30 2nd Half 20:00
Butler 19
Creighton 45 2nd Half 15:19
Georgetown 38
Brown 27 2nd Half
Penn 36
Columbia 18 2nd Half
Dartmouth 28
Canisius 24 2nd Half
Siena 23
St Josephs Brooklyn 17 1st Half 0:45
Western Carolina 45 2nd Half
UNC Greensboro 33
Colorado 7 1st Half 16:15
Arizona 3
Southern Ill 7:00 PM
Drake 0 1st Half 20:00
Wichita State 0
Indiana State 0 1st Half 16:16
Evansville 8
Illinois State 7:05 PM
Northern Iowa 7:05 PM
Missouri State
Utah 7:30 PM
(10) Arizona State
Providence 7:30 PM


question of the day

Poll: With Adrian Peterson's suspension overturned, what should the Vikings do?

Weekly Question





Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters