Chip Scoggins: Another Cadets title re-ignites private vs. public debate

  • Article by: CHIP SCOGGINS , Star Tribune
  • Updated: March 9, 2013 - 10:09 PM

St. Thomas Academy won its third Class 1A title in a row before bumping up to 2A next year, but the controversial ending ignited more private vs. public school debates.


Matt Perry (23) of St. Thomas Academy celebrated after scoring in the third period. It was Perry's third goal of the game. St. Thomas Academy beat Hermantown by a final score 5-4.

Photo: Carlos Gonzalez, Star Tribune

CameraStar Tribune photo galleries

Cameraview larger

Bruce Plante can’t stand the private school philosophy. He didn’t like it before Saturday and he likes it even less now.

The Hermantown hockey coach probably will even help the St. Thomas Academy Cadets pack their bags before they shove off for Class 2A, their rightful new home starting next season.

The public school vs. private school debate raged after the Cadets defeated Hermantown 5-4 in the Class 1A boys’ hockey championship game for a third consecutive season, thanks to a third-period rally and winning goal by sophomore Tommy Novak with 6.1 seconds left in regulation.

The Cadets became the first boys’ team to three-peat since Bloomington Jefferson’s 1992-94 run, and they left their legion of critics seething with a final exclamation point that fanned the flames of those who believe the private-school powerhouse has no business playing small-school hockey. That St. Thomas Academy benefitted from questionable officiating late and Hermantown didn’t was the equivalent of throwing a match into a gasoline can.

“It makes you feel like you’re getting homered,” Plante said. “It stinks.”

No topic in Minnesota high school hockey circles stirs as much emotion as private schools. Diplomatic peace talks have a better chance at civility than a high school game between private and public schools.

St. Thomas Academy has long served as a villain in that conversation because of the school’s insistence on remaining at the 1A level. The school had that prerogative based on enrollment figures, but the Cadets also enjoyed the best of both worlds: They could recruit top players and play 2A teams during the regular season and then collect trophies against weaker competition in the tournament. They outscored their opponents 28-4 in this tournament.

School officials finally made the right call in December by announcing a move next season to Class 2A, which is where they belong based on their stature and built-in advantages. They should test themselves against the big boys. Plus, this move gives their players a chance to receive proper credit for success without having to apologize for it. State championships should be celebrated, not mocked.

“There’s a lot of pressure, more from the outside,” co-coach Greg Vannelli said. “You’re not human if you don’t recognize that it’s going on.”

Plante hasn’t masked his thoughts on the matter. The veteran coach has railed against private schools before and he spoke his mind again after his team lost to a private school in the championship game for a fourth consecutive season.

“I have nothing against the Vannellis,” Plante said of Greg and his brother/co-coach Tom. “They’re great coaches. I don’t buy into this private school philosophy, that’s all. I don’t think you should be able to get kids from Wisconsin and Missouri and all over Minnesota and make a team. I just don’t agree with that. I don’t think it’s right, and I certainly don’t think they should be in single-A hockey.

“This year, I had nine parents of kids that wanted to move to Hermantown and play for us. You know what I told them? Stay there and play with your kids and do your best there and make everyone in your community proud. That’s just my philosophy. It’s not personal. I don’t believe they should be able to get all the kids from wherever and then come here. And we have to compete against that? Come on. Plus, it kills other programs. You finally get a couple of good players and off they go to a private school. It doesn’t feel good to me, it doesn’t feel right.”

Greg Vannelli declined to get into a verbal sparring match.

“We have a different philosophy than he does,” he said. “If I lose, I just say, ‘Congratulations to the other team and I have to get better.’ He likes to go at St. Thomas and say [that] because we win, we’re supposed to move up and there’s no way they could beat us. I just disagree with that philosophy.”

Hermantown had its chances. The Hawks played hard and tough and led 4-2 entering the final period. But they lost their lead and left themselves vulnerable to a controversial finish, which started when Scott Wasbotten received a holding penalty with 1:57 remaining. In the final flurry, the Cadets’ Alex Johnson grabbed Jake Zeleznikar in what the Hermantown player called a “headlock” as he went to retrieve the puck, but the officials did not call a penalty. Novak buried the winner on a slapshot a few seconds later.

