Which third is charm for Vikings?

  • Article by: DAN WIEDERER , Star Tribune
  • Updated: April 26, 2012 - 5:04 PM

The Vikings like three players with the No. 3 overall pick, and might even trade the pick away. The hard part comes when making the decision.

Finally. It's over. All the tireless research and analysis, all the outside speculation and hullabaloo.

Poof. It's gone.

The NFL draft is all about action now. Finally.

Tonight, sometime around the bottom of the 7 o'clock hour, Rick Spielman will make his first selection as Vikings general manager. It's scheduled to be the first of 10 picks Spielman locks in this weekend. Yet, whoever the Vikings reel in as their choice at No. 3 will become the player by which Spielman's acumen and reasoning is widely judged -- at least in the immediate draft aftermath.

So who will it be? Left tackle Matt Kalil? Cornerback Morris Claiborne? Receiver Justin Blackmon? Or might a last-minute trade surface?

The mystery remains.

This week, the Claiborne-vs.-Kalil debate has intensified as much as any story in the draft. Those who favor the Louisiana State cornerback point out how porous the Vikings pass defense was in 2011, then also acknowledge that three standout NFC North quarterbacks all under the age of 29 will be firing bullets at the Vikings six games every year for the foreseeable future.

Man, it sure would help to have a standout cornerback to slow that blitzkrieg.

The Kalil backers' retort? Quarterbacks win Super Bowls. And unless Christian Ponder is given some peace of mind and a legitimate chance to grow in the next year or two, nothing else will ultimately matter. If Ponder fails, the Vikings will likely fail. So a standout offensive lineman is needed immediately.

Which is a legitimate argument -- even if it has been oversimplified to assume that all the pounding a young quarterback takes and all the errors he makes are directly related to the performance of his left tackle.

Somewhere along the line, a best-selling book, a horde of NFL analysts and a schmaltzy acting performance by Sandra Bullock convinced us of this supreme value of a standout left tackle.

Yet here on draft day, we decided to turn loose some of our own independent research, results of a study done to determine how many of Ponder's rookie errors were the direct result of shoddy left tackle play.

Our research was done with no preconceived notions. Instead, we ran the film back on the 43 plays in 2011 during which Ponder was either sacked, committed a turnover or both. For every one of those plays, we asked the same question: Whose fault was it?

The quick summary:

• Ponder was solely responsible for nine of his 15 turnovers and three of his sacks.

• Eight of Ponder's 13 interceptions came with no pressure in his face, often the result of his own poor decision making.

• Right tackle Phil Loadholt was at least partially responsible for eight of the 30 sacks Ponder took.

• Only four of the 30 sacks Ponder absorbed occurred by way of a right defensive end beating Vikings' left tackle Charlie Johnson 1-on-1. Poor protection from Johnson at left tackle contributed to only one other sack.

• Twenty sacks were generated by defensive tackles or blitzing linebackers and defensive backs.

• On five occasions Ponder was sacked, at least in part, because a running back missed a block.

Interpret those numbers however you'd like. And we'll readily admit that research is limited, not fully accounting for all the times Ponder was pressured or hit in 2011, becoming more and more fidgety with each encounter.

But at least understand that adding a stud left tackle like Kalil tonight, while helpful, won't suddenly give Ponder the same protection the Hope Diamond gets at the Smithsonian.

This isn't to suggest Kalil would be a foolish pick for the Vikings at No. 3. He's a fantastic talent who fills an obvious need. But Claiborne also fits that description. Blackmon, too.

Too often, we've been sucked into the draft chaos believing there is only one correct pick for a general manager to make. After all, it's not as much fun to solve a riddle with three logical answers.

But in actuality, tonight Spielman seems to face the perfect scenario for his first pick, ready to pull the trigger in what his coach, Leslie Frazier, believes is "a win-win-win" situation.

Who's the right choice for the Vikings at No. 3? There might be three of them. It all depends on which way you come at it.

