One hot topic: Just how good is Geno Smith?
The hot topic: Just how good is Geno Smith?
Let’s face it. This was going to be a tough year for quarterbacks regardless. After the 2012 draft provided the 1-2 combo of Andrew Luck and Robert Griffin III plus third-round gem Russell Wilson, the bar was raised significantly for what rookie quarterbacks should be capable of achieving.
Luck, RG3 and Wilson all reached the playoffs in 2012, providing a lot to live up to. But now there’s endless debate on whether any of the quarterbacks available this year can be long-term answers in the NFL.
Enter Smith, the 22-year-old out of West Virginia, who has become the most coveted of this bunch. Early last season, he emerged as a Heisman Trophy front-runner with a video-game statistical blitz that was highlighted by his 656-yard, eight-touchdown effort in a 70-point explosion against Baylor. But a five-game West Virginia losing streak soon after quelled the buzz.
Now as pre-draft analysis has circulated, the Smith discussion heated up last month when Pro Football Weekly skewered his lack of work ethic and leadership, asserting those deficiencies would kill Smith’s chances of ever excelling in the NFL.
Those concerns do not seem to be widespread. But they became debate-worthy.
In a league where elite quarterback play is a prerequisite for high-level success, some organization will make a play to nab Smith early, possibly even in the top five. But will that investment be worth it?
Geno Smith, West Virginia
There’s a lot to love, namely Smith’s prototypical size, quick delivery, strong arm and ability to make plays with his feet. But then comes the obvious worry about whether his production in the Mountaineers’ spread offense was a mirage. How’s this for risk-reward? Best-case scenario: Smith showcases all the eye-catching skills of Sam Bradford. Fear: He’s Jason Campbell 2.0.
Matt Barkley, Southern California
Did Matt Kalil’s presence at left tackle make that much difference? In 2011 with Kalil, Barkley had a .691 completion percentage while passing for 3,528 yards and 39 TDs with seven interceptions. Following that surge, he was touted as a top-10 pick. In 2012, his numbers dipped (.636 completion percentage, 3,273 yards, 36 TDs, 15 picks) and so did his draft stock. With the right system, his promise should return.
Ryan Nassib, Syracuse
He is polished fundamentally and can be highly efficient when dialed in. His rocket arm has enabled him to rise up draft boards. Nassib doesn’t seem to have a glaring weakness, though he can be erratic with his accuracy at times.
E.J. Manuel, Florida State
His combination of size (6-5, 237 pounds) and mobility is a major plus. Manuel tested very well at the combine. He can throw deep or into tight windows and has the skills to dabble in the read-option fad if asked to do so. His intelligence and charisma also are positives.
Sean Renfree, Duke
Don’t think Renfree’s four years with Duke coach David Cutcliffe didn’t heighten his football intellect. Cutcliffe’s wisdom is so magnetic he remains a confidant to Peyton and Eli Manning, both of whom he coached in college. Renfree might not have Manning-level upside. But he does possess similar passion and could develop into a reliable backup.
|Boston - WP: M. Ott||4||FINAL|
|Minnesota - LP: M. Hoffman||3|
|San Francisco||4||Top 6th Inning|
|Colorado||2||Top 3rd Inning|
|LA Lakers||46||3rd Qtr|
|Toronto||0||1st Prd 10:27|
|UC Santa Barbara||38|
|San Diego St||73|
|Utah Valley U||83|
|Cal State Fullerton||56||FINAL|
|Long Beach State||66|
|Sam Houston St||70|
|Eastern Mich||60||2nd Half 2:47|
|CS-Bakersfield||61||2nd Half 2:40|
|Rhode Island||56||2nd Half 2:25|
|Portland State||65||2nd Half 0:40|
|Fresno State||68||2nd Half 3:57|
|Northwestern||66||2nd Half 0:17|
|Miss State||54||2nd Half 12:37|
|Georgia Tech||44||2nd Half 10:27|
|ULM||51||2nd Half 8:07|
|Marquette||46||2nd Half 11:43|
|West Virginia||22||2nd Half 13:57|
|Memphis||31||2nd Half 18:43|
|Charlotte||19||1st Half 7:16|
|Boise State||10:30 PM|
|New Mexico St|
|Miss Valley St||68||FINAL|
|(22) Middle Tennessee||69|
|William & Mary||65|
|Old Dominion||52||2nd Half 9:36|
Poll: How many games will the Gophers win in the Big Ten tournament?