Sid Hartman: They couldn't win with Boston; they won't win here

  • Article by: Sid Hartman , Star Tribune
  • Updated: August 5, 2007 - 2:50 AM

The Wolves roster has seven former Celtics and no Kevin Garnett, and it's difficult to project any success for them.

  • share

    email

This past season, the Boston Celtics won 24 games, the second-worst record in the NBA. Only the Memphis Grizzles won fewer.

In 2005-06, the Celtics won 33 games and finished third in the Eastern Division's Atlantic Division.

Now that the Kevin Garnett trade has been officially announced, and with Troy Hudson's contract being bought out, the Wolves have 16 players on their roster. Seven of those players came from a perennial losing Celtics team.

The former Celtics now on the Wolves include Ricky Davis and Mark Blount, who came here in the January 2006 trade for Wally Szczerbiak, and the five who have been acquired now -- Al Jefferson, Ryan Gomes, Gerald Green, Sebastian Telfair and Theo Ratliff.

Two other players who came from Boston in the Szczerbiak deal, Justin Reed (traded to Houston) and Marcus Banks (signed as a free agent with Phoenix), are no longer with the Wolves, otherwise there might be nine former losing Celtics on the roster.

These players couldn't win in Boston, where they played alongside a superstar in Paul Pierce, much like the Wolves couldn't win the past few years despite having a superstar in Garnett.

You wonder what makes owner Glen Taylor and VP Kevin McHale believe they can win here with the nucleus that makes up the Wolves now. The five players acquired from Boston on Tuesday join a team made up of Davis, Blount, Randy Foye, Marko Jaric, Trenton Hassell, Juwan Howard, Mark Madsen, Rashad McCants, Craig Smith and rookies Corey Brewer and Chris Richard.

Some deals will have to be made, or a free agent or two who can play need to be added, otherwise this Wolves team will not match last year's 32 victories.

Forced trade

There is no doubt that in the end, Garnett forced a trade because he was convinced Taylor wanted to get rid of him by shopping him all over this offseason.

Garnett and McHale have been on odds for some time. Garnett has gone public with his dissatisfaction over the ability of the Wolves ownership and front office to make the team competitive.

Garnett made that pretty clear with some of his statements Tuesday, praising the Celtics organization and talking about how uncomfortable he was losing a lot of games in the past few years.

The McHale-Garnett problems started when coach Flip Saunders was fired in February 2005, and Garnett's relationship with Taylor didn't get any better when there was all the publicity on the Internet and in the newspapers about Garnett being shopped around prior to the NBA draft this past June.

McHale has played such a big part in Garnett becoming a superstar, and it was sad at the end that they weren't communicating.

In the end, Taylor was forced to trade Garnett even though I don't think he wanted to.

There was an interesting statement Garnett made at the Boston news conference about always being loyal to somebody when that person was loyal to him. He appeared uncomfortable and nervous and said he didn't want to leave Minnesota. He also said he will always have a home in Minnesota.

Some positives

Sure, there are some positives to the trade.

  • share

    email

ADVERTISEMENT

LA Lakers 88 FINAL
Boston 87
Golden State 109 FINAL
Denver 101
Houston 96 FINAL
Phoenix 89
Oklahoma City 101 FINAL
Sacramento 106
St. Louis 4 FINAL(SO)
New Jersey 3
Montreal 4 FINAL
NY Islanders 2
Tampa Bay 3 FINAL(OT)
NY Rangers 4
Toronto 3 FINAL
Philadelphia 4
Winnipeg 3 FINAL(SO)
Washington 2
Dallas 4 FINAL
Columbus 2
Nashville 3 FINAL
Ottawa 4
Los Angeles 1 FINAL
Florida 3
Vancouver 5 FINAL
Minnesota 2
Calgary 1 FINAL(OT)
Phoenix 2
(21) Wisconsin 68 FINAL
Minnesota 61
Ole Miss 60 FINAL
(20) Miss State 70
Illinois 71 FINAL
(23) Indiana 84
Tennessee St 72 FINAL
(9) Murray State 68
(16) St Marys-CA 59 FINAL
Gonzaga 73
Old Dominion 63 FINAL
(12) Delaware 76
Wisconsin 54 FINAL
(18) Penn State 69
(5) Duke 71 FINAL
Boston College 62
(8) Maryland 91 FINAL
Clemson 61
Detroit 70 FINAL
(9) Green Bay 58
(10) Ohio State 65 FINAL
Illinois 66
(24) South Carolina 47 FINAL
Arkansas 68
Michigan 63 FINAL
(13) Nebraska 52
U-S-C 52 FINAL
(4) Stanford 69
(19) Gonzaga 40 FINAL
B-Y-U 70
(11) Tennessee 79 FINAL
Vanderbilt 93

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

question of the day

Poll: I think Williams Arena...

Weekly Question
 
Close