An irate Plante confronted the officials on the ice after the game. His face was still red 30 minutes later as he addressed reporters.

“I will never forget this one,” he said.

Neither will anyone else.

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


Toronto - LP: D. Hutchison 2 FINAL
NY Yankees - WP: M. Tanaka 5
Washington - WP: S. Strasburg 2 FINAL
Miami - LP: N. Eovaldi 1
NY Mets - WP: J. deGrom 10 FINAL
Atlanta - LP: E. Santana 2
Boston - WP: J. Kelly 3 FINAL
Baltimore - LP: M. Gonzalez 2
Milwaukee - LP: W. Peralta 0 FINAL
Pittsburgh - WP: V. Worley 1
Chicago WSox - WP: J. Danks 10 FINAL
Tampa Bay - LP: N. Karns 5
Cleveland - WP: C. Kluber 7 FINAL
Minnesota - LP: A. Swarzak 2
Detroit - LP: R. Porcello 2 FINAL
Kansas City - WP: J. Guthrie 5
Seattle - LP: H. Iwakuma 3 FINAL
Houston - WP: C. McHugh 8
Los Angeles - WP: C. Perez 8 FINAL
Chicago Cubs - LP: J. Turner 5
Texas - WP: S. Tolleson 2 FINAL
LA Angels - LP: H. Street 1
Philadelphia - LP: M. Gonzalez 6 FINAL
Oakland - WP: S. Doolittle 8
San Francisco - LP: R. Vogelsong 2 FINAL
San Diego - WP: I. Kennedy 8
Arizona - LP: W. Miley 3 FINAL
Colorado - WP: C. Bergman 8
Cincinnati - WP: A. Simon 7 FINAL
St. Louis - LP: L. Lynn 2
San Diego 22 FINAL
Buffalo 10
Dallas 34 FINAL
St. Louis 31
Washington 34 FINAL
Philadelphia 37
Houston 17 FINAL
NY Giants 30
Minnesota 9 FINAL
New Orleans 20
Tennessee 7 FINAL
Cincinnati 33
Baltimore 23 FINAL
Cleveland 21
Green Bay 7 FINAL
Detroit 19
Indianapolis 44 FINAL
Jacksonville 17
Oakland 9 FINAL
New England 16
San Francisco 14 FINAL
Arizona 23
Denver 20 FINAL
Seattle 26
Kansas City 34 FINAL
Miami 15
Pittsburgh 37 FINAL
Carolina 19
Chicago 9/22/14 7:30 PM
NY Jets
NY Giants 9/25/14 7:25 PM
Columbus 4 FINAL
Carolina 3
Buffalo 0 FINAL
Washington 1
St. Louis 3 FINAL
Columbus 4
Calgary 1 FINAL
Edmonton 3
Edmonton 0 FINAL
Calgary 1
Old Dominion 45 FINAL
Rice 42
Troy 0 FINAL
(12) Georgia 66
Georgia Tech 27 FINAL
Virginia Tech 24
Eastern Mich 14 FINAL
(9) Michigan State 73
Iowa 24 FINAL
Pittsburgh 20
Bowling Green 17 FINAL
(19) Wisconsin 68
Maryland 34 FINAL
Syracuse 20
Tulane 13 FINAL
Duke 47
Hawaii 12 FINAL
Colorado 21
Marshall 48 FINAL
Akron 17
North Carolina 41 FINAL
(23) East Carolina 70
Army 21 FINAL
Wake Forest 24
Virginia 33 FINAL
(20) BYU 41
(6) Texas A&M 58 FINAL
Rutgers 31 FINAL
Navy 24
Central Mich 10 FINAL
Kansas 24
Utah 26 FINAL
Michigan 10
Florida 21 FINAL
(3) Alabama 42
Louisville 34 FINAL
Fla Atlantic 19 FINAL
Wyoming 20
Indiana 31 FINAL
Missouri 27
San Jose St 7 FINAL
Minnesota 24
Texas State 35 FINAL
Illinois 42
Massachusetts 7 FINAL
Penn State 48
Georgia State 14 FINAL
Washington 45
Appalachian St 20 FINAL
Southern Miss 21
(14) Miss State 34 FINAL
(17) LSU 29
Northern Ill 14 FINAL
Arkansas 52
Middle Tennessee 17 FINAL
Memphis 36
Utah State 14 FINAL
Arkansas State 21
Miami-Ohio 24 FINAL
Cincinnati 31
Idaho 24 FINAL
Ohio U 36
Ball State 23 FINAL
Toledo 34
(13) So Carolina 48 FINAL
Vanderbilt 34
(4) Oklahoma 45 FINAL
West Virginia 33
Ga Southern 28 FINAL
South Alabama 6
Houston 47
Miami-Florida 31 FINAL
(21) Nebraska 41
New Mexico 38 FINAL
New Mexico St 35
Clemson 17 FINAL
(1) Florida State 23
California 45 FINAL
Arizona 49
San Diego St 7 FINAL
Oregon State 28
(2) Oregon 38 FINAL
Washington St 31
Louisiana 9 FINAL
Boise State 34
Texas Tech 9/25/14 6:30 PM
(24) Oklahoma State
Appalachian St 9/25/14 6:30 PM
Ga Southern
(11) UCLA 9/25/14 9:00 PM
(15) Arizona State
Middle Tennessee 9/26/14 7:00 PM
Old Dominion
Fresno State 9/26/14 7:00 PM
New Mexico
Texas-El Paso 9/27/14 11:00 AM
(25) Kansas State
Tennessee 9/27/14 11:00 AM
(12) Georgia
Vanderbilt 9/27/14 11:00 AM
Wyoming 9/27/14 11:00 AM
(9) Michigan State
Northwestern 9/27/14 11:00 AM
Penn State
TCU 9/27/14 11:00 AM
Iowa 9/27/14 11:00 AM
Tulane 9/27/14 11:00 AM
So Florida 9/27/14 11:00 AM
(19) Wisconsin
Colorado State 9/27/14 11:30 AM
Boston College
Western Mich 9/27/14 11:30 AM
Virginia Tech
Maryland 9/27/14 12:30 PM
Akron 9/27/14 12:30 PM
Bowling Green 9/27/14 2:00 PM
Arkansas 9/27/14 2:30 PM
(6) Texas A&M
Kent State 9/27/14 2:30 PM
Western Ky 9/27/14 2:30 PM
Minnesota 9/27/14 2:30 PM
Wake Forest 9/27/14 2:30 PM
FIU 9/27/14 2:30 PM
(1) Florida State 9/27/14 2:30 PM
NC State
Miami-Ohio 9/27/14 2:30 PM
Colorado 9/27/14 3:00 PM
Louisiana Tech 9/27/14 3:00 PM
(5) Auburn
Texas 9/27/14 3:00 PM
Temple 9/27/14 3:00 PM
(16) Stanford 9/27/14 3:15 PM
TX-San Antonio 9/27/14 4:00 PM
Fla Atlantic
South Alabama 9/27/14 4:00 PM
Cincinnati 9/27/14 5:00 PM
(22) Ohio State
Rice 9/27/14 6:00 PM
Southern Miss
Missouri 9/27/14 6:00 PM
(13) So Carolina
Boise State 9/27/14 6:00 PM
Air Force
North Carolina 9/27/14 6:00 PM
Central Mich 9/27/14 6:00 PM
Troy 9/27/14 6:00 PM
New Mexico St 9/27/14 6:30 PM
(17) LSU
Memphis 9/27/14 6:30 PM
(10) Ole Miss
Duke 9/27/14 6:30 PM
Texas State 9/27/14 7:00 PM
Washington St 9/27/14 7:00 PM
(8) Notre Dame 9/27/14 7:00 PM
(7) Baylor 9/27/14 7:00 PM
Iowa State
UNLV 9/27/14 7:00 PM
San Diego St
Illinois 9/27/14 8:00 PM
(21) Nebraska
Oregon State 9/27/14 9:30 PM
(18) USC
Nevada 9/27/14 9:30 PM
San Jose St
Chivas USA 0 FINAL
Toronto FC 3
Toronto 40 FINAL
Brt Columbia 23
Edmonton 23 FINAL
Hamilton 25
Calgary 15 FINAL
Montreal 31
Ottawa 32 FINAL
Saskatchewan 35


Golden Gavel by Star Tribune

Countdown to great deals

Bid Sept. 21-29




question of the day

Poll: Grade the Vikings offense

Weekly Question


Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters