Rand: Burn the Barn? No!

  • Article by: MICHAEL RAND , Star Tribune
  • Updated: February 9, 2012 - 7:44 AM

Officials announced plans for a "new" Fenway Park in 1999, which was to be an exact replica of the classic ballpark in Boston. But you can't duplicate 100 years of character, nor can you put a century worth of history in a moving van. In part because the "Save Fenway Park" folks were able to do what their name suggests, the old ballpark survived. It received some upgrades, played host to two World Series titles, and here we are now.

The Boston area took Randy Moss, David Ortiz and Kevin Garnett from Minnesota in recent years, enough to torture our Midwestern souls. Now, though, it is time to take something from those haughty East Coasters: The good sense to ensure that Williams Arena -- our version of Fenway, our iconic major sports venue -- lives to be at least 100 and as many years beyond it as possible.

The Barn opened in 1928, and an increasing chorus of voices have suggested it should be nearing the end of its lifespan.

"You can only play so long in any building," men's basketball coach Tubby Smith said recently. "It's like buying a new home. Do you build a new home or do you try to fix up the one you have. If it's 80 years old, then you have to decide."

The cynic in us, hardened by political maneuverings and stadium debates, wonders if talks of replacing Williams Arena are intensifying as part of a sleight-of-hand to make a new $15 million practice facility seem more palatable.

Nebraska, which opened a new (and gaudy) basketball practice facility for $18.7 million, is building an arena as well with an estimated cost of $180 million. Suddenly the cost of upgrading and fixing Williams Arena (tabbed in 2005 as a $20 million project) along with building a practice facility doesn't seem so bad.

But even if Tubby and others are sincere about this being decision-time on Williams Arena, then the choice is easy: Keep it. Fix the things that need fixing. Update what needs updating. Just leave the place fundamentally the same for as long as possible, which should be at least another generation.

If full disclosure is warranted, you should know this author is a U of M graduate who went to plenty of games at Williams Arena over the years -- though not nearly as many as countless other folks. It is mostly their nostalgia we would like to convey. It's not the misplaced kind that fears change and impedes progress at all costs, but the kind that reveres history and the hard to define sense of place that Williams Arena delivers.

Not every new building is cold and soulless -- Target Field is a prime example -- and not every old building is a monument. Williams Arena, just like Fenway, is.

The Barn isn't a relic -- it's a classic. Sure, a modern designer would never draw up plans for the way it's built. Nobody would say, "It would be great if we could put a beam in the middle of all these seats." Nobody particularly enjoys long lines, small corridors and various other quirks of a place built long before it was decided that sports venues needed to be modern movie theaters.

But that place, at its best, is loud -- almost impossibly so for opponents. The raised floor is intimidating. The simplicity focuses a fan's eyes on the court (what a concept). Even watching the players disappear down into the bowels of the locker room area only to magically reappear is an experience.

We'd say the nearly 84-year-old building speaks for itself, but just in case we asked a Williams one-fourth its age how he would feel if the arena was replaced. Rodney Williams, a local product and Gophers player who turns 21 in July, admitted that he, like so many others of his generation, can be seduced by shiny new things. But ... "Personally, I love playing here," Williams said, flashing a smile. "I wouldn't mind if they kept it."

The new athletic director replacing Joel Maturi in the coming months will have several big decisions to make and a lot of money to raise. But the new AD shouldn't overthink things when it comes to basketball. For very disparate reasons, both practical and visceral, Williams Arena needs to stay.

Not every facility needs to be a brand new palace. In this case, let's keep what is uniquely ours -- the charming old Barn.

Michael Rand • mrand@startribune.com

  • POINT/COUNTERPOINT KEEP OR SCRAP WILLIAMS ARENA?

    POINT/COUNTERPOINT KEEP OR SCRAP WILLIAMS ARENA?

  • get related content delivered to your inbox

  • manage my email subscriptions

ADVERTISEMENT

New England 2/1/15 5:30 PM
Seattle
Detroit 6:00 PM
Philadelphia
Portland 6:00 PM
Cleveland
Sacramento 6:30 PM
Toronto
Boston 7:00 PM
Minnesota
Dallas 7:00 PM
Houston
Denver 7:00 PM
New Orleans
Brooklyn 7:00 PM
Atlanta
Oklahoma City 7:00 PM
New York
Charlotte 7:30 PM
San Antonio
LA Clippers 8:00 PM
Utah
Washington 9:30 PM
Phoenix
Toronto 6:30 PM
New Jersey
Pittsburgh 7:00 PM
Washington
Chicago 9:30 PM
Los Angeles
Temple 6:00 PM
UCF
Winthrop 6:00 PM
Coastal Carolina
Lafayette 6:00 PM
Colgate
Northeastern 6:00 PM
Drexel
Wake Forest 6:00 PM
Florida State
Rhode Island 6:00 PM
Fordham
Delaware 6:00 PM
James Madison
South Carolina 6:00 PM
LSU
New Hampshire 6:00 PM
Maine
Seton Hall 6:00 PM
Marquette
Binghamton 6:00 PM
UMBC
American Univ 6:00 PM
Navy
Elon 6:00 PM
UNC-Wilmington
Wright State 6:00 PM
Oakland
Minnesota 6:00 PM
Penn State
Duquesne 6:00 PM
Richmond
SMU 6:00 PM
South Florida
Hartford 6:00 PM
Stony Brook
Albany 6:00 PM
Vermont
Hofstra 6:00 PM
William & Mary
UNC-Asheville 6:00 PM
Longwood
Radford 6:30 PM
Char Southern
Holy Cross 0 Postponed
Loyola-Maryland 0
Duke 6:30 PM
Notre Dame
Texas Tech 6:30 PM
Oklahoma
Oregon State 7:00 PM
Arizona State
Morehead State 7:00 PM
Austin Peay
Drake 7:00 PM
Bradley
Lehigh 7:00 PM
Bucknell
Rice 7:00 PM
Houston
Missouri State 7:00 PM
Illinois State
Loyola-Chicago 7:00 PM
Wichita State
Nebraska Omaha 7:00 PM
South Dakota St
Northern Iowa 7:05 PM
Southern Ill
Louisville 8:00 PM
Boston College
St Johns 8:00 PM
Creighton
East Carolina 8:00 PM
Memphis
Georgia Tech 8:00 PM
Miami-Florida
Miss State 8:00 PM
Ole Miss
Clemson 8:00 PM
NC State
Indiana 8:00 PM
Purdue
Kansas 8:00 PM
TCU
Oregon 9:00 PM
Arizona
Air Force 9:00 PM
San Jose St
Stanford 10:00 PM
Washington
Rider 56 FINAL
Siena 49
Dayton 76 FINAL
Richmond 62
Eastern Kentucky 53 FINAL
Jacksonville St 73
Saint Josephs 0 Postponed
Saint Louis 0
UMBC 6:00 PM
Binghamton
Akron 6:00 PM
Ohio U
Ball State 6:00 PM
Miami-Ohio
Memphis 6:00 PM
Cincinnati
East Carolina 6:00 PM
(2) Connecticut
Murray State 6:00 PM
Eastern Illinois
Kent State 6:00 PM
Central Michigan
UT Martin 6:00 PM
Tennessee St
Eastern Michigan 6:00 PM
Western Mich
Bucknell 6:00 PM
Lehigh
Indiana 6:00 PM
Michigan State
Colgate 6:00 PM
Lafayette
Fordham 6:00 PM
Davidson
Duquesne 6:00 PM
St Bonaventure
George Mason 6:00 PM
VA Commonwealth
Detroit 6:00 PM
Youngstown St
Army 0 Postponed
Boston U 0
Loyola-Maryland 0 Postponed
Holy Cross 0
SMU 7:00 PM
Tulsa
Oklahoma St 7:00 PM
Kansas State
West Virginia 7:00 PM
Texas Tech
Denver 7:00 PM
South Dakota
Northwestern St 7:00 PM
Central Arkansas
Austin Peay 7:00 PM
SIU-Edwardsville
Kansas 7:00 PM
Iowa State
Bowling Green 7:00 PM
Northern Ill
Penn State 7:00 PM
Minnesota
San Jose St 8:00 PM
Air Force
Boise State 8:00 PM
Colorado State
Utah State 8:00 PM
Wyoming
San Diego State 9:00 PM
Fresno State
Nevada 9:00 PM
UNLV

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: What chance does the Wild have of making the playoffs?

Weekly Question

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Connect with twitterConnect with facebookConnect with Google+Connect with PinterestConnect with PinterestConnect with RssfeedConnect with email newsletters

ADVERTISEMENT

 
Close