Dan Wiederer • dan.wiederer@startribune.com

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions


Tampa 6 FINAL
Philadelphia 2
LA Clippers 96 FINAL
Chicago 86
Cleveland 103 FINAL
Houston 105
Golden State 106 FINAL
Boston 101
Philadelphia 74 FINAL
Indiana 94
Portland 110 FINAL
Sacramento 99
Charlotte 98 FINAL
Orlando 83
Oklahoma City 108 FINAL
LA Lakers 101
New Orleans 99 FINAL
Denver 92
Los Angeles 2 FINAL
Winnipeg 5
Tampa Bay 3 FINAL
Florida 4
Columbus 3 FINAL
Pittsburgh 5
Toronto 0 FINAL
Washington 4
Anaheim 3 FINAL
Dallas 1
St. Louis 5 FINAL(SO)
Vancouver 6
Connecticut 81
Quinnipiac 65 FINAL
Manhattan 69
Fairfield 56 FINAL
Niagara 57
Marist 49 FINAL
Rider 59
Iona 60 FINAL
Saint Peters 68
Oregon State 56 FINAL
California 73
South Florida 55 FINAL
Houston 72
Marquette 66 FINAL
Providence 77
Michigan State 61 FINAL
Wisconsin 68
Siena 57 FINAL
Monmouth 63
Pittsburgh 66 FINAL
Wake Forest 69
Oregon 73 FINAL
Stanford 70
Purdue 61 FINAL
Ohio State 65
Arizona State 81 FINAL
Colorado 87
Washington St 67 FINAL
Georgetown 66 FINAL
Providence 81
Binghamton 50 FINAL
Elon 65 FINAL
Hofstra 58
Virginia Tech 47 FINAL
Boston College 49
(8) Louisville 59 FINAL
Virginia 75
Texas 69 FINAL
West Virginia 76
Creighton 53 FINAL
Villanova 61
Seton Hall 85 FINAL
Butler 76
UNC-Wilmington 76 FINAL
Coll of Charleston 65
(5) Maryland 69 FINAL
(25) Northwestern 48
Saint Josephs 67 FINAL
La Salle 55
Louisiana Tech 53 FINAL
TX-San Antonio 60
Rhode Island 70 FINAL
Massachusetts 78
Richmond 55 FINAL
VA Commonwealth 49
Davidson 46 FINAL
Fordham 54
St Bonaventure 43 FINAL
Duquesne 51
George Mason 45 FINAL
(22) George Washington 80
Indiana 60 FINAL
(20) Rutgers 71
(12) Texas A&M 63 FINAL
LSU 80
Ole Miss 47 FINAL
(11) Miss State 55
Clemson 56 FINAL
Pittsburgh 61
Maine 47 FINAL
New Hampshire 61
Vermont 48 FINAL
Albany 76
Quinnipiac 87 FINAL
Monmouth 48
Saint Peters 47 FINAL
Siena 64
(4) Notre Dame 67 FINAL
NC State 60
Wisconsin 62 FINAL
Penn State 56
Stony Brook 49 FINAL
Hartford 56
Northeastern 47 FINAL
William & Mary 62
St Johns 61 FINAL
Xavier 74
James Madison 74 FINAL
Delaware 71
Towson 45 FINAL
Drexel 50
Illinois State 50 FINAL
Bradley 60
Southern Ill 74 FINAL
Loyola-Chicago 70
Northern Iowa 54 FINAL
Wichita State 66
Minnesota 76 FINAL
(17) Iowa 92
(15) North Carolina 80 FINAL
(16) Duke 81
Alabama 73 FINAL
Auburn 80
(9) Florida State 69 FINAL
Miami-Florida 55
Arkansas 41 FINAL
Missouri 57
Georgia 52 FINAL
Florida 45
Dayton 95 FINAL
Saint Louis 68
Drake 57 FINAL
Missouri State 86
Colorado 46 FINAL
(10) Arizona State 59
(19) Stanford 55 FINAL
Oregon 62
Marquette 82 FINAL
DePaul 99
Southern Miss 66 FINAL
Texas-El Paso 60
Vanderbilt 49 FINAL
(6) Tennessee 79
(2) South Carolina 56 FINAL
(13) Kentucky 67
Utah 41 FINAL
Arizona 64
Ohio State 78 FINAL
Nebraska 60


question of the day

Poll: With Adrian Peterson's suspension overturned, what should the Vikings do?

Weekly Question





Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters